Showing posts with label Peace. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peace. Show all posts

Peace Talks Reach Stalemate As Kerry Frames Outline For Final Agreement

In the framework of the Palestinian reconciliation talks, and just days after a Fatah delegation arrived to the Gaza Strip to meet Hamas leaders, Hamas issued a statement, on Saturday, calling upon Fatah to withdraw from negotiations with the Israeli occupation without further delay, in light of information leaked about US Secretary of State John Kerry’s framework agreement.

In the statement issued by Dr. Sami Abu Zuhri, in the name of Hamas, the Islamic movement declares that Kerry’s plans would lead to a liquidation of the Palestine cause. Abu Zuhri added that Fatah should stop adopting unilateral decisions concerning fateful issues, the Alternative Information Center (AIC) has reported.

The statement by Hamas comes on the backdrop of diplomatic declarations made by Israeli, American and Palestinian leaders during the meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.

John Kerry outlined several U.S. principles for a negotiated solution of the core issues, during a public address on Friday. According to Kerry’s outline, the negotiations should lead to an independent Palestinian state and to security arrangements for Israel. Moreover, Kerry outlined that negotiations should also lead to a just and agreed solution to the Palestinian refugee issue, to an end of the conflict and all claims and to mutual recognition of the nation-state of the Palestinian people and the nation-state of the Jewish people.

Kerry added that he is working with Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas on a framework for negotiations that would include those principles for the core issues.

On the other hand, the Israeli prime minister, speaking in Hebrew to Israeli journalists, said that he will not evacuate West Bank settlements. This statement was made amid three separate meetings he held with Kerry.
Share:

World leaders decry the latest Israeli move but will do nothing against their Zionist Masters


zionist-octo-bad1World leaders have expressed regret and disappointment after Israel announced it would not extend the 10-month moratorium on new settler homes in the West Bank.

Israeli settlers resumed building across the West Bank on Monday, after the partial freeze on construction expired, but there was widespread praise for Palestinians, who held back on threats to quit peace talks over the move.
"We are disappointed, but remain focused on our long term objectives," Philip Crowley, the US state department spokesman, said.
"One way or the other the parties have to find a way to continue direct negotiations."
UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon reminded Israel on Monday that the building of settlements on occupied territory was illegal, and said he was "disappointed" by the government's failure to extend its partial ban on further West Bank construction.
European leaders were unanimous in their concern at the Israeli decision, and warned that the Middle East peace talks could founder on the issue.
William Hague, Britain's foreign secretary, said he was "very disappointed" and would personally pass on his appeal to Avigdor Lieberman, the Israeli Foreign Minister, at the UN General Assembly in New York.
Ahmet Davutoglu, Turkey's foreign minister, joined the growing international chorus against Israel, saying that its one-time ally was not showing signs that it wanted peace.
'Settlement must stop'
Nicolas Sarkozy, the French president, sharing a joint press conference with Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, expressed his "regret that the unanimous calls for the moratorium on Israeli settlement building to be extended were not listened to. I deplore this."
He said that the 10-month freeze "should have been extended to give negotiation a chance. I say this in front of president Abbas: 
'settlement must stop'."
The French leader said he would ask Abbas, Binyamin Netanyahu, Israel's prime minister, and Hosni Mubarak, Egypt's president, to peace talks by the end of October.
"We will not have any quick reactions," Abbas said at the news conference.
"After this chain of meetings, we will be able to put out a position that clarifies the Palestinian and Arab opinion on this issue now that Israel has refused to freeze settlements."
Direct Israeli-Palestinian talks resumed in September after a 20-month hiatus, under the auspices of the United States but without fellow peace Quartet members the EU, Russia and the United Nations.
Jacky Rowland, Al Jazeera's correspondent in Paris, said Abbas' call for an extension on the moratorium appeared a 
"desperate measure".
"This really is the bottom line ... for President Abbas, he needs some kind of gesture in order for him to to be able to argue to his own public that there is any point at all to continue with this process.
"Otherwise [he] is left entirely exposed - how can he justify to his own constituency that he is going to continue with these talks with the Israelis while flagrantly building is continuing?"
Meanwhile, Netanyahu called on Abbas not to abandon the peace talks after the freeze expired at midnight on Sunday.
"I call on president Abbas to continue with the good and honest talks we have just embarked upon, in an attempt to reach a historic peace agreement between our two peoples," Netanyahu said after allowing the partial moratorium on settlement construction to lapse.
However Khaled Meshaal, the exiled leader of Hamas, called on Abbas to uphold his promise and quit the talks.
"I call on my brothers at the Palestinian Authority, who had stated they would not pursue talks with the enemy [Israel] if it continued settlement construction, to hold to their promise," he said on Monday.
"To negotiate without a position of strength is absurd," he added.
Settlers' rally
The moratorium ended as the United States urged Israel to extend the freeze, urging a compromise over the end of the ban.
As the freeze ended, around 2,000 people, including hundreds from Netanyahu's own right wing Likud party and a large contingent of flag-waving evangelical Christians, flooded into Revava settlement in the northern West Bank for a rally.
Standing in front of a stage draped with a huge banner emblazoned with the slogan "We salute the pioneers of Judaea and Samaria," the crowds counted down from 10 to zero as the sun set over the hills.
Earlier, settlers laid the cornerstone for a new nursery school in the nearby settlement of Kiryat Netafim in an event organised by Danon, a political hardliner but not a settler himself.
But settlers conceded that despite the symbolic displays, there was unlikely to be a flood of construction.
"We are getting back to business as usual and building but we will respect the prime minister's request," said David Ha'ivri, head of the Samaria regional council.
Jewish settlement on occupied Palestinian land is one of the bitterest aspects of the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians.
Currently, around 500,000 Israelis live in more than 120 settlements across the West Bank and east Jerusalem, territories the Palestinians want for their promised state.
A previous round of direct talks collapsed in December 2008 when Israel launched a war on the Gaza Strip.
Share:

Israel: We want no-peace nor Palestinian State

Netanyahu-state-palestine-speech (Pal Telegraph)-

Binyamin Netanyahu, Israel's prime minister, has warned the Palestinian leadership against any attempts to unilaterally declare statehood for the Gaza Strip, the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem. West Bank-based Palestinian officials said on Sunday that they were preparing to ask the United Nations Security Council to declare their backing for the Palestinian quest for an independent state.

In a radio address on Sunday evening, Netanyahu said: "There is no substitute for negotiations between Israel and the Palestinian Authority.

"Any unilateral action would only unravel the framework of agreements between us and can only lead to one-sided steps on the part of Israel."

Netanyahu did not specify what "steps" Israel could take, but Israeli legal experts have said that if the Palestinians were to move forward on their own then Israel could cancel interim peace accords.

"Israel could say there has been such a gross and major violation that the agreement itself is no longer in force," Robbie Sabel, a former legal adviser to Israel's foreign ministry, told The Associated Press news agency.

'Defining moment'

Interim accords agreed by the two sides set up a system of interlocking administrations that falls far short of peaceful relations but brings some order to issues like Palestinian imports and exports, tax collection, utilities and security co-operation.

The Palestinian Authority, which is led by Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian president, is itself is a product of the interim accords.

Saeb Erekat, the chief Palestinian negotiator, said that the Palestinians had decided to turn to the UN due to frustration at the lack of progress peace talks, which have been stalled since Israel launched 22-day offensive in Gaza last December.

"Now is our defining moment. We went into this peace process in order to achieve a two-state solution," the Associated Press news agency quoted him as saying.

"The endgame is to tell the Israelis that now the international community has recognised the two-state solution on the '67 borders."

Israel captured and occupied larges areas of the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem after the 1967 Middle East war, and the Palestinians want to form their state based on the borders agreed by a ceasefire before then.

"They are not looking for a unilateral declaration of independence, they have already done that on November 15, 1988," Al Jazeera's Nour Odeh, reporting from Ramallah, said.

"What they want is something a lot more concrete," she said.

"They know it won't immediately result in the withdrawal of Israeli occupation troops from their territory, but they want the Israelis to stand in front of an international collective will that says this is what needs to be done in order for peace to be realised."

Stalled talks

Barack Obama, the US president, has been trying to restart talks between Abbas and Netanyahu since the US leader took office in January.

But the efforts have been hindered by the issue of illegal Israeli settlement construction in the occupied West Bank. Abbas has demanded a freeze in the construction before the resumption of negotiations.

Mohammed Dahlan, a senior official in Abbas's Fatah faction, said on Sunday that the UN initiative would be "a real test of the intentions of the international community".

"We are now leading a diplomatic battle," he said. "If the American administration does not agree, that will be another setback."

If the Security Council does not approve the measure, Dahlan said other options include a unilateral declaration of statehood and "popular, comprehensive resistance against settlement and the occupation".

Salam Fayyad, the Palestinian prime minister, who in June set a goal of establishing the institutions of a state within two years, said it was time for the international community to take responsibility for "the mission of ending the occupation".

"This is the responsibility of the international community and when we talk about that and international law, of course we are talking about the United Nations," he said in Ramallah.

'Major shift'

Marwan Bishara, Al Jazeera's senior political analyst, said: "Everyone knows this will not go to the Security Council without the green light from the US.

"If the US gives the green light, it means the relations between the US and Israel are in trouble.

"The US and Israel have avoided the Security Council for more than 16 years. To go back to it today, would be a major shift, a game changer in the diplomatic process.

"All Palestinians would be quite excited. Everyone, on all various levels, feels betrayed by a process that delivered not much after 16 years and seven agreements with the Israelis while quadrupling the illegal Israeli settlements."

Nimr Hamad, an adviser to Abbas, said the Palestinian president would travel to Cairo on Wednesday to discuss the plan with Hosni Mubarak, his Egyptian counterpart.

Source:Al Jazeera and agencies

Share:

Abu Ala : settlers can stay on under Palestinian sovereignty and laws

As part of a peace agreement with Israel, the inhabitants of the major Israeli settlements in the West Bank, including Ariel and Maale` Adumim, will continue ``to stay in their homes under Palestinian sovereignty and laws,`` said the head of the Palestinian negotiating group Abu Ala (Ahmed Qrea) in an interview appearing in Haaretz today.

Abu Ala also said that a clear agreement on Israel`s borders with a Palestinian state ``will resolve no less than 70% of the entire conflict in the region``. ``We will not resume negotiations (with Israel),`` he added, ``without a complete stop to the settlements including what you call natural growth``.

In Abu Ala`s view ``the creation of a national unity government including Fatah and Hamas is a preliminary condition for peace with Israel. Much progress has been made in negotiations (between Fatah and Hamas) in Egypt``.

There is already an agreement between the two rival Palestinian organisations, according to Abu Ala, on the PLO as the only legitimate representative of the Palestinians and on its reform. They also agreed that Palestinian presidential and legislative elections will be held on January 25 2010, even if there are disagreements on the electoral system.
Share:

The end of Peace

http://www.notmytribe.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/time-magazine-cover-israel.jpg



why does anyone expect Israel to achieve any Peace ?
who told you , that Peace is thinkable or even imaginable ?

Peace makes Israel return the Lands it has stolen
Peace makes Israel availiable for accountability
Peace makes Israel coexesisting with other races
Peace makes Israel answering to many guilt
and to many questions.

Peace will bring the end of Israel
or better said :
The end of Israel , will bring Peace .


Before Israel , there was ,anyhow, Peace
and the same will come back
after Israel leaves......

USA and NATO
are afraid of becoming jobless and useless
after the departure of the Cold-War.

Therefore Peace for Israel
shall mean the burial of NATO
and the paralisation of the US war-machines.

USA + NATO
need Israel
and
Israel needs no Peace.

Raja Chemayel
one plus one , makes two !
Share:

Abu Marzouk: Palestinian negotiators committed unforgivable mistake


LONDON, (PIC)-- Dr. Mousa Abu Marzouk, the deputy political bureau chairman of Hamas, has expressed fears that Israeli premier Benjamin Netanyahu might insist on the idea of a "Jewish" state after former PA chief Mahmoud Abbas had accepted the principle of exchanging lands in his negotiations with Israel.

In an interview with the London-based Al-Hayat newspaper published on Sunday, he said that an agreement was reached on the percentage of lands to be exchanged, adding that the seriousness is in the principle rather than the application.

Abu Marzouk said that the Palestinian negotiator had committed an unforgivable mistake when he accepted that principle, which he even described as a "crime".

The Palestinian negotiator is no longer taking into consideration any red lines, the deputy Hamas leader charged.

Share:

An open letter to Caryl Churchill from a Palestinian Mother

Dear Caryl Churchill

Seven Jewish Children - a Play for Gaza



Written by Iqbal Tamimi

Palestinian Mothers are thanking you for your great contributions to peace and understanding. We support your calls for common sense and reminding everybody of what we have in common of unconditional love for our children, we support your mission; your words healed some of our wounds. Allow me to join you.. And tell her that....Tell her soon she will grow up like all young girls do, she will get married and becomes a mother...


Tell her she will understand then how it feels to worry about her child, and how painful it is to lose one, No. don't tell her that... tell her... her children will always be safe.


Tell her blood is dearer than oil. Explain to her what kind of oil you are talking about; explain to her how many chocolate bars one can buy for the price of one bomb.


Tell her she should reject discrimination and call for equal rights for all when she grows up, . No .. do not tell her that now... discrimination is a big word... just tell her every human being is special and we are all equal, you might have to tell her why some people are more equal than others.

Tell her if the killing stops we will enjoy art, music, and literature. ...don't tell her that, just tell her that she will play outside as much as she wants, and she can play with all the children.


Tell her to demand an apology of the Israeli state to every mother who lost a child. No... don't...just tell her no more children are going to be killed.

Tell her to request compensating people for their losses. Tell her that she might have to share her toys.

Tell her that we never intended to kill the children and women of Gaza, and did not mean to bomb the schools, hospitals, universities, and ambulances, tell her we are going to rebuild everything. Do not tell her that her father was flying an F-16 and that he bombed the school in Gaza...tell her F-16s deliver milk sometimes...No...do not lie to her, she will find out later.

Tell her Israel is no democracy, no democracy will discriminate against ones beliefs. Don't... she does not know yet what democracy or beliefs mean, she only knows lollypops, dolls, and candy floss, just tell her that all children should be able to taste some sweets.

Tell her a democratic state will never imprison 55 MPs who represent the people. Don't tell her that Palestinian MPs have children of her own age.

Tell her children of her age are in prison with the criminals deprived of schooling because they dared to love their country. Tell her not to be worried for Jewish children do not go to prison.

Tell her to thank God that she is not a pregnant Palestinian woman about to give birth at a check point. Tell her if she becomes pregnant she will deliver her baby in the most comfortable way and she will be supervised by the best doctors in the best equipped hospitals.

Tell her we love her. Tell her USA love her.

Tell her she can change every body’s future because she will save many lives. Do not tell her that we never cared about the blood of Palestinians unless it was donated for transfusion to our sick.

Tell her that her great grand parents lived in peace with Palestinians for hundreds of years before the apartheid regime ruled over the land of peace. Tell her Muslims are now fanatics, do not tell her about the Christian Palestinians. Just tell her we do not need their help any more.

Tell her we want to sleep without fears. Tell her about the mini rockets fired from Gaza to Sderot, but do not tell her that Sderot was the home of those refugees of Gaza. Do not tell her about the tons of rockets and missiles fired on Gaza.

Tell her the white phosphorus bombs were fireworks celebrating the New Year.

Tell her not to be frightened, all the Palestinian want is equal rights and justice. Do not tell her that we consider Palestinians as animals and unworthy of life.

Tell her if she is brave to change this ugly system one day we will all meet like all good neighbours do.

Tell her Palestinian mothers used to babysit for Jewish mothers like sisters.

Tell her not to believe all the lies she hears from main stream line media. She can only trust Tom and Jerry, but not to believe in Superman.

Tell her if she really believe in God she will respect life and dignity of others. Do not tell her that we consider Palestinians not worthy of respect.

Tell her God is capable of making prophecies come true if he wants without the help of Zionists. Do not tell her that we manipulate relegion whenever we like to suit our agenda, do not tell her that most of our government are secular people who never practiced Judaism.

Tell her no God will favour some of his children over the rest of them. But still tell her we are the chosen people.

Tell her it is not fair that she came from Russia and she lives in a Palestinian home while a Palestinian woman and her family were expelled from their home where they used to live for 1400 years.

Tell her...to ask them..why this woman can't go home now.

Tell her why people in her home town can't pray in their local mosque as they used to for hundreds of years.

Tell her 11.870 Palestinian are detained in prisons the majority were never tried at a court.

Tell her a Palestinian woman said when she dies she wants to be buried in her home under a vine tree, tell her do something to stop them uprooting the trees.

Tell her my body blossomed from the soil of Palestine and one day it should be reunited with Palestine's soil to nourish a jasmine tree....climb the windows and stretch to hug the sky.

Tell her when she prays for children's safety, she should not pray only for Jewish children, God would not like that... angles are immuned against Zionist propaganda.

Tell her only justice can bring peace.


Regards

Iqbal Tamimi
Creator of Palestinian Mothers Network
Share:

Do you want to see what some Israeli intellectuals think?

Many of the Israeli elites who appreciates life , human rights and dignity are rarely given the opportunity to share their views. Here is a video tape they produced themselves I would recommend you watch and comment.

It Is No Dream (2002 - 53min.) from Joseph Rochlitz on Vimeo.


It Is No Dream (2002 - 53min.) from Joseph Rochlitz on Vimeo.

It Is No Dream

"If you will it, it is no dream," wrote the founder of political Zionism Theodor Herzl in 1902, prophesizing the creation of a utopian Jewish state.

One hundred years later, some of the harshest critics of Israel's occupation policies are Israelis themselves – a small minority of intellectuals, political activists and artists whose voices are rarely heard outside Israel.

Shortly after the outbreak of the second Intifada in 2001, filmmakers Benny Brunner and Joseph Rochlitz travelled through the country and spoke to a number of them:

Meir Shalev – one of Israel's best-known writers.
Gideon Levy – columnist for Haaretz newspaper.
Jessica Montell – Director of B'Tselem (Israeli Human Rights Center).
Yehudit Katzir – writer.
Yizhar Be'er – Director of the Israeli Center for the Protection of Democracy.
Adi Ophir – Professor of Philosophy at Tel Aviv University.
Noa Levy – leader of the High School students "refusal-to-serve" movement."
Yitzhak La'or – writer and poet.

The filmmakers also attended a major peace rally in Tel Aviv, and recorded the fiery words of Yishai Rosen-Tzvi, one of the first to sign the Letter of Refusal to serve in the Occupied Territories: "Fighting against terrorism? What a joke! Government and army policies create a hothouse for terrorism (...) It is forbidden to treat men, women and children like dirt. The more people understand it, the sooner there will be an end to this cursed occupation."

The film is enhanced by the powerful work of artist David Reeb, who frequently uses images of the occupation in his drawings and paintings.

Documentary - 53 minutes
Produced & Directed by Benny Brunner and Joseph Rochlitz
Original languages: English & Hebrew with English subtitles
Share:

"Two State Solution" Equals Racism

By John Spritzler

In light of Stephen Walt's recent article, "Is Obama turning up the pressure on Israel?" (i.e. pressure for a "two state solution"), it may be good to read (or re-read) this earlier one by yours truly: A New Path For Israel? The "two state solution" means, in reality, a "Bantustan solution" in which the "Palestinian state" would be no more "independent" of Israel than Gaza today is "unoccupied" by Israel. Palestinians would continue to suffer from being the victims of ethnic cleansing. They would continue to be denied their right to return to the land where they were born, and to be compensated fully for the property that Zionists stole from them. Israel would still insist that is is anti-Semitic to oppose the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from the part of Palestine now called Israel. Israel would very likely use "making the Jewish state secure against violent anti-Semites" as a pretext to invade the "Palestinian state" and slaughter its people, just as it invaded Gaza after "withdrawing" from it.There is no reason to believe that the "two state solution" would mean less Israeli violence against Palestinians.

The American upper class that President Obama represents has consistently supported Israeli ethnic cleansing. They have a very strong reason for doing so. Israel's ethnic cleansing foments a violent conflict that the American corporate-controlle d media can lie about and use to persuade the American public to believe a Big Lie: "Freedom-loving people like Israelis and Americans are surrounded by irrational, hateful violent anti-American and anti-Semitic terrorists." The conflict that Israel foments provides valuable credibility to the Orwellian "War on Terror," a war that Obama is as determined to keep waging as George Bush Jr. ever was. This is Obama's goal, not any reduction in the suffering of the Palestinians (or of ordinary Jews either.)

What the Palestinian people need from us in countries whose governments support Israel, is for us to persuade our fellow citizens to oppose our government's support for Israel. Palestinians need us to mount a successful campaign of divestment and boycott against Israel that pushes for our governments to apply sanctions against Israel as a rogue state the way the apartheid South African regime was treated. That requires explaining to our fellow citizens that the root of the conflict is the enormous crime of ethnic cleansing required to make Israel a "Jewish state." We must explain that there should not be a Jewish state in Palestine and that Palestinian opposition to Israel is not anti-Semitism, but justifiable and righteous anger at being treated unjustly. We must explain that the two sides in the conflict are not Jews versus non-Jews but rather people who are for equality versus people who are for inequality. Until people understand these fundamental facts, they will be unable to understand why Israeli attacks on Palestinians are unjustified no matter what the pretext.

If the "two state solution" is implemented, our fellow citizens will be told, "Look, the Palestinians now have their state and they still complain--it shows that what they really want is to destroy Israel and drive the Jews into the sea." If we jump on the "two state" bandwagon, we will only have helped the pro-Israel propagandists succeed in this propaganda. We will have implicitly endorsed the racist lie that is the premise of the two-state solution: "Palestinians hate Jews, always have and always will; they can never live in the same state with Jews peaceably, and Jews cannot be expected to let Palestinians live among them as equals."

"Two state solution" equals racism. We need to reject it, not support it.

CAN JEWS AND PALESTINIANS LIVE PEACEFULLY AS EQUALS IN ONE DEMOCRATIC STATE?

Elite leaders like Obama and Netanyahu want everybody to believe the lie that ordinary Jews and non-Jews in all of Palestine (i.e. including the part of it now called Israel) cannot live together in peace and equality. They point to the current mutual fear and distrust between Jews and non-Jews in Palestine as evidence for this. But understanding the situation in context shows us a very different picture.

Firstly, the mutual fear and distrust between Jews and non-Jews in Palestine today is no more innate to these people than the belief in anti-black stereotypes so widely accepted by white Americans in the past was innate to white people. The animosity between Palestinians and Israeli Jews was deliberately fomented by Israeli Zionist leaders with the help of British and American leaders for decades. It was not the presence of Jews in Palestine, per se, that angered the native Palestinians; rather it was the intention (and then the reality) of Zionists removing non-Jews from their homeland to turn most of it into an exclusively Jewish state. Some Jewish leaders who wanted to see a Jewish homeland inside Palestine never wanted to see it take the form of an exclusively Jewish state based on ethnic cleansing. Albert Einstein always opposed the idea of a Jewish state. Judah Magnes, the first Chancellor of Israel's Hebrew University, opposed the "Jewish state" idea because, as he expressed it in his diary in 1942, "The slogan 'Jewish state' (or commonwealth) is equivalent, in effect, to a declaration of war by the Jews on the Arabs."

But the imperialist powers of the United States and Great Britain knew that ethnic conflict in the Middle East made it easier to keep that region and its oil wealth in the hands of privileged elites and not the masses. So they supported Zionist leaders very different from the likes of Einstein and Magnes. Zionist leaders like David Ben Gurion, who wanted to create an exclusively Jewish state, had the backing of first Great Britain and then the United States. Even before the establishment of the state of Israel, at the close of World War II, the United States gave Ben Gurion virtual control over Jews in the American-run displaced persons camps in Europe and allowed him, in 1948, to forcibly draft thousands of Jews from these camps and transport them--very much against their will!--to Palestine to be soldiers in the Zionist Haganah militia and to fight Palestinians.

There was a concerted effort by Zionist leaders not only to create Palestinian anger against Jews but to make Jews fear Palestinians. David Ben Gurion, in February of 1948 when Zionist military forces were expelling entire Palestinian populations from their villages and towns, gave fiery speeches to the Jewish masses in Palestine describing Palestinian resistance this way [pg. 72]: "This is a war aimed at destroying and eliminating the Jewish community." Zionist leaders have been carrying out ethnic cleansing of non-Jews and telling Jews in Israel that Arabs are irrational and violent anti-Semites for decades. Today's mutual fear and distrust between Jews and Palestinians doesn't just arise from any inherent trait of either Jews or Palestinians; it is the result of a vicious effort from above to pit these people against each other.

Secondly, a movement against Zionism can mobilize not only Palestinians but ordinary Jews as well, if it is based on class and not religion. The reason for this is that Zionist leaders are the enemy of ordinary Jews and they have attacked ordinary Jews ever since the Holocaust, when they opposed efforts to rescue Jews. Today upper class Zionist leaders are driving ordinary Jews down with the kind of class oppression that America's upper class is using to drive down most Americans.

It is true that at the present time Israeli Jews fear Palestinians more than their own upper class Zionist billionaires, generals and politicians. But this does not have to be true forever. Working class Jews, like other working class people, dislike inequality and don't want to be ruled by a privileged and wealthy elite. This is why Jewish workers before World War II joined socialist or communist parties and organizations, and why most of them rejected Zionism, whose leaders were rightly dismissed as collaborators with anti-working class governments. After World War II, however, socialism and communism were discredited by their association with the thoroughly anti-democratic regime of Stalin in the Soviet Union. Zionism (Jewish nationalism) came to be seen by many working class Jews after the Holocaust as the only salvation for Jews. These Jews decided to put up with the increasing inequality and elite rule of Zionism in Israel because they believed it was necessary to avoid something much worse, namely being "driven into the sea" by hate-filled terrorists.

There has been virtually no class-based anti-Zionist organizing effort inside Israel since its establishment, which is why Jewish opposition to Zionism seems, on the surface, to be impossible. However, if such organizing took place, aiming to expose the anti-working class lies and oppression of Zionism, and aiming to explain to Israeli Jews the truth about why Palestinians quite rightly do not think there should be a Jewish state in Palestine, there is every reason to believe it would resonate with working class Jews for one huge reason--it would have the truth on its side.

Thirdly, the fact that millions of Jews in Israel live in houses or on land that was stolen from Palestinians by the Zionist movement does not mean that these same Jews will never wish to return this property to its rightful Palestinian owners and live with them peacefully as equals. Here's why. An anti-Zionist movement based on class--and calling for Palestinians to enjoy their right of return and compensation for stolen property and equality with Jews in all of Palestine--would have enormous support from ordinary Israeli Jews as well as Palestinians if--a very big if--it had a revolutionary outlook. With such an outlook it could fight for, among other things, something like this: Take money away from the eighteen wealthiest families in Israel (who earn 32% of the country's revenues) and create a fund with that money that would be large enough to say to every Israeli family living in or on stolen property the following:

"The fund will give you one million U.S. dollars (in shekels) which you must use this way: first offer to buy the property from the rightful Palestinian owner for one million dollars; if the Palestinian refuses, then give the property back to him or her and then use the one million dollars to buy land and build a new house for yourself."

The eighteen wealthiest families in Israel are rich enough to make this work, as spelled out in detail here. This would be a win/win scenario for ordinary Jews and Palestinians alike. It would create a new social environment of equality and trust and solidarity across religious lines. Palestinian anger at being kept out of their homeland and denied compensation for stolen property and made refugees or second class citizens would be a thing of the past. Islamic Fundamentalists who continued to carry out violence against Jewish civilians would be rejected as criminals by most Palestinians. Jewish fear of Palestinians due to knowing that they were living in or on stolen Palestinian houses and land would also belong to the past. At the same time an economic housing construction boom with increased employment for all working people would make life better economically for Jews and non-Jews, in sharp contrast to the days when many people were either unemployed or employed to make weapons or be soldiers in a bloody ethnic war killing innocent people. All of this, and much more, is possible if its revolutionary essence is explicitly recognized and embraced as the movement's goal.

The way to defeat Zionism is by uniting ordinary Jews and non-Jews in all of Palestine against it. But to do this, the goal needs to be more than just the abolition of Zionism; it needs to be the revolutionary goal of abolishing class inequality too. In this revolutionary framework, the "One State Solution" makes perfect sense. But in the absence of a revolutionary class framework, the "One State Solution" can be a trap. Palestinians could continue to be dominated and oppressed by a predominantly Jewish upper class, just as blacks in South Africa continue to be oppressed by a predominantly white upper class after that country's "One State Solution" abolished apartheid. Neither outcome is inevitable and both are very possible. What happens depends on what people decide to do. That is why it is crucial for everyone opposed to Zionism to think hard about the choices that confront us, and to make sure that our decision about what to oppose and what to support is not made for us by upper class agents such as Obama and Netanyahu.
Share:

President Obama, King Abdullah, and the end of Israel


During the G-20 summit in London, Barack Obama took time out for a brief meeting with King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia caught on video by two cameras, and by a still photographer, where the U.S. president bowed deeply in greeting the Saudi monarch. No major American media paid any attention to the startling, unreciprocated bow, gesture of subservience. In tandem, there was scant paid attention to a disquieting comment by Obama when he spoke effusively about a 2002 Saudi peace initiative for normalization of relations between the Arab world and Israel. The Saudi initiative, which would end Israel as a Jewish state, is now also the official position of the entire Arab League.

In a brief press statement, the White House said "the President reiterated his appreciation for Saudi Arabia's leadership in promoting the Arab peace initiative."

Later, President Obama's Middle East Special Envoy, George Mitchell, said the U.S. intends to "incorporate" the initiative into its Middle East policy

That stops short of an explicit endorsement of the Saudi-Arab plan, but it comes uncomfortably close. Either way, Obama's gushing over the Saudi initiative hardly can be reconciled with his oft-repeated assurances that Israel can count on U.S "unwavering support" of its basic security interests.

The Saudi initiative usually is presented in mainstream media as a pretty good deal -- Arab nations would normalize relations with Israel in exchange for Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 line and a "just" solution to the refugee problem.

But there's far more to the plan, and the devilish details can't be swept away or ignored.

For starters, the plan would grant millions of Palestinian refugees and their descendants a "right of return" to Israel -- a demographic bomb in the megaton range that would end up creating two states -- both Palestinian. The Saudis pull off this feat by defining a "just" solution to the refugee problem as having to be "in accordance with" UN General Assembly Resolution 194 -- a non-binding 1948 measure that vainly pleaded for an end to Arab aggression against the nascent Jewish state. In the midst of the war, the resolution also pleaded for return of refugees -- not just for Arabs who were displaced but for all refugees, including a greater number of Jews who were being driven out of Arab lands.

Significantly, all Arab nations voted against Resolution 194 -- after all, they weren't ready in late 1948 to halt their war against Israel. But in later years, in a revisionist twist, they adopted Resolution 194 as a legal warrant for a "return" of all Palestinian refugees and their descendants.

As if this weren't enough, the Saudi initiative -- with its absolute insistence on Israeli withdrawal to the 1949-1967 armistice line -- would require Israel to pull back from all of Gaza (which it already has done), from the entire West Bank, from all of East Jerusalem, and from the entire Old City of Jerusalem, the site of Judaism's most sacred shrine -- the Western Wall.

Jewish worshippers again would be beholden to an Arab regime for access to the Western Wall, having tasted the bitter experience of not being allowed to pray there during Jordan's 19-year-old occupation of the Old City. Jordan destroyed numerous synagogues there and used Jewish tombstones from the Mount of Olives to build a road. It doesn't take much imagination to project a repeat of this tragic episode if Palestinians ruled the entire Old City since, in areas already under their control, they have fired on Rachel's Tomb near Bethlehem, demolished Joseph's Tomb near Nablus and desecrated an ancient synagogue in Jericho.

To comply with the Saudi initiative, Israel would have to uproot more than a half million Jews from the Old City, East Jerusalem, and close-in Jewish settlements that George W. Bush pledged would remain on the Israeli side in any two-state peace deal.

Prior U.S. and Israeli governments offered a cordial but nuanced reception to the Saudi plan over the last seven years. The diplomatic term usually was that the Arab initiative had some promising elements that could form a "basis" for productive negotiations. But neither Bush, nor Ariel Sharon or his successor Ehud Olmert, ever embraced it in its totality. King Abdullah and other Arab rulers, however, insist on full acceptance of their initiative -- take it or leave it.

Now comes Obama in his debut on the world stage and gets ever so close to a full endorsement of this Saudi "gift" to peace.

One is left to wonder if the President is aware of the full implications of the Saudi-Arab peace initiative, or how he's put Israel behind the eight ball by praising King Abdullah's efforts to put it front and center in future peace negotiations.

Since Obama previously was quoted as saying that "the Israelis would be crazy not to support this initiative," it is past time for him to explain how he reconciles the real Saudi plan with Israel's real security challenges.


By Leo Rennert
Share:

Annapolis Deal Was A Waste Of Time


Israel foreign minister rejects Annapolis deal

Israel's new foreign minister says Tel Aviv is not bound by the 2007 Annapolis deal to pursue the creation of a Palestinian state.

"There is only one document that binds us and it is not the Annapolis conference, it has no validity," ultranationalist Avigdor Lieberman said at a handover ceremony at the foreign ministry a day after being sworn in by parliament.

"The Israeli government never ratified Annapolis, nor did the parliament," he added.

Lieberman's comments marked a sharp break with former foreign minister Tzipi Livni, who had led the Israeli delegation to the Annapolis peace talks with the Palestinians.

A political source close to new Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told Reuters that Lieberman's remarks largely reflected the premier's position.

Yasser Abed Rabbo, an aide to acting Palestinian Authority Chief Mahmud Abbas, was quoted by AFP as saying that Lieberman was 'an obstacle to peace'.

"Nothing obliges us to deal with a racist person hostile to peace such as Israeli Foreign Affairs Minister Lieberman," he added.

During the Annapolis conference, the then Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert agreed to pursue 'the goal of two states, Israel and Palestine' in peace negotiations with the Palestinians.

However, his government failed to meet a 2008 end deadline for reaching a two-state agreement with the Palestinians.

Lieberman, meanwhile, said that Israel would instead pursue the 'Road Map' which is an international peace plan launched in 2003, under which Israel bound itself to the principle of a Palestinian state and vowed to freeze all settlement activity in the occupied territories.

Netanyahu, whose right-wing government was sworn in on Tuesday, said during his inauguration speech that Israel would continue peace talks with Palestinians but declined to express support for a two state solution.

Israel has also announced in recent months the construction of hundreds of new Jewish homes in al-Quds although both the Annapolis summit and the Road Map oblige Israel to stop settlement activities in East al-Quds and the West Bank.
Share:

Zionism is the problem

The Zionist ideal of a Jewish state is keeping Israelis and Palestinians from living in peace.

By Ben Ehrenreich

It's hard to imagine now, but in 1944, six years after Kristallnacht, Lessing J. Rosenwald, president of the American Council for Judaism, felt comfortable equating the Zionist ideal of Jewish statehood with "the concept of a racial state -- the Hitlerian concept." For most of the last century, a principled opposition to Zionism was a mainstream stance within American Judaism.Even after the foundation of Israel, anti-Zionism was not a particularly heretical position. Assimilated Reform Jews like Rosenwald believed that Judaism should remain a matter of religious rather than political allegiance; the ultra-Orthodox saw Jewish statehood as an impious attempt to "push the hand of God"; and Marxist Jews -- my grandparents among them -- tended to see Zionism, and all nationalisms, as a distraction from the more essential struggle between classes.

To be Jewish, I was raised to believe, meant understanding oneself as a member of a tribe that over and over had been cast out, mistreated, slaughtered. Millenniums of oppression that preceded it did not entitle us to a homeland or a right to self-defense that superseded anyone else's. If they offered us anything exceptional, it was a perspective on oppression and an obligation born of the prophetic tradition: to act on behalf of the oppressed and to cry out at the oppressor.

For the last several decades, though, it has been all but impossible to cry out against the Israeli state without being smeared as an anti-Semite, or worse. To question not just Israel's actions, but the Zionist tenets on which the state is founded, has for too long been regarded an almost unspeakable blasphemy.

Yet it is no longer possible to believe with an honest conscience that the deplorable conditions in which Palestinians live and die in Gaza and the West Bank come as the result of specific policies, leaders or parties on either side of the impasse. The problem is fundamental: Founding a modern state on a single ethnic or religious identity in a territory that is ethnically and religiously diverse leads inexorably either to politics of exclusion (think of the 139-square-mile prison camp that Gaza has become) or to wholesale ethnic cleansing. Put simply, the problem is Zionism.

It has been argued that Zionism is an anachronism, a leftover ideology from the era of 19th century romantic nationalisms wedged uncomfortably into 21st century geopolitics. But Zionism is not merely outdated. Even before 1948, one of its basic oversights was readily apparent: the presence of Palestinians in Palestine. That led some of the most prominent Jewish thinkers of the last century, many of them Zionists, to balk at the idea of Jewish statehood. The Brit Shalom movement -- founded in 1925 and supported at various times by Martin Buber, Hannah Arendt and Gershom Scholem -- argued for a secular, binational state in Palestine in which Jews and Arabs would be accorded equal status. Their concerns were both moral and pragmatic. The establishment of a Jewish state, Buber feared, would mean "premeditated national suicide."

The fate Buber foresaw is upon us: a nation that has lived in a state of war for decades, a quarter-million Arab citizens with second-class status and more than 5 million Palestinians deprived of the most basic political and human rights. If two decades ago comparisons to the South African apartheid system felt like hyperbole, they now feel charitable. The white South African regime, for all its crimes, never attacked the Bantustans with anything like the destructive power Israel visited on Gaza in December and January, when nearly1,300 Palestinians were killed, one-third of them children.

Israeli policies have rendered the once apparently inevitable two-state solution less and less feasible. Years of Israeli settlement construction in the West Bank and East Jerusalem have methodically diminished the viability of a Palestinian state. Israel's new prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has even refused to endorse the idea of an independent Palestinian state, which suggests an immediate future of more of the same: more settlements, more punitive assaults.

All of this has led to a revival of the Brit Shalom idea of a single, secular binational state in which Jews and Arabs have equal political rights. The obstacles are, of course, enormous. They include not just a powerful Israeli attachment to the idea of an exclusively Jewish state, but its Palestinian analogue: Hamas' ideal of Islamic rule. Both sides would have to find assurance that their security was guaranteed. What precise shape such a state would take -- a strict, vote-by-vote democracy or a more complex federalist system -- would involve years of painful negotiation, wiser leaders than now exist and an uncompromising commitment from the rest of the world, particularly from the United States.

Meanwhile, the characterization of anti-Zionism as an "epidemic" more dangerous than anti-Semitism reveals only the unsustainability of the position into which Israel's apologists have been forced. Faced with international condemnation, they seek to limit the discourse, to erect walls that delineate what can and can't be said.

It's not working. Opposing Zionism is neither anti-Semitic nor particularly radical. It requires only that we take our own values seriously and no longer, as the book of Amos has it, "turn justice into wormwood and hurl righteousness to the ground."

Establishing a secular, pluralist, democratic government in Israel and Palestine would of course mean the abandonment of the Zionist dream. It might also mean the only salvation for the Jewish ideals of justice that date back to Jeremiah.
Share:

Peace, Propaganda & the Promised Land

Peace, Propaganda & the Promised Land U.S. Media & the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict How Israel manipulates and distorts American public perceptions Through the voices of scholars, media critics, peace activists, religious figures, and Middle East experts, Peace, Propaganda & the Promised Land carefully analyzes and explains how--through the use of language, framing and context--the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza remains hidden in the news media, and Israeli colonization of the occupied terrorities appears to be a defensive move rather than an offensive one. keywords: Palestine Israel Zionist Jew Islam Jewish Idi Amin Noam Chomsky Media Bias Big Brother Rupert Murdoch FOX News Sky News George Orwell Police State Military Occupation Iran Lebanon Terrorstorm Alex Jones manipulation media movements revolution alternative media Video available for sale here : http://www.mediaed.org/videos/MediaRaceAndRepresentation/PeacePropaganda Watch current Israel/Palestine news: http://newstree.org/search.jsp?query=Israel%20palestine%20video:1&hp=10&sort=ndateinmin&reverse=true&vx=1

Share:

Jewish-Canadian Activists Come Together for Peace

Here is an article of interest on Independent Jewish Voices and the creation of a Jewish Canadian umbrella organization that opposes Israel's policies towards the Palestinians and calls for an end to the Occupation of Palestinian land. Published in Embassy Magazine in Ottawa, Canada.

Ed Corriganby Jo Roberts

Outside the Israeli consulate on Toronto's Bloor street, Jewish-Canadian peace group Women in Solidarity with Palestine is staging its weekly vigil. Eight people have gathered. One woman holds up a large black hand inscribed with "End the Occupation!" Another carries a map of Israel and Palestine showing the growth of Israel's territory since 1948. Passers-by take a leaflet, or stop and engage in conversation, sometimes heated. It's a sunny day, but the vigil continues through the snowy winter months as well.
At its March 2008 founding conference, Independent Jewish Voices (Canada) adopted the following principles:

• Human rights are universal and indivisible and should be upheld without exception. This is as applicable in Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories as it is elsewhere.

• Palestinians and Israelis alike have the right to peaceful and secure lives.

• Peace and stability require the willingness of all parties in the conflict to comply with international law.

• There is no justification for any form of racism, including anti-Semitism, anti-Arab racism or Islamophobia, in any circumstance.

• The battle against anti-Semitism is vital, and it is undermined whenever opposition to Israeli government policies is automatically branded as anti-Semitic.
One of the regulars is Smadar Carmon, a 52-year-old Israeli-Canadian. She's been attending since she arrived in Canada in 2001. "I do all my activist work around Palestine from the perspective of fighting for human rights," she says. "Growing up in Israel, I read a lot of books on the Holocaust. The only way I could deal with that was not to be silent when others are living in horrifying conditions."

The vigil was started in solidarity with Women in Black, an anti-war organization of Jewish and Arab-Israeli women in Israel. It's also supported by Not in Our Name: Jewish Voices Opposing Zionism. Many such groups form a network of small affiliated anti-occupation organizations in Canada.

Bernard Katz is a member of several Jewish social justice groups in Toronto, including Canadian Friends of Peace Now, the mainstream Israeli peace organization. "There is a broad spectrum of Canadian Jewish peace organizations," he says, "ranging from people who support the existence of Israel as a Jewish state to those who believe Israel should not exist as a Jewish state because that makes it non-democratic."

Many people in the former camp would support a two-state solution to the conflict. Many in the latter would support a one-state solution, and a Palestinian right of return. Those two positions are so far apart, and so heavily contested, that they create a chasm that has so far been impossible to bridge.

Although he and Ms. Carmon, who is strongly anti-Zionist, stand in different places on that spectrum, both attended a spring conference for progressive Canadian Jews, organized by the Alliance of Concerned Jewish Canadians. That weekend conference, at which Naomi Klein was the keynote speaker, birthed Independent Jewish Voices (Canada) (IJV), a new umbrella organization under which 18 Jewish groups from 26 Canadian cities have come together.

"The Conference adopted a platform of 5 different points," explains Bernard Katz. "The one or two-state issue was not included. By leaving that out, people can focus on common themes and formally affiliate with each other."

Diana Ralph, from Ottawa, was the conference's primary organizer. "Our goal was to build a national coalition, so we could speak with one voice with a relatively broad mandate," she says.

The organization will give anti-occupation Jewish-Canadians "a credible alternative voice both in Canada and internationally." The new group has working relationships with all political parties.

In the months since its inception, IJV has sent delegations to the Gaza Community Mental Health Conference and to the World Conference against Racism in Geneva, and is coordinating Israeli anti-occupation activist Jeff Halper's Canadian tour in January.

Dismissed as "a rump" by the Canadian Jewish Congress, IJV counters that "those who claim to speak on behalf of Jews in Canada and other countries consistently put support for the policies of an occupying power above the human rights of an occupied people."

Diana Ralph is clear about why she does this work. "We are taught to live peacefully, with justice and humility, for the healing of the world. This is the best way I can be a Jew."


Share:

Pope Asks for Solution to Palestinian Issue

Speaks With Lebanese Leader About Mideast Christians

VATICAN CITY, .- Benedict XVI is advocating a safer situation for Christians in the Middle East and a "rapid and just" solution for the Palestinian question.These two themes, and the identity of Lebanon, were among the topics of discussion today when the new Lebanese president, Michel Sleiman, visited the Pope at the Vatican.

The president also met with the Holy Father's secretary of state, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, and Archbishop Dominique Mamberti, secretary for relations with states.

During the "cordial discussions," the Vatican press office reported, the Holy See's interest in Lebanon and the nation's "continuing determination to safeguard its particular identity" was reaffirmed.

The Pontiff expressed his appreciation for "the effort that the country and its leaders are making to redirect institutional life within the normal channels of political dialectic, in which every part of the Lebanese people can offer their contributions to the common good and see their own concerns and expectations duly taken into account."

The two leaders spoke for about 25 minutes.

Sleiman offered the Pope the gift of an Arabic book with the texts of a Maronite synod from 1736. The Holy Father gifted the president with a pontifical medal.

Lebanon's some 4 million inhabitants are about 60% Muslim and 39% Christian.
Share:

One Democratic State in Israel/Palestine as the Route to Durable Peace

By Sam Leibowitz and Mazin Qumsiyeh*

As the endless negotiations between the Israeli government and Palestinian Authority officials regurgitate old arguments while making no progress, a growing number of Israelis and Palestinians are paying attention to other solutions than the supposed “two state” outcome. They focus on the “one-democratic-state” solution -- a proposal to establish a single, democratic and secular state in the area known as Israel/Palestine.The concept of coexistence in a binational or one secular democratic state, granting equal rights to all its citizens regardless of their religion, is worthy of critical consideration. It is not a new concept. In the early days of the Zionist movement, it was promoted by Albert Einstein, philosopher Martin Buber, and Rabbi Judah Leib Magnes who argued vociferously against a “Jewish state.” It was also a political position taken by the Palestine Liberation Organization in its more visible days, and by some Israeli parties in the 1950s. Though it did not garner significant support in past decades, the idea has received new interest with the collapse of the Oslo process, and recently it has been the subject of numerous books, research papers and conferences.

In the past eight years, over a dozen books were published analyzing carefully why a single democratic state is the only durable solution. These books rely on research data from various disciplines, showing that the two people would benefit a great deal more if they shared the resources of the land together within a democratic framework. From every aspect, sociologically, economically, environmentally and security-wise, the Israelis and Palestinians are better off if they learn to live together in a secular country, with a constitution modeled after the American one, guaranteeing civil liberties and separation of state from religion.

Certainly, it will be no easy feat to educate both societies, after decades of wars, oppression, colonization, and violence against civilians, to respect the human and civil rights of each other. Perhaps the most pressing obstacle is the perception within Israeli society that a single, democratic state poses a threat to the Jews living in Israel/Palestine. This argument, reiterated ad nauseam by Israeli politicians, claims the single, democratic state is tantamount to the “elimination of Israel.” However, establishing a shared homeland for Israelis and Palestinians based on civil rights does not mean “the elimination of Israel” anymore than similar transformations in South Africa meant the elimination of South Africa.

Indeed, it will transform Israel, but this will be a positive transformation repairing truly destructive aspects of present-day Israel and producing a new and better country. Today’s Israel has failed to uphold the best of Jewish values and has in fact perverted them by making Judaism an adjunct of a discriminatory and brutal state ideology. If we want an Israel that is really true to the best of Jewish values, it cannot be exclusively Jewish. It is a strange but manifestly true irony that for Judaism and Israel to become really compatible, Israel must become a democratic, equalitarian, and tolerant place.

Most commentators think that the removal of the 450,000 Israeli settlers currently living in the area of the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) slated for a tiny Palestinian state is not feasible. But even if this issue is resolved, there are other, far more daunting, obstacles to the mythological “two-state” solution. The establishment of Israel as a “Jewish state” in 1948 created the largest remaining refugee population in the world. As Israeli historians have documented, Israel was founded through the ethnic cleansing of more than 500 Palestinian villages and towns, which brought about the Palestinian refugee problem -- a continuing crisis for 6 million refugees who have been driven from their homeland. Under international law, they have a right to return to their homeland, which must be implemented without jeopardizing the rights of Israelis to live peacefully and securely in their homes.

Israeli and Palestinian researchers have shown that only a single, democratic state, guaranteeing civil liberties to all its citizens and providing economic opportunity to its communities, can accommodate a just solution to the otherwise intractable refugee problem. A democratic, secular state defused of national-religious components will provide the sustainable framework needed for integrating the returning Palestinian refugees while at the same time allowing Israel to continue to thrive economically and technologically. Undoubtedly, it is also the best guarantee of security and peace for both societies.

Rather than engage in convening futile peace conferences that ignore human rights obligations and International law, politicians and policy makers would do well to get us all (Israelis and Palestinians) to sit down and start drafting a constitution that provides for joint security and economic development, and guarantees civil liberties to all. That is the real road map to a durable and just peace.

* Sam Leibowitz is an Israeli civil rights attorney and a graduate of American University Washington College of Law LL.M. program in international law, and Mazin Qumsiyeh is a professor at Bethlehem University and the author of the book “Sharing the Land of Canaan: Human Rights and the Israeli-Palestinian Struggle.”
Share:

Cat Stevens Denied Entry to Israel

You'd think that if Shimon Peres invited you to Israel, getting a visa would be snap. After all, Peres does happen to be the country's President, and surely that counts for something. But apparently not if you're a musician named Yusuf Islam, formerly known as the folksy singer- songwriter Cat Stevens. Stevens, a Briton who converted to Islam over 30 years ago, was invited to play at a 10th anniversary bash for the Peres Center for Peace, along with Argentine singer Mercedes Sosa and Italian tenor Andrea Bocelli. According to the Israeli press, Stevens was excited about the show and was going to play a re-written version of his hit "Peace Train" alluding to peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians.


But the show's producer Irit Tenhangel made a late check with the Israeli security services, who said that Stevens would not be allowed into Israel, even if it was at President Peres' request.


In 2000, Stevens had been denied entry to Israel for allegedly making contributions to the Palestinian Islamic militant group Hamas. "This put me in a very embarrassing situation with Stevens and his personal manager," Tenhangel told Ynetnews.com. "What am I supposed to tell them now, that the State of Israel doesn't want him to come and talk about peace voluntarily?" She added: "He may have supported Hamas once, but the fact that a singer who converted to Islam wants to come to Israel and express his support for peace and we're not letting him do so infuriates me."


A name like Yusuf Islam on a passport does tend to set alarm bells ringing, and not just in Israel. In 2004, the singer, educator and philanthropist was barred from visiting the U.S. He was suspected of being an Islamic militant, but it's not as though he was plotting to meet anybody subversive, just that most wholesome of American icons: country singer Dolly Parton, who had recorded several of Stevens' songs. Half Swedish and half Cypriot, Stevens was your typical, hard-partying young pop star of the 1970s when a near-drowning sent him on a spiritual quest, often explored through his songs, that ended with his embrace of Islam in 1977. He jettisoned his pop idol career, and dedicated himself to Islamic religious study. Using royalties from his 60 million record sales, he set up Islamic charities helping famine victims and orphans around the world.


Israeli officials say that this mishap over Stevens' invite could easily have been avoided if the organizers of Peres' party had checked first with the foreign ministry. The law says that anyone declared non grata and expelled, as Stevens was in 2000, cannot be allowed back into Israel for at least 10 years.


And as for Stevens now being a "Man of Peace", as he is often described, "his actions speak louder than his music", says Government Press Spokesman Daniel Seaman. "A man of peace doesn't give money to terrorist organizations that killed Israelis and those Palestinians who disagreed with them."


Nevertheless, denying Israeli entry to Stevens, a musician who advocates co-existence between Israel and the Palestinians, and who is a respected figure throughout the Islamic world, undercuts the message of peace that Pres. Peres is trying to convey to his wary Arab neighbors. Happy anniversary, Mr President.


By Tim McGirk/Jerusalem
Share:

Abbas: Israel's terror against the olive harvest shows "bad faith"

And what is he planning to do about it, beyond paying lip service? Nothing, as usual?

Well, what can a PA president possibly do, after all?

How about suspending the so-called negotiations, which are nothing more than a fig leaf covering up Israel's ongoing colonization of the West Bank, particularly in and around Jerusalem, and acts of genocide in Gaza?

How about urging the EU to suspend their association agreement with Israel?

How about waking up the long-dormant Palestinian ambassadors in most countries to launch campaigns, with solidarity groups, against Israel's occupation and apartheid?

If he cannot do any of the above, how about resigning in peace?

Omar BarghoutiAbbas criticizes Israel on olive harvest

By KARIN LAUB

RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — The Palestinian president accused Israel of not protecting Palestinian farmers against settler attacks during the ongoing olive harvest, but Israel's defense minister said Monday his troops are doing the best they can.

President Mahmoud Abbas was quoted as saying that the situation has become "unbearable." He said that a continued failure by Israel to crack down on militant settlers is a show of bad faith at a time when the two sides are trying to reach a peace deal.

"All lines have been crossed in the olive groves this season," Abbas said in comments published in the Palestinian daily Al Ayyam.

Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak said the army is making a major effort to protect the olive pickers and denounced those attacking farmers as "hooligans," but dismissed Abbas' accusation of bad faith.

"We are talking about hundreds of locations where there is an olive harvest and it is impossible to be at all the places at all the same times," Barak told Army Radio.

The West Bank has about 10 million olive trees, and the harvest, involving thousands of Palestinians, began more than a week ago. This year's harvest is expected to contribute some $100 million to the Palestinian economy and benefit some 100,000 families.

In recent years, more and more groves have become harder to reach, either because they lie beyond Israel's lengthening separation barrier or are close to Jewish settlements and their multiplying satellite camps.

Since the outbreak of Israeli-Palestinian fighting in 2000, settlers have repeatedly attacked farmers and damaged crops. In recent days, there have been several reports of attacks on olive pickers or their property.

The Israeli army claimed that in some cases, olive farmers and the Israeli and foreign volunteers escorting them have engaged in "deliberate provocation" by going to groves in areas of tension.
Share:

Israeli president declares acceptance of the Arab peace initiative

Israeli president Shimon Peres, declared in Cairo today his acceptance of the Arab peace initiative of 2002, which was endorsed during this year's Arab states summit meeting.Peres's position came during a meeting with his Egyptian counterpart, Husni Mubarak, in the Egyptian red resort town of Sharm Elshaikh.

The Israeli top official expressed the hope that the Israeli government will approve the initiative in order to continue current peace efforts that 'would lead to a genuine peace in the region'.

From his part, the Egyptian president welcomed Peres's stance, pointing out that the Arab states have long agreed to establishing normal relations with Israel in return for Israeli withdrawal from the occupied Arab territories, Israeli troops took over during the June4, 1967 Arab-Israeli war.

Mubarak also shed light on the latest developments of the peace process between Arab parties, such as the Palestinains and Syrians, and Israel.
Share:

Where is the U.S. Taking the Palestinian-Israeli Negotiations Process?

U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who spoke at the Aspen Institute on 2 August, attempted to assure the public that there has been significant movement behind the scenes in the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations process.
U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, who spoke at the Aspen Institute on 2 August, attempted to assure the public that there has been significant movement behind the scenes in the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations process.

You may not have noticed if you were busy watching the Olympics, but the U.S. Secretary of State is still trying to push Israelis and Palestinians towards reaching a peace agreement. Condoleezza Rice plans to visit the region today, reportedly timed to coincide with Israel releasing 199 Palestinian prisoners—none affiliated with Hamas—as a “good will” gesture towards Mahmoud Abbas. Visits by Secretary Rice have become so routine, and the prospects for a final status agreement seemingly so slim since Ehud Olmert announced his intention to resign, that most observers have given up on the Annapolis process launched last fall. Where is the negotiations process going?

From the beginning, President Bush and Secretary Rice acknowledged that time would be short for reaching an agreement before Bush leaves office. That time seems to have gotten even shorter. Olmert could be out of office as soon as Kadima holds party elections to replace him on 17 September. Yet, according to Rice’s official position, the Olmert resignation is an “internal Israeli matter” and Israeli-Palestinian talks continue to be “very fruitful.” She reportedly wants the two sides to produce a progress report, listing areas of agreement, before the UN General Assembly begins its 2008 session, also in late September. Israeli and Palestinian negotiators are resisting pressure to create such a document and have started issuing threats and leaks to the press.

Rice assured the Aspen Institute earlier this month that “the absence of public movement is not necessarily evidence of the absence of movement.” She now has to deal with private negotiations spilling into the public. Last week, the Israeli government apparently leaked a final status proposal presented by Olmert to Abbas that focused on borders, the issue on which the two sides are said to be closest to agreement. Under the plan, the Palestinians would receive Gaza and 93 percent of the West Bank, with the border of a future Palestinian state roughly coinciding with the current route of the Israeli Separation Wall. In exchange for the seven percent of the West Bank that Israel would take, Palestinians would receive a portion of the Negev desert adjacent to Gaza, equal to 5.5 percent of the area of the West Bank.

The proposed agreement would be implemented sequentially. Israel would get major settlements such as Ma’ale Adumim, the Gush Etzion bloc and the settlements around Jerusalem immediately, while the Palestinian Authority would receive the compensatory Negev territory and a passageway to Gaza only after it could retake control of Gaza from Hamas. Israel would also make full evacuation of the settlements inside the new Palestinian state contingent upon the Palestinian Authority. meeting certain other commitments. The future Palestinian state would be “demilitarized” and there would be no “right of return,” except for a small number of family reunifications. The two sides would postpone the issue of sovereignty over Jerusalem.

Rice cannot have been happy with the release of the proposal, as it put the negotiations into the glare of the media and showed how far apart the two sides are to reaching an agreement. Abbas spokesperson Nabil Abu Rudeineh immediately rejected the Olmert proposal as demonstrating a “lack of seriousness,” saying, "The Israeli proposal is unacceptable, it is a waste of time. The Palestinian people will agree to a state with territorial contiguity only in a way that includes Jerusalem as its capital." Earlier, chief Palestinian negotiator Ahmed Qurei even raised the possibility that his side would turn away from the “two states” formula if settlement construction continued and Israel refused to even discuss the issue of Jerusalem: “If Israel continues to reject our propositions regarding the borders [of a future Palestinian state], we might demand Israeli citizenship.”

Even before the latest round of negotiation-by-press-release, veteran British journalist and author Patrick Seale was ready to declare the Annapolis process officially dead and unlikely to return. “Bush, and his hapless Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice,” he said in a recent column, “must bear the prime responsibility for the failure. They have been unwilling—or unable—to put the slightest pressure on Israel, even to insist that it honor its verbal commitments to freeze settlements and evacuate illegal outposts. […] No U.S. Secretary of State has devoted so much time and effort to the Israeli-Palestinian imbroglio to so little effect.”

As an example of Rice’s timidity, Seale could point to her response to the Aspen audience query concerning getting the parties to fulfill their minimal Road Map obligations: “The Palestinians said that they would dismantle the infrastructure of terror. The Israelis made some representations about dismantling outposts. It's a slog, to be quite frank. […] And we keep working and working on that track.” Rice, it seems, cannot even get Israel to meet its obligations when she significantly lowers the bar for compliance from a settlement freeze and dismantling all outposts constructed since March 2001, as called for in the Road Map, to just dismantling unspecified outposts.

With Olmert stepping down, the next Israeli prime minister may be less enthusiastic, or even hostile, towards the peace process. As Seale notes, Tzipi Livni, the chief Israeli negotiator for Olmert, is the only Kadima candidate to replace Olmert that might keep the Israeli coalition of Kadima, Labor, and Shas together and thus continue support for the present negotiations process. Shaul Mofaz, according to the Jerusalem Post, would “likely pull the party to the right, making it virtually indistinguishable from the Likud.” If the new Kadima leader is unable to form a coalition within 48 days, new elections will be held in early 2009, which polls suggest could result in a revival of Likud leader Binyamin Netanyahu’s premiership. Netanyahu is known to favor a step-by-step process, with Israel’s implementation contingent upon the Palestinians meeting certain commitments, over one that settles all issues at once.

The upcoming U.S. presidential election adds more uncertainty to the mix. The two presumptive presidential candidates have not outright opposed the Annapolis process, but they seem to disagree on how important resolving the conflict is relative to other Middle East priorities.

Democratic presidential candidate, U.S. Senator Barack Obama, seems to favor making the Israeli-Palestinian conflict a higher priority than did the Bush administration. He told Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic earlier this year that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a “constant wound” or a “constant sore” that “does infect all of our foreign policy.” While he repeatedly emphasized “Israel’s right to defend itself,” Obama said that “the status quo is unsustainable” for Israel and that the United States has “a national-security interest in solving” the problem. Obama even quipped during his recent visit to Israel that he would not "wait a few years into my term or my second term, if I'm elected," to push for a peace agreement.

At an America Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) policy conference in Washington, DC, where both presidential candidates spoke earlier this year, Obama seems to have made a gaffe when he said, “Jerusalem will remain the capital of Israel, and it must remain undivided.” His campaign later backtracked on this embrace of the right-wing Israeli claim over Palestinian East Jerusalem by saying that sovereignty over Jerusalem is a “final status issue that has to be resolved between the Palestinians and the Israelis.”

Republican John McCain sees dangers hiding behind every rock in Israel’s neighborhood. In a press release that his campaign sent during the AIPAC conference, the McCain campaign devoted the first half to the threat posed by Iran and “radical Islamic extremists.” The Israeli-Palestinian negotiations merited one, incoherent bullet point: “While encouraging this process, we must also ensure that Israelis can live in safety until there is a Palestinian leadership willing and able to deliver peace. A peace process that places faith in terrorists can never end in peace.”

It is hard to imagine a Palestinian leadership more willing to sign an agreement than the Abbas/Fayyad government, which may be why Condoleezza Rice continues to push the Annapolis process forward—the alternatives seem so much worse. Excluding Hamas from the bargaining table, however, hinders the government’s ability to deliver an agreement. Further, the successful ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza suggests that there are times when “negotiating with terrorists” can actually improve Israel’s security, at least in the short term.

When asked by Goldberg what he thought of Obama’s characterization of the conflict as a “constant sore,” McCain said, “I don't think the conflict is a sore. I think it's a national security challenge. I think it's important to achieve peace in the Middle East on a broad variety of fronts and I think that if the Israeli-Palestinian issue were decided tomorrow, we would still face the enormous threat of radical Islamic extremism.”

It is difficult to know at this point whether the work that Condoleezza Rice has done will survive the change of leadership in the United States and Israel. Days before Rice was set to arrive in Israel, Tzipi Livni issued a warning that seemed directed at the United States and possibly Rice herself: “The pressure, the international pressure, this can lead to clashes, this can lead to misunderstandings, this can lead to violence as we had, as we faced, after Camp David 2000 and the circumstances, in a way, are similar.” Rice must weigh the threats and gamble on what her legacy might be once the negotiations process falls into new hands.
Share: