Showing posts with label Fatah. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fatah. Show all posts

Jailed Fatah leader calls for Palestinian state on 1967 borders


Marwan Barghouti has criticised the concept of land swaps with the Israelis and called for a Palestinian state on all of the land occupied by Israel in 1967. The jailed member of the PLO Executive Committee made his comments on the 65th anniversary of the Nakba, the catastrophe of the founding of the state of Israel which saw more than 750,000 Palestinians driven from their land in an act of ethnic cleansing which continues to this day. He also took the opportunity to demand the retention of Palestinian refugees' right of return.
"We call for all Palestinians everywhere to commemorate the Nakba with more resistance against the Israeli occupation and illegal settlements," said Barghouti. Nobody can concede the right to return by proxy, he insisted, as it is guaranteed as an individual right, not a collective right, by UN Resolution 194. "This is a point of consensus among Palestinians everywhere," he pointed out, "and is the noblest and holiest aim for Palestinians to fight for."
Calling for Israel's complete withdrawal from the Palestinian territories occupied in 1967, Mr Barghouti said that no concessions of the Palestinian national principles are acceptable, calling them "free gifts" to the Israelis. He stressed that Palestinians have the right of self-determination and the right to establish a full sovereign independent state within the 1967 borders with Jerusalem as its capital. "Freeing all prisoners in Israeli jails is also one of the Palestinian principles."
Barghouti, who is one of the most popular leaders among Fatah supporters, criticised the attempts to resume negotiations with the Israelis without fulfilling Palestinian demands. "Any attempt to resume negotiations before fulfilling the demands will harm our national interests," he added.
The Fatah leader was detained by the Israeli occupation authorities in April 2002. He was convicted and given five life sentences by an Israeli court for his alleged involvement in the first and second Palestinian uprisings against Israel's brutal military occupation.
Share:

Shami al-Shami is recovering from gunshot wounds in a Jenin hospital

Shot lawmaker: Attacker wanted to kill me


JENIN (Ma’an) -- Fatah lawmaker Shami al-Shami, who was shot early Sunday in his hometown of Jenin, told Ma'an from hospital that he believes the unknown assailants aimed to kill him.

Al-Shami was wounded by two bullets in his right thigh and is recuperating in Jenin government hospital. Medics say his wounds are moderate.

The deputy told Ma'an he had returned to his home after work about 1.30 a.m. Sunday morning. As he left his car to open the garage he heard gunfire towards him.

Al-Shami said a man shot between eight and ten bullets at him, two of which hit him while he was hiding behind his car.

He said he was unable to identify the shooter as he fled the scene, but noted that the gunman had been waiting near his house for his arrival.

The lawmaker said the incident was just the latest attempt to destablize Jenin and called on Palestinian security services to apprehend anyone who undermines security.

Jenin Governor Talal Dweikat told Ma'an earlier that security services were exerting major efforts to try and discover the assailants as soon as possible.

Palestinian security forces have led a crackdown in the Jenin district after assailants opened fire on the home of Jenin Governor Qaddura Musa in early May.

The governor died of a heart attack the same night.
Share:

The Kaddumi bombshell

Accusations of conspiracy to murder continue to reverberate across the Palestinian arena, threatening to break the Fatah movement in two, writes Khaled Amayreh in the West Bank



Farouk Kaddumi's recent bombshell accusations that Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas and his aide, former Gaza strongman Mohamed Dahlan, had connived with Israel to murder late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat continue to reverberate throughout the Palestinian arena.

The allegations made by the second highest-ranking leader of the Fatah organisation during an impromptu press conference in Amman last week, have overshadowed the Hamas-Fatah rift and even the standoff over Jewish settlement expansion in the West Bank. The increasingly ugly showdown between Fatah's two divergent camps is already polarising the group at all levels, including the grassroots level, with activists pointing fingers of accusation at either Kaddumi or Abbas.

Last week, the PA government decided to close down the West Bank offices of Al-Jazeera TV after the Qatari-based satellite channel carried live Kaddumi's press conference from Amman. The Western-backed Ramallah-based government accused Al-Jazeera of "broadcasting false news, bias, incitement and fostering division and disunity in the Palestinian arena". The decision drew mostly negative reactions from several quarters, especially Palestinian civil society and the journalistic community, prompting Prime Minister Salam Fayyad to rescind the decision a few days later.

Clearly disquieted by the accusations, Palestinian leader Abbas lashed out at Kaddumi, accusing him of spreading cheap lies in order to abort the convening of Fatah's long overdue Sixth Conference, slated to take place in Bethlehem in the first week of August. Similarly, Abbas allies have been attacking and fulminating against Kaddumi, calling him names such as "senile", "liar", and "saboteur". The West Bank Fatah leadership has asked the movement's Central Council to discuss Kaddumi's "canards" and "eject him from our ranks".

Unfazed by the sabre rattling from Ramallah, Kaddumi reasserted the "veracity and authenticity" of the minutes of the March 2004 meeting in West Jerusalem during which the alleged plot to poison Arafat was discussed. Kaddumi has also reportedly hinted that he possesses further incriminating evidence against Abbas and Dahlan that further corroborates and consolidates his earlier charges. The secretary-general of Fatah also challenged Abbas and his allies to prove their loyalty to the group.

"You don't own Fatah, you have hijacked Fatah for the purpose of amassing wealth and stealing money. You have swerved off the true path of Fatah, the path of resistance and liberation, and chosen to be a pawn in the hands of our enemies," Kaddumi said.

As the two contentious camps within Fatah continue to trade recriminations, former political advisor to Arafat Bassam Abu Sharif reasserted charges he made shortly after Arafat's death in November 2004. Abu Sharif claimed that Arafat was killed as a result of a chemical substance provided by Israeli intelligence.

Abu Sharif argued that Israeli soldiers manning a roadblock outside Ramallah stopped the Palestinian ambulance that had regularly brought food and medicine to the besieged Palestinian leader. "When the soldiers were searching the ambulance, while its Palestinian staff was kept away, they substituted a medicine which Arafat had been taking with an identical substitute containing a chemical poison. This is how Arafat got sick and eventually succumbed to his illness."

Hamas's politburo chief Khaled Meshaal almost died in Amman in 1997 when Mossad agents disguised as Canadian tourists smacked a chemical substance into his ear. The two agents were captured and then-King Hussein of Jordan threatened to sever ties with Israel, forcing the Israeli government, headed at the time by Binyamin Netanyahu, to provide the antidote that saved Meshaal's life.

On Arafat, while Abu Sharif's hypothesis is mostly speculative in nature and may prove impossible to verify, the fact that the life of the leader of the Palestinian people is entrusted to Israeli soldiers manning roadblocks and checkpoints speaks volumes about the nature of the PA and its near total subservience to Israel.

Meanwhile, Arafat's widow, Suha, has been quoted as saying that "Israel was the only suspect in the death of my husband." Suha cleared Abbas and Dahlan of any wrongdoing, saying that they were Arafat's comrades. Most observers in occupied Palestine find it hard to rely on Suha's remarks, on the grounds that she often appeared detached from political realities in Palestine, living a lavish lifestyle in Paris while her husband was languishing under Israeli siege in Ramallah.

This is not to say that Kaddumi's accusations ought to be given the benefit of the doubt. But there is little doubt that the Kaddumi bombshell will cast a dark shadow on deliberations at Fatah's Sixth Congress when -- and if -- convened. It is expected that Abbas will try to take advantage of the charged atmosphere and the fact that anti-Abbas delegates are largely based outside occupied Palestine or in the Gaza Strip and are unlikely to attend the conference in Bethlehem.

However, a conference at which Abbas and his allies enjoy absolute hegemony will only deepen and widen the existing chasm between various camps within Fatah. More to the point, Kaddumi might resort to holding a rival Fatah conference of his own, possibly in Damascus or Beirut. If this were to happen, Fatah would disintegrate into two camps, one based abroad and enjoying "revolutionary legitimacy" and backed by Syria and Iran, and probably Qatar, and the other coalesced into the PA and enjoying "international legitimacy" and backed by the US, EU and the so-called moderate Arab regimes.

Finally, the success of the Bethlehem conference will also depend to a large extent on the cooperation of the Hamas movement. Hamas, which has so far opted to remain outside the Kaddumi-Abbas confrontation, has hinted that it may not allow Fatah delegates from the Gaza Strip to leave for the West Bank if PA security agencies continue to round up and persecute Hamas leaders and activists and if hundreds of Hamas detainees are not released. Since the PA is unlikely to release these detainees, mainly because there is a strong lobby within Fatah against rapprochement with Hamas, it is probable that very few Fatah delegates from Gaza, if any, will make it to the West Bank.

The "Israeli factor" is also relevant. Israel has an established policy of barring Gaza residents from entering the West Bank as a matter of principle. Undoubtedly this, too, will be an important factor militating for or against the convening of the conference, as well as its success.
Share:

Future of Fatah in Doubt



Analysis by Mel Frykberg

RAMALLAH, Jul 2, 2009 (IPS) - The future of Palestinian unity talks is far more complex than the bitter rivalry, bloodshed and division which represent the yawning chasm separating Palestine's two main political factions, Hamas and Fatah.

There are serious issues within Fatah that need to be resolved. After two decades of power struggles and acrimony within the organisation, Fatah's Revolutionary Council has agreed to hold its sixth general conference Aug. 4 in Bethlehem in the Palestinian West Bank. Fatah, founded in 1964, is affiliated with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas's Palestinian Authority (PA), which controls the West Bank.

The conference, due to be attended by over 1,500 members, is significant in that it is the first to be held on Palestinian territory. Hitherto, Israel banned leaders from returning to the Palestinian territories. The formerly Tunisia- based Palestinian leadership-in-exile held its last conference in Tunis in 1989 following its expulsion from Lebanon.

Of further relevance is the fact that party members have been able to agree who will attend and where the conference will be held. Infighting and disagreement meant Fatah's factions took 20 years to agree a date and place.

The conference will be an indicator whether the fragmented Fatah is a spent political force and a mere footnote in the history of the Palestinian national liberation struggle. The conference will also lay the groundwork for unity talks with arch-rival Hamas and peace talks with Israel.

Internal Palestinian upheaval has often been reduced to a West Bank PA vs Gaza Strip Hamas political and military struggle. The reality on the ground, however, is not as black. Within both organisations there are power struggles, differing agendas, and contradictory ideologies.

At present Fatah and the PA command little respect either in the West Bank or in Gaza due to continuing accusations of corruption, nepotism and cronyism. The popularity of Hamas, renowned for being austere and more honest, has surged since the Islamic group won free and fair elections in January 2006.

Fatah is fragmented along several lines. Bickering between the 'old guard' and the 'younger guard' remains one of several contentious points.

The older guard, many of them over 65, comprises founding members of the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). Among them, the late Yasser Arafat was one of the main architects of the PLO. Fatah is the largest faction of the PLO; Hamas is not part of the group.

The younger guard was formed by young Palestinian men from the Palestinian territories who cut their political teeth during the first Palestinian Intifadah, or uprising, in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

This membership was joined by Palestinian activists during the second Intifadah which broke out in October 2000, following former Israeli premier Ariel Sharon's provocative visit to Islam's third holiest shrine, the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem, despite warnings from Israel's security services.

Both uprisings came without any direction from the PLO leadership, catching it by surprise.

Following the 1993 Oslo peace accords between Israel and the PLO, some of the old guard returned to the Palestinian territories, and kept up a hedonistic lifestyle at the expense of a Palestinian society wracked by poverty.

This alienated the younger guard who were also angered at the older guard's refusal to share power with them or open up Fatah's leadership to new blood.

The corruption within Fatah was one of the reasons behind Hamas's sweeping 2006 victory. Many Fatah supporters, including a number of Christian Palestinians, voted for Hamas not because they supported its ideology but in protest against the PLO's endemic nepotism.

The PA is staffed with native West Bankers, some of whom are accused of putting their personal prestige, power and business interests above national liberation.

But the divisions in Fatah go beyond generational and accountability issues. Fragmentation has come around patronage, shared history, geography and foreign policy.

Some members support the international peace process, while others call for a return to armed resistance. Some Fatah members want the PA, which was formed after Oslo, to be dismantled; others don't.

Many Palestinians are disillusioned with a lack of democracy and human rights in the West Bank under Abbas's leadership. This is exacerbated by disappointment with a peace process which to many appears to be going nowhere.
Share:

Palestinian Authority detains 13 Hamas members

Members of Palestinian Authority security forces

Palestinian Authority security forces have arrested thirteen members of Hamas in different locations of the West Bank, the resistance movement says.

The Hamas members, detained on Wednesday, were students and academics formerly held in Israeli jails.

The arrests came as representatives from the rival faction of Hamas and Fatah, which controls the West Bank, agreed to hold a new round of reconciliation talks in Cairo next month to reach an agreement on the formation of a unity government and to set up a date for elections.

Hamas accuses Palestinian Authority of disrespecting the ongoing inter- Palestinian peace talks by stepping up its arrest campaign against the supporters of resistance.

Tensions between Hamas and Fatah emerged after Hamas' victory in the 2006 parliamentary elections. Following the elections, Mahmoud Abbas dissolved the democratically elected Hamas government and appointed a Fatah-led Palestinian Authority in the West Bank.
Share:

IOA releases MP Abdelrazek, Fatah preventive security kidnaps his son


NABLUS, (PIC)-- The IOA released Dr. Omar Abdelrazek, a Palestinian lawmaker and the former minister of finance in the 10th government, from the Negev prison Tuesday morning while the Fatah-affiliated preventive security apparatus kidnapped his son Mohamed soon after his release.

In a press statement to the PIC, his family said that Dr. Abdelrazek told them on the phone that he was still in Al-Khalil city and on his way home.

Instead of congratulating him on his freedom, the preventive security kidnapped his son just few hours after he was released from Israeli jails.

Israel kidnapped Dr. Abdelrazek in mid-2006 in the context of the campaign which was waged then against Palestinian lawmakers affiliated with Hamas, then he was released in August 2008 and later re-arrested again at the end of the same year.

In another related context, the PA security apparatuses kidnapped Monday the son of Sheikh Nasr Jarrar, a prominent Qassam leader who was assassinated by the IOF troops in 2002.

They also kidnapped a Palestinian professor called Yousuf Abu Al-Rub from Jalbun town, east of Jenin, and remarkably issued many summonses on Hamas members in Jenin in the last period.

Share:

Hamas hints at extending its term in Palestinian parliament


Gaza Strip, April 23, 2009, (Pal Telegraph) - A senior Hamas leader hinted Thursday that the radical Islamist movement would extend its term in the Palestinian parliament if no agreement was reached with the rival Fatah party, dpa reported.

If an agreement was reached before January 2010, when the term of the current Hamas-dominated parliament expires, the elections would take place that month, "but if the agreement is not reached before January 25, then we will communicate with the factions to endorse a new period," said Mahmoud Zahar, a Hamas leader based in the Gaza Strip.

Hamas defeated the long-dominant Fatah movement led by President Mahmoud Abbas in parliamentary elections in 2006. A year later, Hamas routed pro-Abbas forces and seized control of Gaza, splitting the coastal strip politically from the West Bank.

The Gaza take-over was the culmination of a bitter and at times deadly Hamas-Fatah power struggle, the result of the 2006 parliamentary election and of presidential elections won by Abbas the previous year.

Since then, the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC), seated both in Gaza City and in the West Bank city of Ramallah, has become idle and has not passed any resolution.

Hamas and Fatah have currently resumed talks through Egyptian mediation. They agreed on forming a unity government that would quit when the elections are held in January 2010. However, they failed to agree on the government's programme and the electoral law.

According to Zahar, Hamas has prepared its vision about the outstanding issues and will present it to the Egyptian mediators before another round of talks with Fatah resumes on April 26.

http://news-en.trend.az

Share:

REVEALED: Hamas spokesperson spent first days of Gaza war protected in Fatah home

On the second day of the Israeli war on the Gaza Strip Hamas spokesman Fawzi Barhoum fled and hid in the home of a friend, who was affiliated with Fatah and regularly "coordinated with the Ramallah government," he revealed to journalist Thursday.

In a workshop for journalists and media personnel to discuss coverage of the Israeli war on Gaza Barhoum first applauded Gazan press and broadcast workers for their role in getting the Gaza story to the world. During his speech he also revealed untold stories from the three week onslaught.

Barhoum explained that he stayed in his friend’s house for several days. He was given logistical support during the days before the Israeli ground invasion and protected by his friend and several other Fatah affiliates who joined them in the home.

During his stay in the home Israeli warplanes shelled a building only meters away, shaking its foundations. The missile turned out to be a warning shot and F16s then detonated several more shells on the home, destroying all five floors. He recalled watching the residents flee after the first shots and was relieved that none had been hurt.

Barhoum recalled sitting next to his fellow Hamas spokesperson Ismail Radwan during the first day of the ground invasion. The two thought tanks were approaching their building and considered quickly writing a farewell speech. With the power out they had time to reconsider, however, and decided to wait for the end of the war and deliver a victory speech instead.

Recalling another incident where he was preparing to deliver a statement during the war, Barhoum told a story of his cameramen unable to find a green (for Hamas) flag or sheet to put behind him. "We could only find a yellow flag (for Fatah)," he said. He was about to speak about the death of several children and the tragedies and told the crew, "they will think I have become a Fatah spokesperson." Rather than making the show about politics Barhoum opted for no backdrop and appeared next to a stark white wall.

In a final recollection, Barhoum revealed that moments before one of his last statements during the war, he received a text message saying his eldest son, Baha, had been seriously injured and transferred to hospital. Deciding to continue with the statement was "one of the most difficult personal and human moments" he had ever encountered during his job as Hamas spokesperson, he said.
Share:

Gaza: international plan hatched to bring back Fatah

A plan to create a new foothold in Gaza for the Palestinian Authority and to bring in international monitors was being drawn up by diplomats yesterday as a UN ceasefire call was dismissed by both sides. The plan would allow a return of the authority, led by the secular Fatah faction, to the territory 18 months after it was expelled by the Islamist Hamas. Diplomats are considering taking a triangle at the southern end of Gaza, including the Rafah crossing to Egypt and the Kerem Shalom crossing to Israel, to be policed by Turkish and French military monitors to stop arms smuggling into Gaza.

The zone would nominally be controlled by the authority, the internationally recognised Government. Such a plan would allow the crossings to reopen for the first time since Hamas seized power in Gaza in June 2007.

The plan is being negotiated as part of the Egyptian peace initiative, announced by President Mubarak after talks with President Sarkozy of France, which calls for an immediate ceasefire to be followed by talks on securing the Gaza-Egypt border and reopening the crossings.

It faces formidable obstacles. Diplomats said yesterday that the Egyptian efforts were getting bogged down because of disagreements over how to secure the border. Hamas has said it would consider allowing observers at the border crossings with Egypt but opposes an international force. It also claimed yesterday that a delegation of three Hamas leaders had crossed the border into Egypt to join talks.

Israel, however, is insisting on a robust international force to destroy smuggling tunnels under the border.

Egypt, for its part, does not want international troops on its territory. Instead, Cairo wants to revive the 2005 agreement on movement and access, under which EU monitors oversaw the passage of people through the Rafah crossing and vehicles through Kerem Shalom, a deal that fell through when Hamas came to power. The new plan came as the UN ceasefire proposal was flatly rejected almost as soon as the Security Council backed it 14-0, with the US abstaining.

The US had been expected to back the UN resolution but abstained at the last minute. Diplomats said Condoleezza Rice, the Secretary of State, changed her position after a call from President Bush.

Yesterday F16s continued to fire missiles at houses and apartment blocks in Gaza City, and the air reverberated with artillery fire. The fire was not all one way, though. Rockets repeatedly streaked out of Gaza towards the settlements of Sderot, Beersheba and Ashkelon just across the border.

Ehud Olmert, the Israeli Prime Minister, said: “Israel has never agreed for any outside influence to decide on its right to defend its citizens. The firing of rockets this morning only goes to show that the UN decision is unworkable and will not be adhered to by the murderous Palestinian organisations.”

Israel’s rejection of the resolution was no surprise. The offensive against Hamas is hugely popular: a poll in the Maariv newspaper showed 91 per cent of Israelis supporting it. “This is the time to back the commanders, soldiers and pilots working day and night to conduct a difficult, complex and entirely just war,” Ari Shavit, of the left-of-centre Haaretz newspaper, said.
Share:

The Gaza Massacres Brought to You By:

Today's massacres in Gaza brought to you by Israel who says there will be more ...
May I ask where the Hell is Fatah? And Mahmoud Abbas? Where the hell are Middle Eastern Countries with their Leaders: who the majority who are sellouts to not only Arabs but to the Palestinian Cause and I say are whores to Israel, Europe, and the United States.

Am I mad, yes , I am pissed off! How many more must die at the hands of the Zionist Whores and when will Israel be held to account by the United Nations. When is somebody actually going to do something to stop the current holocaust happening in Gaza?

I don't want to read or hear leaders talk about how this is wrong. I don't want to hear leaders telling Israel to stop and they don't, I want Israel and their leaders brought to justice for their War Crimes.

If shoes are being thrown at George Bush you might as well start throwing shoes at the Majority of leaders in the Middle East and around the world.

Here the some more headlines

GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP - DECEMBER 27: (EDITOR'S NOTE: THIS IMAGE CONTAINS GRAPHIC CONTENT) Bodies of Palestinians laid out on the ground outside Shifa hospital on December 27, 2008 in Gaza City, Gaza. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets along the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds, killing more than 200 people and wounding hundreds. From Getty Images.

Single Bloodiest Day

[U]nprecedented waves of airstrikes Saturday, killing at the time of this publishing at least 205 and wounding more than 310 in the single bloodiest day of fighting in recent memory. . . . Some of the Israeli missiles struck in densely populated areas as children were leaving school, and women rushed into the streets frantically looking for their children. . . . ''We are treating people on the floor, in the corridors. We have no more space. We don't know who is here and what the priority is to treat."
http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2008/12/27/world/AP-ML-Israel-Palestinians.html

Palestinian children and a man wounded in Israeli missile strikes are seen in the emergency area at Shifa hospital in Gaza City, Saturday, Dec. 27, 2008. Israeli warplanes demolished dozens of Hamas security compounds across Gaza on Saturday in unprecedented waves of simultaneous air strikes. Gaza medics said at least 145 people were killed and more than 310 wounded in the single deadliest day in Gaza fighting in recent memory. From AP Photo by Khalil Hamra.
GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP - DECEMBER 27: (EDITOR'S NOTE: THIS IMAGE CONTAINS GRAPHIC CONTENT) A Palestinian man checks the body of a Palestinian child as he lies among bodies of Palestinians laid out on the ground outside Shifa hospital on December 27, 2008 in Gaza City, Gaza. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets along the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds, killing more than 200 people and wounding hundreds. From Getty Images.
GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP- DECEMBER 27: A wounded child awaits medical attention at the Shifa hospital on December 27, 2008 in Gaza City, Gaza. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets along the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds, killing more than 155 people and wounding hundreds. From Getty Images.
Hospitals Overwhelmed
At Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, scores of dead bodies were laid out in front of the morgue waiting for family members to identify them. Many were dismembered.
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/28/world/middleeast/28mideast.html?_r=1&hp

Palestinians look at bodies removed from the sites of Israeli air strikes in Gaza City on December 27, 2008. At least 155 Palestinians were killed across the Gaza Strip today in massive Israeli air strikes on the Hamas-run enclave, Hamas radio reported. Israeli military spokesman Avi Benayahu told army radio the massive bombardment of Gaza was only just beginning. From Getty Images by AFP/Getty Images.
And More Where That Came From
Israeli military spokesman Avi Benayahu said the bombardment of Gaza was "only the beginning."
http://www.russiatoday.com/news/news/35350

An Israeli F16 fighter jet lands at air base near the border after a bombing raid in Gaza December 27, 2008. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets in the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds and killing more than 140 people, medical officials and witnesses said. From Reuters Pictures by REUTERS.
Video (1:38m): Brought to You By . . . U.S. F-16s
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7801128.stm

RAFAH, GAZA STRIP - DECEMBER 27: Palestinian women and children flee an area hit by an Israeli air strike in the southern town of Rafah on December 27, 2008 in Gaza. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets along the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds, killing more than 155 people and wounding hundreds. From Getty Images.
Video (1:41m): Scenes of Destruction in Gaza
This video contains some disturbing images.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7801012.stm

GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP - DECEMBER 27: A Palestinian man cries over the body of a child in his arms, beside bodies of Palestinians laid out on the ground outside Shifa hospital on December 27, 2008 in Gaza City, Gaza. Israel's air force fired about 30 missiles at targets along the Gaza Strip on Saturday, destroying several Hamas police compounds, killing more than 155 people and wounding hundreds. From Getty Images.
Video (4:59m): Witness Describes Gaza Attacks
Fikr Shallpoot, a health worker and resident in Gaza, spoke to the BBC about the attacks that she witnessed.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7801291.stm

Share:

Fatah in turmoil

The sacking of a Palestinian Authority security chief appears to substantiate allegations of direct Fatah collusion with Israel, reports Khaled Amayreh in Ramallah

The sacking by Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas of Intelligence Chief Tawfiq Tirawi on Tuesday seems to be more than just a "formality" related to the latter reaching the age of retirement, as PA spokesmen have been saying.


Tirawi, along with a number of other PA security chiefs, spearheaded the relentless campaign against Hamas's supporters and institutions in the West Bank, even to the point of active coordination and collaboration with Israel.


This fact, which became well known to many Palestinians, including Fatah's followers, eventually rendered most security chiefs a serious liability, undermining Fatah's image as a national liberation movement.


Moreover, critics, including Hamas, have used the "excesses" to portray the PA as a quisling entity working in concert with Israel against the national cause.


Last month, a number of security chiefs met with commanders of the Israeli army at the settlement of Beit El near Ramallah and reportedly told them: "Israel and the PA are allies against a common enemy, which is Hamas."


According to Israeli journalist Nahom Barnea, who attended the meeting with the Palestinian officers' consent, the Palestinian participants asked their Israeli "colleagues" for weapons and training for the purpose of "re-conquering the Gaza Strip".


Moreover, according to Barnea, the Palestinians also sought to impress the Israeli occupation commanders by citing their crackdown on Hamas in the West Bank, with one of them saying, "we usually do more than you ask us to do," and "we don't even flinch from entering the mosques when we have to."


News of the meeting, dubbed by Fatah as a public relations disaster, spread fast through the Internet and in the Hebrew press, embarrassing Fatah and prompting some of its veteran leaders to ask Abbas to fire the security chiefs immediately.


Munzer Irsheid, a former mayor of Jericho and former security figure, now residing in Jordan, suggested in an article published in September that the security chiefs were "traitors to Fatah" and "traitors to Palestine".


Similarly, Qaddura Fares, a Fatah MP and close confidante to imprisoned Fatah leader Marwan Al-Barghouti, called for the "immediate sacking" of the security chiefs who he said didn't represent Fatah.


The Beit El meeting, along with the perceived close collaboration between the security agencies and the Israeli occupation army, continued to reverberate in the Palestinian arena, with Hamas calling on Abbas to "oust the traitors from your midst".


One Hamas official in the Hebron region remarked: "How can we possibly have a serious national unity dialogue with people who claim to be patriotic Palestinians in daylight hours while at night they coordinate with the Israeli army the next wave of arrests against our people?"


Earlier this month Fatah MP Isa Qaraqi castigated members of the security agencies, describing them as "panicking rabbits". He pointed out that thousands of PA security personnel, who are supposed to provide protection for the Palestinian people, flee to their "coops" whenever Israeli occupation troops storm Palestinian population centres.


Qaraqi's mordant broadside drew sharp reactions from Tirawi and other security officials who responded by arguing that the security agencies gave numerous martyrs for Palestine and that people who drive smart cars and receive hefty salaries were not in a position to question the nationalistic credentials of the soldiers of Palestine.


Tirawi hinted that Qaraqi was effectively aiding Hamas by questioning the integrity of the security agencies. Qaraqi's supporters retorted forcefully by arguing that "true soldiers of Palestine" don't spend convivial nights with Israeli occupation army chiefs. "If you are not capable of protecting us, and if you are not capable of protecting yourselves, then what is the justification for your very existence?" one Fatah activist wrote last week.


The heated exchange reflects a growing polarisation between two camps within the Fatah movement: the nationalist, or "Arafatist" camp, which is faithful to the legacy of Yasser Arafat and is determined to maintain the "purity" of the national struggle for independence and freedom; and the so-called "pragmatic camp", namely the careerist-minded Oslo-era beneficiaries who have profited immensely as a result of the status-quo.


The first camp is represented by such people as Marwan Al-Barghouti and his supporters, Hani Al-Hassan, Farouk Qaddumi and a large number of Fatah MPs and leaders, especially at the grassroots and intermediate levels. The second camp encompasses the security chiefs, PA operatives and functionaries who are small in terms of numbers but powerful due to foreign -- especially American -- backing and who control the coffers of the PA, Fatah, and the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO).


President Abbas and his leading aides, such as Ahmed Qurei, Saeb Ereikat, Nabil Amr and Nabil Shaath are often seen trying to bridge the gap between the two camps in order to present Fatah as a united front, especially in the face of Hamas. However, these bridging efforts have not been successful.


Last week, when top Fatah leaders met in Amman in an effort to set a date for holding the repeatedly delayed Sixth Fatah Congress, acrimonious exchanges between Abbas and Qaddumi underscored the serious chasm between the pro- and anti-Oslo camps. Qaddumi reportedly told Abbas that "You are no Yasser Arafat" and that, "You can't hold all these portfolios at the same time."


Abbas is chief of the PLO, chief of Fatah and president of the PA, which means that people like Qaddumi are effectively marginalised.


Nonetheless, the real issue impeding -- even preventing -- the convening of the congress is that the "pragmatists" (i.e. those who would keep up the peace process no matter what Israel does) are worried that they might be voted out of office in the event that Fatah's rank and file are allowed to decide who Fatah's next leaders will be.


Earlier, Intesar Al-Wazeer, Um Jihad, the widow of murdered Fatah military commander Khalil Al-Wazeer (who was assassinated in Tunis by Mossad in 1989) told the London-based Al-Hayat newspaper that there is "a conspiracy to weaken and marginalise Fatah" by "people who claim to be Fatah".


Al-Wazeer accused "people around Mahmoud Abbas" of being "indifferent to Fatah" and of "catering only for their own interests". She also accused Abbas of "only consulting with a small coterie of people around him" who she suggested had a different agenda.


The meeting in Amman ended inconclusively with no definite date set for the congress, although a statement issued by Hakam Balaawi, Fatah's secretary, said that there was a determination to hold the congress before the end of 2008. Balaawi's statement, however, can't be taken for granted for several reasons.


First, more than two years of intensive negotiations with Israel as well as several high-profile international peace conferences have failed to achieve a breakthrough towards ending the 41-year-old Israeli occupation. It is unlikely that Abbas and his supporters will go "empty-handed" to an all-important convention that would determine their political future.


Second, the new US administration and growing political instability in Israel is not conducive to holding a successful Fatah congress and might even militate in favour of the "radicals" who are fed-up with a peace process that has only seen more Palestinian land being stolen by Israel and the dream of Palestinian statehood shattered.

Still, failure to hold the congress before the end of 2008 would undoubtedly complicate things further within Fatah and increase frustration among the movement's supporters, especially at the grassroots levels, which is further bad news for Abbas.
Share:

Rice wants tension among Palestinians

Hamas spokesman Fawzi Barhoum
Hamas Spokesman Fawzi Barhoum has accused the US Secretary of State of trying to obstruct ongoing efforts for Palestinian unity.

Fawzi Barhoum said that the October visit by State Secretary Condoleezza Rice will aim at fomenting discord among Palestinians and preventing the formation of a new Palestinian unity government.

Washington seeks to prevent any accord between Palestinians, knowing that any such agreement is contrary to the interest of the US and its ally Israel, Barhoum added.

Palestinian groups, headed by the Hamas and Fatah movements, have been invited by Egypt to attend a meeting in Cairo in the first week of November to prepare their strategy to face the current crisis.

Rice is scheduled to visit the Middle East ahead of the Cairo meeting, in mid-October.

The spokesman said Rice is using every method available to prevent Palestinian Authority Chief Mahmoud Abbas from negotiating with the Hamas movement.

Tensions between Hamas and Fatah arose after Hamas' victory in the 2006 parliamentary elections. Following the elections, Mahmoud Abbas dissolved the Hamas-led government and appointed a Fatah-led Palestinian Authority in the West Bank. Hamas responded by taking control of the Gaza Strip.

Hamas and Fatah have not held direct talks since then.
Share:

The Joke of Palestinian “democracy” under Fatah, Israel

Comment by Khalid Amayreh in occupied Palestine

Jockeying for an advantageous public posture vis-à-vis Hamas, the Fatah movement has been calling for the organization of presidential and parliamentary elections in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The proposal is being touted as the only way to resolve the enduring crisis between Fatah and Hamas, following the latter’s counter-coup in Gaza in June of last year.

The proposal, however, seems to be more of a propagandist gambit than a sincere effort aimed at achieving inter-Palestinian reconciliation.

And it doesn’t suggest that Fatah, now solidly backed and financed by the United States, has undergone a true democratic transformation.

Indeed, Fatah today remains the same Fatah that only reluctantly and under American pressure agreed to allow general elections to take place in 2006- and only because Fatah leaders seemed then certain they would win.

However, when Hamas won the polls by a wide margin, Fatah couldn’t swallow the bitter bill and decided to embark on every conceivable act of sabotage in order to undercut Hamas and destabilize its rule. Some observers believe that Fatah took a secret decision to bring the would-be Hamas government down as soon as elections results were announced.

True, some Fatah leaders publicly accepted the results of the election. However, in reality, they sought to narrow Hamas horizons by effectively and actively joining the American-led open war against Hamas, a war that is yet to come to an end.

A few years ago, I remember I listened to a secret audio-taped briefing by Muhammed Dahlan to his supporters at al Hurriya radio station in Gaza. In that infamous briefing, Dahlan swore to make Hamas regret the day it decided to take part in the election.

“I will make them eat…expletive, and if any Fatah guy dares participate in the Hamas government, I will know how to deal with him.”

Dahlan added that “ I will send a few jeeps here and there and give the impression that Gaza is on fire.”

Dahlan made more horrifying remarks that one would refrain from mentioning to maintain the dignity of language.

Subsequently, Fatah, or more correctly the American-empowered camp within the movement, actively collaborated with the CIA and Israel to “make the Hamas experiment fail” lest it be repeated elsewhere in the Middle East and the rest of the Muslim world.

The idea was very simple: Impose draconian economic and financial strangulation as much as possible on ordinary Palestinians to make them not only regret their erstwhile decision to vote for Hamas but also actively turn against the Islamic movement in ways analogous to the many CIA-induced coups in Latin and Central America.

Earlier this year, the American magazine “Vanity Fair” published an extensive investigative report titled “How the Bush Administration Lied to Congress and Armed Fatah to Provoke Palestinian Civil War Aiming to Overthrow Hamas.”

The report pointed out that the White House tried to organize the armed overthrow of the Hamas-led government after Hamas swept Palestinian elections in 2006.

According to the report, the Bush administration lied to Congress and boosted military support for rival Palestinian faction Fatah in the aim of provoking a Palestinian civil war they thought Hamas would lose.

Vanity Fair dubbed the episode “Iran Contra 2.0″—a reference to the Reagan administration’s funding of Nicaraguan Contras by covertly selling arms to Iran.

A former top Bush administration official said he believed Hamas’s seizure of power in Gaza last year might have likely been a preemptive measure against the anticipated US-backed coup.

The official, David Wurmser, served as Vice President Cheney’s Middle East adviser until he resigned in July of 2007, a month after Hamas took over. Wurmser said, “There is a stunning disconnect between the President’s call for Middle East democracy and this policy. It directly contradicts it.”

Clearly embarrassed, Fatah, as expected, belittled the credibility of the report, dismissing it as “grossly inaccurate.”

So now Fatah is asking for early elections while being completely oblivious to a host of important questions pertaining to the elections. Such questions include the following:


First, Will Israel and the American administration, which consider Hamas a “terrorist organization” (not for the violence but for insisting on Palestinian rights, especially the right of return for Palestinian refugees), allow free and transparent elections to take place in light of the “
disastrous experiment” of 2006?

Fatah leaders may argue, mostly for the sake of argument, that that the elections are an internal Palestinian matter. Well, this is true, but we all know that the PA is not a state, let alone a sovereign one. We also know that the PA is 150% subservient to the US which is in turn subservient to Israel. So why speak to the monkey when you can speak to organ grinder?!!

Second, let us argue, at least for the sake of argument, that Hamas won the elections, so would Fatah accept the results this time? Would the tens of thousands of American-trained and American-paid anti-Hamas soldiers in the West Bank accept the jurisdiction of the new Hamas-led government?

In fact, it would be more than naïve to think that they would. We are talking after all about security forces whose raison d’être is to fight and annihilate Hamas as is evident from the vindictive campaign against suspected Hamas supporters and Islamic institutions now underway all over the West Bank.

Third, let us imagine that Fatah would accept the results, even if these results proved to be not to its liking. But would Israel? Indeed, are there guarantees that the Israeli occupation army, which controls every corner and every street in the West Bank, wouldn’t round up the “wrong candidates” and the “wrong winners” and dump them in Israeli dungeons and concentration camps all over occupied Palestine as it has done the last time elections were held?

Israel, for those who have forgotten, continues to detain for the third consecutive year hundreds of elected Palestinian officials, including mayors, local council members, and, especially, as many as 40 elected lawmakers and former cabinet ministers.

The main “crime” committed by these elected Palestinian officials, people like Professor Aziz Duweik, the Speaker of the Palestinian parliament, is that they took part in an “illegal election”! Well, this is really a big lie since the 2006-Palestinian elections were okayed by both Israel, under the premiership of Ariel Sharon, and the Bush Administration.

This scandalous and gangsterly conduct by a state that calls itself the only democracy in the Middle East is a clarion proof that democracy under a foreign military occupation is a big farce.

To be sure, this is a message that all Palestinian factions, particularly Fatah and Hamas, ought to comprehend and internalize.

Failing to do so will make us the laughingstock of the world.

Share:

Human chain in Rafah urges Palestinian national unity

Palestinians linked arms in a human chain in the city of Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip, on Wednesday in a demonstration urging Hamas and Fatah to end their rivalry and reunite the Palestinian people.

The protest was organized by the National Association for Democracy and Law in association with dozens of civil society organizations in the Gaza Strip

A Hamas-Fatah unity government disintegrated in June 2007 following deadly fighting between Hamas and Fatah in the Gaza Strip. Since then Hamas has remained in control of Gaza, Fatah the West Bank.

Ibrahim Mu'ammar, the director of the association, said the rivalry between the two movements has a negative affect on the human rights of Palestinians. He urged civil society organizations to speak out and demand national unity.

He also appealed to Arab countries to place pressure on both rivals to achieve national unity.

Representatives of other organizing groups delivered speeches calling on Hamas and Fatah to give priority to higher Palestinian interests over their own partisan interests. The rivalry, they said, threatens the Palestinian cause itself.
Share:

Islamic Jihad leader speaks to the press about Gaza, Palestine, unity


Islamic Jihad leader Muhammad Al-Hindi gave an interview with Gaza's weekly paper Al-Istiqlal, and spoke about conditions in Gaza, the state of Palestine and ideas about national unity.Al-Hindi prefaced his interview with the statement, “challenges and dangers have taken place in the Palestinian arena recently, which affect the very essence of whatever it is that we call “Palestinian.” The widening gap between Hamas and Fatah despite the frequent proposals of different sides to resume internal dialogue to get out of current crisis is troubling."

A positive atmosphere for the launch of an internal Palestinian dialogue is essential, according to Al-Hindi. He said that dialogue would be useless if it occurred without the support of many Palestinians devoted to the efforts. He sited political persuasion and detentions across the West Bank and the Gaza Strip as one of the things that must stop in order to create the positive atmosphere.

Islamic Jihad has been working towards carrying out dialogues with those in Ramallah and Gaza, he added. It was these efforts, he noted, which resulted in the release of a number of detainees, saying that this was not enough and all political detainees should be released as soon as possible.

The current Palestinian situation, he said, serves Israel by allowing it to surround and close off Gaza, and at the same time take advantage of instability in the West Bank to continue confiscating lands and constructing settlements.

As the term of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas comes to an end in January-February, Al-Hindi said he was afraid that the next months will witness escalations in factional disagreements.

With regard to truce, Al-Hindi added: “the truce hasn’t ended the blockade and there is a large resentment of continuation of such a situation.” He called on all resistance factions to meet and evaluate the situation of the truce and to take a united course with regards to its future.

Whether Olmert stayed or left the leadership of Israel, he said, nothing would change since all Israeli parties agree on basic issues used in dealing with Palestinians especially Jerusalem, borders, settlements and refugees.

Israeli talk about invading Gaza is just election propaganda, he said, adding, "any invasion wouldn't be a picnic for Israeli army".
Share:

Dialogue of the deaf?

Are Fatah and Hamas really going to talk, asks Khaled Amayreh in Ramallah

In a terse speech marking 41 years since the 1967 Arab- Israeli war, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas called for a broad national dialogue with Hamas that would bolster national unity and place the Palestinian people in a better position to end Israel's occupation of the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem.

"I call for a comprehensive national dialogue in order to implement the Yemeni initiative [between Fatah and Hamas]... We are doing this in order to end the national division that has caused the worst damage ever to our cause and increased the level of suffering of our people in Gaza," said Abbas.

"For this national dialogue to succeed I will act on the Arab and international levels to secure the support we need to augment the move in a way that will restore to our people their national unity and provide a stronger guarantee for the restoration of our inalienable rights to self determination, return and independent statehood."

Abbas, who has been meeting with Arab leaders to expedite his initiative, said he would call for new presidential and legislative elections but did not say if the holding of such elections would be conditional on a successful outcome of the dialogue with Hamas or, indeed, the conclusion of a peace agreement with Israel.

After a brief visit to Egypt on Monday where he met with President Hosni Mubarak, Nabil Amro, Palestinian ambassador to Cairo, announced plans for Egypt to host a meeting of all the Palestinian factions.

On 7 June, a day after Abbas gave his speech, Ismail Haniyeh, prime minister of the ousted Hamas government in Gaza, welcomed Abbas's overture and urged him to take "swift steps" to facilitate the holding of a fruitful dialogue.

Haniyeh called for political prisoners to be released, offices reopened and civil servants sacked because of their political affiliation to be reinstated. He urged Abbas to order his security forces to stop arresting Hamas supporters in the West Bank as an expression of good will. Haniyeh also called for an immediate end to the year-old propaganda war between Fatah and Hamas and said he had instructed Hamas's media in Gaza to stop attacks on the Palestinian Authority and Fatah.

In return Nimr Hammad, chief advisor to and spokesman for Abbas, ordered the suspension of incitement against Hamas "in the interest of Palestinian national unity".

Observers in Palestine see Abbas's speech as a tacit acknowledgement that American-backed peace talks with Israel have failed. The speech suggested that Abbas now despairs of even a semblance of US evenhandedness towards the Palestinians, especially after George Bush's speech before the Knesset in which he displayed his administration's complete infatuation with Israel.

But Abbas's speech could also be interpreted as a defensive reflex to counter recent decisions by Israel which his critics argue underscore Israel's disregard for the entire peace process, including a new law enacted by the Knesset adopting Jerusalem, including Arab-East Jerusalem, as the eternal capital of Israel and the Jewish people, as well as Olmert's government's dogged insistence on settlement building in the West Bank.

Abbas's speech coincided with the first anniversary of Hamas's counter-coup in Gaza and the failure of Israeli, American, European and Fatah efforts to destroy the Hamas government through economic blockade.

One Fatah official told Al-Ahram Weekly that the PA in Ramallah feels increasingly that the Bush administration is treating it as if it were a "quisling entity" rather than the national representative authority of the Palestinian people.

"I think some of our people here have got the feeling that the US and Israel were utilising the Fatah-Hamas rift to place the PA under American-Israeli tutelage and cripple its ability to recover Palestinian rights. Abbas's speech can be seen as a sort of wakening from this illusion."

While most Palestinians welcomed Abbas's call for unconditional national dialogue, some Palestinians question whether the PA leadership in Ramallah really has the will to pursue successful reconciliation talks with Hamas given its near total dependence on American financial and political backing.

US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice reportedly conveyed to Abbas her "worries" about any rapprochement with Hamas without the latter first recognising Israel, renouncing armed resistance and accepting the peace process.

Meanwhile, Israel this week temporarily paralysed the Palestinian government in Ramallah by refusing to transfer Palestinian tax revenues, forcing the American-backed Fayyad government to postpone the payment of salaries to more than 160,000 civil servants for a week. One Palestinian commentator viewed the move as a "stern warning" to the PA against mending bridges with Hamas.

"If they are willing to sever payment of customs revenues to the PA, imagine what they would do if Fatah and Hamas agreed to establish a government of national unity," said Hani Al-Masri.

Statements issued on Tuesday by Amro are already predicting problems ahead. He told reporters: "US, American and I don't want to say Arab pressures" have been exercised over Abbas to retreat from his call for direct talks with Hamas.

Meanwhile, Damascus-based Hamas political bureau chief Khaled Meshaal on Tuesday called for a meeting between eight Palestinian factions to be held in the Syrian capital next week "to boost national unity".

Last week Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni openly warned Abbas against "getting closer to Hamas".

"Abbas knows the Israeli position in this regard," Livni told the Israeli state-run radio.

Some pro-Hamas pundits privately accuse Abbas, whose term in office has six months to run, of electioneering. Abbas had indicated on several occasions that he was close to resigning and would not seek a second term as president of the PA, statements that have been discounted as an attempt to pressure Israel to be more forthcoming in peace talks.

This week Ahmed Qurei, number-two in the PA's political hierarchy, told reporters that Fatah was for general legislative and presidential elections and that Abbas would be Fatah's candidate for the post of PA chair. Abbas's extended hand may well be a tactical gesture aimed at placing the PA leadership in an advantageous position vis-à-vis the elections.

Many Hamas supporters are unlikely to give Abbas the benefit of the doubt. They would argue that Abbas's speech is a pre-emptive gesture, likely to be followed by a wide-scale Israeli invasion of Gaza. In this case, goes the argument here, Abbas will be able to deny any collusion or connivance with Israel, pointing to his call for rapprochement with the Islamic movement. (see pp.6&amp7)

Share:

Qurei denies reports that 3 million US dollars was diverted to his joint bank account




Please Mr El Batoun give
back some of the $3 million
to the people so they can buy
some bread to feed their kids....

We will return reports

Ramallah – Ma'an - Head of the Palestinian negotiating team
Ahmed Qurei ( aka Abu El Batoun)has denied reports published
by a number of news websites that three million US dollars has
been diverted to a joint bank account he holds with two
unknown persons.


Qurei told Ma'an that the money is part of five million dollars
given to Fatah and the Palestine Liberation Organisation and
the bank account mentioned in the news reports is the bank
account of the Palestinian National Fund in the Arab
Bank in Amman.


He said he did not know who was behind the news stories or
what was the motive behind publishing such accusations and
demanded legal action should be brought against those who
were trying to discredit him."I would like to clarify that this
amount is part of the five million dollars for the benefit of
both Fatah and the PLO, and that the account number
111444/713 noted in the letter named "Adli Sadeq" to
Mohammed Dahlan, is the account of the Palestinian
National Fund in the Arab Bank in Jordan,"
Qurei told Ma'an.


"The Account No. 21250/510 referred to in the letter refers
to the account of the Palestinian National Liberation Movement
(Fatah) in the Arab Bank in Jordan. The account is in the names
of different persons known to the movement and the decision of
the leadership since the mid-eighties and the start of the Fatah
movement was to register the account in the names of different
persons for security reasons," he added.


"This five million dollars was deposited on behalf of the
late president Yasser Arafat in the name of the secretariats
of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Fatah
movement," he said.

Share:

Tragedy of Israel and Palestine

By Mark Levine




The father of 18 days-old newborn
Palestinian baby girl
Amira Abu Asr, who was shot in the head by Israeli soldiers,
mourns during her funeral on March 5 [GALLO/GETTY]

Americans have grown so accustomed to the disastrous

dynamics operating between Israelis and Palestinians today

that the failure to reach a peace deal amid the soaring death

tolls assumes an aura of normalcy in their minds.

This reflects a situation we imagine ourselves to be

powerless to help change and only adds to the tragedy

unfolding in the Occupied Territories and Israel as well.

Today the world's attention has turned to the aftermath

of the murder of eight students of an ultra-Zionist Mercaz

HaRav yeshiva, established by the founder of religious

zionism, Rabbi Avraham Isaac Kook in 1924.

Last week the focus was the ongoing war in Gaza,

which will likely be the centre of attention next week as well.

The attacks on religious students in the midst of

study and prayer - coupled with the ongoing rocket

attacks from Gaza on the Israeli towns of Sderot and

Ashkelon - are already being offered as the latest

examples of continued Palestinian unwillingness

to make peace with Israel more than two years after

its unprecedented withdrawal from the Gaza Strip.

activist injured in protest against the wall


World's largest prison

But there are many problems with this argument; firstly,

most of the acts of Palestinian resistance to the occupation

have always been non-violent.

Equally important is the fact that while Israeli civilians no longer

live in Gaza, Israel's military presence has never ended.


Tel Aviv withdrew civilian settlers and then threw away the key

to what has now become the world's largest prison.

Ariel Sharon, the former Israeli prime minister and the architect

of the settlement movement, was willing to sacrifice Gaza in order

to ensure Israel held onto the major settlement blocs of the West

Bank, which today house more than 250,000 settlers

(almost double that number if one includes the Jewish

settlements in East Jerusalem).

The settler population of the West Bank also doubled during

the years of the Oslo "peace" process - which began when

Abu Dahim was about 12 and ended when he was 19 -

without a whimper of complaint from the United States.

By the time Yitzhak Rabin, the former prime minister,

was assassinated in 1995, Palestinian leaders were warning

that the continued settlement expansion was "killing" the peace

process and would sooner or later lead to a "revolution"

from the street.

Matrix of control

The presence of well over 100 settlements

has necessitated a matrix of control in which

80 per cent of the West Bank be declared off

limits to Palestinians.

It also meant the destruction of thousands of homes

and olive and fruit trees (the backbone of an otherwise

closed Palestinian economy), the confiscation

of 35,000 acres of Palestinian land, and the creation

of a network of bypass roads, military bases.

The 400-kilometre, 8-metre-high "separation

wall" also pierces deep into Palestinian territory, cutting

into at least three isolated cantons.

Together, the settlement system has made the idea of

creating a territorially and economically viable Palestinian

state impossible to implement.

With the eruption of the al-Aqsa intifada in September 2000

whatever infrastructure of peace had been created during

Oslo was quickly dismantled by both sides.

By mid-2002 Israel began deploying a strategy of managed

chaos, in which a near total closure of the Territories, coupled

with a destruction of much of their economic and political

infrastructure, turned the intifada into what Palestinians term

an "intifawda," a neologism that brings the violence of the

intifada together with the chaos, or "fawda" of a society

living in a barely functioning state and economy.


Israel's Apartied Wall cuts a broad path

through Palestinian olive groves



Dividing Palestine

Israeli planners gambled that by splitting the West Bank from Gaza,

deepening the occupation of the former while freeing itself of the

settlements in the latter, and routinely deploying disproportionate

violence (including tanks, helicopter gunships, F-16s, and heavily

armed troops) against all signs of resistance, Palestinian society

would begin turning on itself.

Indeed, Israel hoped for this when it clandestinely supported

the emergence of Hamas two decades ago, with the goal of

building up a rival to the Palestine Liberation Organisation

(PLO) that would have them fighting each other rather than

figuring out more successful strategies of fighting the occupation.

But, even as Palestinians fight each other, resistance to

the occupation has continued. Most of it is comprised of

various forms of non-violence (marches, sit-ins, and

attempts to stop home demolitions or replant uprooted

fields or groves).

These are rarely covered by the international media,

and are usually met with violence by the Israeli

military or settlers.

Fairly or not, however, it has been Palestinian violence,

and especially suicide bombings and now rocket attacks

on civilians, that have defined their resistance to the

ongoing occupation.

Suicidal suicide attacks

And in this regard the actions have been nothing short

of suicidal - Palestinian "resistance" to the occupation

seems to have been scripted by Israel as it has suited the

interests of the Israeli governments in power since 2000.

As Haaretz columnist Bradley Burston recently put it:

"The Palestinians have kept their ultimate doomsday

weapon under tight wraps for 40 years ... Israeli senior

commanders could only pray that the Palestinians

would never take it out and put it to actual use ...

non-violence. This is one reason why, for decades,

Israel did its best to head off, harass, and crack down

on expressions of Palestinian non-violence."

If Palestinians ever decided to just "get up and walk" en masse to

the Erez Crossing separating Gaza from Israel and the major

West Bank check points like Qalandiya and used hammers and

picks to tear them down, there would be almost nothing Israel

could do, short of a massacre in full view of the world's cameras.

But Palestinians have become so stuck in the ideology of

summud, (which naturally become a national imperative

after a million Palestinians were uprooted in the 1948 and

1967 wars), or defiantly staying put, that they have rarely

taken the strategic or moral offensive.

When they applied the moral approach during the first intifada,

Israel's harsh crackdown coupled with PLO dominance of

Palestianian politics, ensured the de-politicisation and

disempowerment of the first "intifada generation".

Two weeks ago, when a few brave Palestinians tried to

organise a peaceful march to the Erez border crossing to

build on the momentum gained by breaching the border fence

between Gaza and Egypt, they were stopped far from the border

by a line of heavily armed Hamas policemen.

Soon after, the day's ration of rockets was fired into the nearby

Israeli town of Sderot, wounding two Israeli children.

Israel responded with a new rounds of attacks by

Israel, killing and wounding more Palestinians.

How to stop?

A few years ago, in a particularly violent moment of the intifada,

I interviewed a senior Hamas leader at his office in Gaza.

After the usual boiler plate questions and answers, I finally

grew exasperated and said to him, "Look, let's put aside the

question of whether you have the right to use violence,

particularly against civilians, to pursue your ends.

The simple fact is that the strategy has not worked."

His response stunned me with its honesty:

"We know the violence doesn't work, but we don't

know how to stop."

In a mirror image of Israeli strategic thinking, Hamas

has remained unable to break free of the dangerously

outdated paradigm that says violence, particularly against

civilians, can only be met by even more violence until the

other side yields.

Aside from the moral turpitude of such thinking by both

sides - not to mention blatant illegality according to

international law - the reality, at least in the near term,

is that the human and political cost of such a policy for

Israel is far lower than for Palestinians, who have very little

time left before their dreams of independence are

crushed for good.

Ehud Olmert, Israel's prime minister, has himself admitted,

the day Palestinians give up on the dream of an independent

state will be the day Israel will "face a South African-style

struggle for equal voting rights, and as soon as that happens,

the state of Israel is finished."

Dysfunctional dynamics

But so dysfunctional are the current dynamics that

neither side seems willing to take the first step away

from the abyss.

In such a situation, only a strong outside party can force

the warring sides to make the hard compromises necessary

to achieve a just and lasting peace.

This was the job the US signed up for in 1993, when Bill Clinton,

then president, witnessed the signing of the first Oslo agreement

on the White House lawn. But we have failed miserably in our

self-appointed role as "honest broker."

It's not just that US has unapologetically taken Israel's side

on almost every major issue since then.

During the Oslo years the US worked hand in glove with the

Israeli and Palestinian security services to stifle dissent within

Palestinian civil society, or the Legislative Council, to a

process that was moving away from rather than towards a

just and lasting peace.

And with the militarisation of US foreign policy after September

11 and the sullied occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq, Israel has

had even greater carte blanche to inflict precisely the kind of

damage upon Palestinian society we are witnessing now in Gaza.

Blood of children

By refusing to press Israel - as many Israeli commentators, and

an increasing number of US policy-makers as well, urge - to

negotiate with Hamas we have not just enabled the current

violence, but are directly responsible for it.

Hamas has declared its willingness to negotiate a two-state solution,

albeit under conditions to which Israel has little incentive to accept.

The blood of Israeli and Palestinian children that

appears on TV is on our hands too.

It would be nice if we could imagine that the next US president

will have the courage to "change" this dynamic.

But there is little chance of that.

The only hope is that Israeli and Palestinian societies come

together to stop the violence their leaders keep inflicting on

them before the delusions of victory on both sides cross the

line into psychosis.

Mark LeVine is professor of history at UCI Irvine and author

or editor of half a dozen books dealing with the Israeli-Palestinian

conflict and globalisation in the Middle East, including

Overthrowing Geography: Jaffa, Tel Aviv and the Struggle

for Palestine, Reapproaching Borders: New Perspectives on

the Study of Israel and Palestine, Why They Don't Hate Us:

Lifting the Veil on the Axis of Evil, and the forthcoming An

Impossible Peace: Oslo and the Burdens of History.

Share: