Showing posts with label The View. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The View. Show all posts

An Open Letter to Mahmoud Abbas - President of the Palestinian National Authority

We the Palestinian Canadian community assembly at the Palestinian National Voice Preparatory Conference in Hamilton, Canada, issue this letter out of profound concern regarding the present state of the Palestinian national struggle and the November 2007 “peace” conference to be hosted by the United States in Annapolis, Maryland.

While Palestinians still suffer from the disaster of the Oslo Accords, the Palestinian National Authority has now agreed to attend another round of flawed negotiations. This time it does so under the pressure of North American and European nations that have actively collaborated with Israel to divide the Palestinian people and inflict collective punishment and other war crimes against them.

Even now
Israel is being allowed to deny the Palestinians the basic necessities for a functioning society through a humiliating siege against the Palestinian people in response to the exercise of Palestinian democracy and the adherence to its results.

It is our belief that the purpose of the
Annapolis round of negotiations is to extract further critical concessions from the Palestinians while further delaying final status agreements. In particular, we believe that Israel will attempt to redefine the conflict with the Palestinians as being only about ending the occupation of Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza, or parts thereof. Such a redefinition leads the Palestinians into the trap of the “two-state” formula which subverts our legitimate rights under international law. We stress that the central issue in the Palestinian conflict with Israel has always been the dispossession of the Palestinian people from their land and property caused by the Zionist ethnic cleansing of 1948 and the Israeli denial to Palestinians of the basic human right to return and to live in peace and security as equal citizens on their land.

We further specifically caution you against any recognition of
Israel as a “Jewish” state. Such a recognition would give Israel the façade of moral and legal legitimacy while critically compromising the full implementation of the inalienable Palestinian right of return. In addition, it would contradict the struggle by Palestinian citizens of Israel to maintain their identity and gain equal rights as citizens. We point out that Israel was established through United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181 (Partition Resolution) which does not envisage or consent to the establishment of states on a religious or ethnic basis.

In addition, we underscore that
Israel was admitted as a member of the United Nations on the basis of its having recognized the full right of return of the Palestinian people on the basis of United Nations General Assembly Resolution 194 (Right of Return Resolution).

Today it is more apparent than ever that the only basis on which peace can be brought to the historic
land of Palestine is through the establishment of a unified secular democratic state in which all citizens are equal and share the same rights and responsibilities regardless of a citizen’s religion.

Palestinians can only be properly represented through a delegation representing the united Palestinian people. Accordingly, it is essential that the internal dispute between Ramallah and
Gaza be resolved before Palestinians participate in any negotiations with the Israelis.

In addition, the ultimate decision on what Palestinians can accept can only be determined by a fully elected and democratically effective Palestinian National Council (PNC) representing all of the world’s 10 million Palestinians.

Palestinians who are denied the right to participate in elections to the PNC cannot be regarded as having consented to any agreement made in their name. The re-activation of the PNC as a fully elected and democratically effective body would also have the effect of re-energizing the Palestine Liberation Organization as a legitimate instrument of the Palestinian people.

We stress that any attempt to establish peace and security in the
land of Palestine can only be successful if it is firmly based on natural justice and the principles of international law. We reconfirm that the right of the Palestinian people to return to their homes and property and to receive full compensation for all damage done to their property as well as for all other losses associated with the violation of their rights by Zionist forces is both an inalienable individual and collective right.

Any Palestinian leadership that suggests that the inalienable Palestinian right of return can be negotiated away abrogates any legitimacy it may have had to speak in the name of the Palestinian people.
Share:

Going Home (Part 1) - However Long it Takes.'

BEHIND THE WALL: 'Going Home

(Part 1) – However Long it Takes…'


"I could see only an Israeli settlement instead of Ras Abu Amar. There was a checkpoint that stopped us from entering the village. I took photos from a distance but I found all the land was now a settlement. I felt this is not my village anymore and that they had taken it from me. This is my village but I could not enter it…"

Mohammed is angry as he talks. He displays a passion which may have seemed surprising for a child of just thirteen years of age had I not spent so much time with children inside Palestine's refugee camps. Children who, much like their parents, have lived their whole life in forced exile.

Ras Abu Amar was not the first village we had visited that morning. The day had begun in Al Malha, a village that has now been eaten up and seemingly swallowed by the sprawling judaisation of Al Quds. Blue street signs in Hebrew, a zoo, a train station, the city's largest sports stadium, and thousands of Israeli houses covered the site which until 1948 was home to many Palestinians. It was like a Zionist rewriting of history, or rather a history that never existed seemed the impression intended. But whilst the comfortable signs can mislead, distort, or even mask the horrible truths they hide, they will never completely bury the ethnic cleansing which they try to deny. As we headed up a hill in Al Malha a literal tower of strength stretched out and above the surrounding houses. It had resisted the all encompassing sprawl of development. If we were lost on a dark night at sea then this tower was our lighthouse. It was the ancient Palestinian mosque that had served the village and its residents for years until they were chased out in 1948.

When Theodore Hertzl, the founding father of the Zionist dream, described Palestine as 'a land without people for a people without land' he had intended the world to believe such propaganda, and whilst countless governments internationally have attempted to help spread such lies this resilient minaret, and the 750,000 people who were forced from their homeland, would never accept a life in silence. Now, these 750,000 original exiles have become literally millions of Palestinian refugees and the lies are horrifically clear to all.

As children skipped playfully into the new Israeli school opposite the mosque, and bounced basketballs around its playground, I stood outside with Rawan and Samah, two girls born into a crowded refugee camp only a few kilometers away as a result of the atrocities which had created these facts on the ground. They found a certain pride in seeing the minaret despite the fact we couldn't reach the mosque itself due to it being totally surrounded by Israeli houses. There was also pride to be found under the old olive trees down the hill in the shadow of the 'Canyon' shopping mall, the girls knew who had tended these trees and tasted their fruit all those years ago.

Rawan wanted to find the houses her grandfather had told her about. She wanted to take back marimeyah (sage) and zatar (thyme) to him in the camp, but apart from the mosque there was little she could see. Little however does not mean nothing, and she did find something to hold onto:

"Finally I found two trees, two small trees. I knew they were not ancient trees that had been planted in our original country but it was enough for me, and for my grandfather, that they had been planted in Al Malha's soil."

They photographed the trees and they photographed the mall itself – built on land their relatives had nurtured, until that is security guards began to scream at us and order us to stop taking photos. I approached the fuming guards as the girls went back to the bus, and just as the guards were calling the police. More guards and police turned up, more began to shout at me demanding the camera. They told me it was illegal to take photos there as it posed a 'security threat'. I told them to wait whilst I got the camera from the girls and their hesitancy gave me just enough time to swap cameras and return with an empty one and convince them we had not photographed anything at the mall. I would not let them steal the girl's memories in the same way as their forefathers had orchestrated the theft of the girls land.

In Beit Natif we found the kibbutz of Netiv. The name change and the ugly housing units which had replaced the traditional Palestinian abodes of rolling archways and local stone once more masked the history, but the huge gnarled trunks of the olive trees told us other stories. There we tasted the delicious local 'roman' fruit (pomegranate) of which we had been told by Nakba survivors from the village. Young Americans strolled around the kibbutz with shopping bags filled with groceries and beer, whilst those who could truly call this their 'home', and remember it as it was, languished in Aida Camp in proud traditional dress yet with inadequate supplies of fresh water.

On the land of Ajur village another kibbutz stood by the name of Agur but outside its gates we saw the beautiful houses we had heard so much about.

They were not complete and were few in number, but stood proudly like living skeletons of history. In their surrounding fields the swollen ripe sabar (cactus fruit) brought joy to the faces of Amjad and Saja whilst picking it brought spikes to our fingers. Their grandmother had told them so much about Ajur Sabar. She told me last year that if she could just taste this delicious fruit, her sweetest memory, once more in her village she could die a happy woman. She would have loved to have come with us, but even had her health permitted such a trip her ID would have not. The disgusting reality is that the children could only make this journey of discovery as they were too young to have to carry ID (all under 16), and because they had a foreign passport holder with them. Once again I sickeningly found myself with greater rights in Palestine than Palestinians themselves… Amjad's face was alive though and his head filled with his grandmother's memories as he knelt on his land and let the rich red earth slide through his fingers. His excitement was uncontainable. He wanted to explore everywhere at once; his walk was two inches taller and his chest two inches wider now he was back in
his village.

Yet when we eventually located Zur Haddasah settlement, built on top of Mohammad's home village he found nothing. He too had interviewed survivors of Al Nakba in preparation for the trip. His grandfather had recounted in infinite detail his vivid memories of village life, of his days growing up amongst the pine trees and playing in the many fresh water springs, of exploring the mountains and picking herbs and fruit. But none of these memories fitted with the sight that greeted Mohammad's eyes… the sight of huge electric fences with warning signs written in Hebrew, the sight of uniform and bland houses with distinctive red roofs that reminded him of the illegal Zionist colonies that litter the West Bank. The huge yellow gate and control rooms that opened it only for the entrance of resident's cars,
whilst keeping at bay 'strangers' such as himself and his sister, were hard to stomach:

"I felt that my village should have been beautiful like other villages we saw, but when I saw it I didn't feel like it was my village. My grandfather had told me there were ten water springs and two mountains in Ras Abu Amar but when I went I could see nothing. I found that everything had changed as though it was not really my village…"

The towering minaret of Al Malha, the steadfast ancient olive trees in Beit Natif, and the ruined houses and immovable cacti of Ajur, had all provided other children with a sense of pride. These remnants of days gone by, and of their own identity, were all startling only in their absence in Ras Abu Amar, yet on the land of the other villages insignificant as they may seem to the current residents, they had offered the children something physical to see and touch that brought their grandparents memories to life. We had been told that there were still ruins to be found somewhere in the area but we just didn't know where to look, and as far as we could see there was nothing but this settlement that had devoured Mohammad's land.

When the bus in which we were traveling had initially pulled up outside the settlement's gates I asked Mohammad and his sister Ahoud to come with me to take some photos, but he refused:

"This is not my village! I will not take photos here, this is not my village!"

When he eventually came down from the bus he still could not accept that the sprawling city in front of him now covers the land on which his grandparents had lived. I had never visited the area before and since there were no signposts or other evidence that we were in fact in the right place I rang people back in Aida Camp for confirmation. I was told by two people in the Camp who knew the land well that this was the site of the destroyed village of which Mohammad had dreamt so any times. He had been here himself previously only three short years ago and Zur Hadassah was there then but it had grown so much during this time that it was now unrecognizable to him.

It had taken in more land and the fences kept him away from all but a couple of metres of land outside the oppressive 'security' cage that circles the settlement. After I talked for a few minutes with the two children Mohammad began to look down at his feet, but it wasn't because he was shying away from eye contact. I realized he was actually looking hard at the ground around his feet, studying it looking for something to recognize. He dropped down to his knees and began to touch the soil, to play with it in his fingers. He was feeling the textures and the shapes like a blind man reading Braille. As his fingers caressed the earth he spoke:

"Is this my land? Is this my soil? Are these my stones?

It was not said in particular to anyone, maybe he was asking himself, or maybe he was speaking to the land itself. He was looking for something to hold onto emotionally, and something physical, something about which he could proudly say 'this is from my village' when he returned to Aida. His words may now sound very depressing but in a way they were Mohammad's light. They offered him a beacon of hope. The stones and soil were not what he had dreamed about but they were still from his land, this tiny strip of land on which he stood was all of Ras Abu Amar that he could now reach, but it was at least Ras Abu Amar:

"I saw stones and soil at the entrance to the village. I took some to give to some of my friends in the Camp who are also from Ras Abu Amar but who had never visited the village or seen it before. My aunt asked me to bring her zatar (thyme) and marimeyah (sage), but I took her stones and soil instead. I could not enter to get her what she had asked for but I felt that the soil and stones were still ours, and they were better than nothing. Those stones I took will make me always remember that my homeland will return to me and
my people one day…"

The words and actions of this young boy who I have known for three years now were both heart-wrenching and beautiful at the same time. They devastated me and lifted me simultaneously; it is hard to describe adequately with mere words, yet it is a moment that will live with me for ever.

This notion could be said to sum up this trip, the first of two planned trips to take the children to revisit their homelands, this idea that words can simply not describe such an experience. I myself have studied Nakba history through people in the camps, I have interviewed Nakba survivors and heard the passion with which their grandchildren talk about their villages. I have heard statistic after statistic and seen photograph after photograph. But I had refused for three years despite repeated requests from friends in the Camp to go to the villages alone to take photographs for them. I had refused because I always believed I could not understand the villages sufficiently from a visual perspective alone, and could therefore not have done the land or the memories justice. I am now convinced that I was right to make such a decision. The villages cannot be understood in such terms because they are not merely physical. As I visited the villages with our children layer after layer of depth unraveled itself. Through the eyes of our children, through their actions and reactions, I have learnt more than a million books could have told me although this trip was not intended for my benefit. I have seen our children carrying their emotions proudly on their faces and heard them mutter words which have both hurt and inspired me deeply.

If Theodore Hertzl or Golda Meir, or Ariel Sharon or Ehud Olmert, really ever believed the refugees could be forgotten or silenced then they were badly mistaken. If they ever thought memory would die or pass with time then they were wrong. If they hoped that future generations would lie down in submission and dutifully accept all the wrongs that have been done without struggling for their rights they should have thought again.

Nearly 60 years after Al Nakba I sat in a chair in a small room in a Palestinian Refugee Camp and talked with a young boy about our trip back to his land. He said something to me which I have heard uttered by survivors from 1948 many times, but something that I have never ever heard from a 13 year old boy before. A 13 year old boy who knows the road ahead may be long, but he is prepared for the journey irrespective of its duration:

"If I couldn't return then my sons after me, and the future generations for sure will go back, because this is my village, my home, and my land on which my grandparents lived... The right to return to my village will come one day, however long it takes…"

__._,_.___Rich Wiles is a photographic artist who has been living and working in Palestine for much of the last five years. His photography work has been shown around Europe, in the U.S., Australia and Palestine itself, amongst other places. Since 2006 he has been writing from Occupied Palestine under the title 'Behind the Wall' for a forthcoming book. Much of this work is based in and around the refugee camps where he is based in Palestine, highlighting daily life and memories of refugees who still live in forced exile nearly 60 years after Al Nakba.
.

__,_._,___
Share:

Who Are The Fanatics?

By Paul Craig Roberts

President Jimmy Carter was demonized for pointing out in his book, Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, that there are actually two sides to the Israeli-Palestinian issue. Distinguished American scholars, such as John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt have suffered the same fate for documenting the excessive influence the Israel Lobby has on US foreign policy.

Americans would be astonished at the criticisms in the Israeli press of the Israeli government's policies toward the Palestinians and Arabs generally. In Israel facts are still part of the discussion. If the Israeli newspaper, Haaretz, could replace Fox "News," CNN, New York Times and Washington Post, Americans would know the truth about US and Israeli policies in the Middle East and their likely consequences.

On September 1, Haaretz reported that Rabbi Eric Yoffie, the president of the Union for Reform Judaism, which represents 900 Congregations and 1.5 million Jews, "accused American media, politicians and religious groups of demonizing Islam" and turning Muslims into "satanic figures."

Rabbi Yoffie is certainly correct. In America there is only one side to the issue. An entire industry has been created that is devoted to demonizing Islam. Books abound that misrepresent Islam as the greatest possible threat to Western Civilization and seek to instill fear and hatred of Muslims in Americans. For example, Norman Podhoretz proclaims "World War IV: The Long Struggle Against Islamofascism." Daniel Pipes shrieks that "Militant Islam Reaches America." Lee Harris warns of "The Suicide of Reason: Radical Islam's Threat to the West."

Think tanks have well-funded Middle East programs, the purpose of which is to spread Islamophobia. Fear and loathing pour out of the Middle East Forum and the American Enterprise Institute.

In the US it is acceptable, even obligatory in many circles, to hate Muslims and to support violence against them. Pipes has been described as a "leading anti-Muslim hate propagandist." He is on record advocating the use of violence alone as the solution to the Muslim problem. This won him the endorsement of the Christian Coalition, AIPAC, and the Zionist Organization of America for appointment to the board of the United States Institute of Peace. President George Bush used a recess appointment to appoint this man of violence to the Institute of Peace.

Pipes advocates that the Muslims be beaten into submission by force, the view that has guided the Bush administration. To brainwashed and propagandized Americans, Pipes appointment made perfect sense.

Podhoretz believes that Islam has no right to exist, because it is opposed to Israeli territorial expansion, and that America must deracinate Islam, which means to tear Islam up by the roots.

While neoconservatives, Christian Zionists, and the Bush administration embrace unbridled violence against Muslims, Lee Harris warns that America is much too tolerant and reasonable to be able to defend itself against Muslim fanaticism. America's "governing philosophy based on reason, tolerance, consensus and deliberation cannot defend itself against a [Muslim] strategy of ruthless violence."

Islamophobia overflows with such absurdities and contradictions. Harris tells us that the Enlightenment overcame fanatical thinking in the West, leaving the West unfamiliar with fanaticism and helpless to confront it. Harris, who fancies himself an authority on fanaticism, is deaf, dumb, and blind to Communism and National Socialism and is completely ignorant of the fact that neoconservative fanatics are the direct heirs of the Jacobins of the French Revolution, itself a fanatical product of the Enlightenment.

If Americans did rely on reason, tolerance and deliberation, they might free their minds of shrill propaganda long enough to consider the "Muslim threat." Muslims are disunited. Their disunity makes them a threat to one another, not to the West.

In Iraq most of the fighting and violence is between Sunni and Shi'ite Arabs and between Sunnis and Kurds. If Iraqis were unified, most of the violence, instead of a small part of it, would be directed against the American troops, and the remnants of a US defeated army would have been withdrawn by now. However much Iraqis might hate the American invader and occupier, they do not hate him enough to unite and to drive him out. They had rather kill one another.

Iran, the current focus of demonization, is not Arab. Iranians are the ancient race of Persians. Indeed, Iran would do itself a favor if it changed its name back to Persia. For eight years (1980-1988) the Iranians and Iraqis were locked in catastrophic war with horrendous casualties on both sides. Despite its military exhaustion, Iraq was considered a "threat" by the American Superpower and was bombed and embargoed for the decade of the 1990s, one consequence of which was 500,000 deaths of Iraqi children.

Not content with the complete crippling of Iraq by the Clinton administration, the Bush administration invaded Iraq in 2003 and has been dealing more death and destruction to Iraq ever since.

Palestine has been under Israeli occupation for decades. Israel has simply stolen most of Palestine, and the remaining Palestinian enclaves are ghettos policed by the Israeli army.

The rulers of Saudi Arabia and the oil emirates are Sunni Arabs. They are more afraid of Shi'ite Arabs than of Israelis. Egypt, Jordan, and Pakistan are ruled by bought-and-paid-for American puppets. The Turkish military is also in the American pocket and suppresses any Islamist influence in the civilian government.

Afghanistan is a disunited country of tribal peoples, each holding sway in their area. The Taliban were attempting to unify Afghanistan, and the Bush administration's fear that the Taliban might succeed was the reason for the US invasion of Afghanistan. The US allied with the defeated Northern Alliance, in part a remnant of the old Soviet puppet government, and turned Afghanistan back over to warlords.

When the facts are considered--Muslim disunity and the absence of modern technology, navies, and strategic reach--the Bush/Cheney/ neoconservative/Zionist propaganda that "we must fight them over there before they come over here" is such a transparent hoax that it is astounding that so many Americans have fallen for it.

To the extent that there is any Muslim threat, it is one created by the US and Israel. Israel has no diplomacy toward Muslims and relies on violence and coercion. The US has interfered in the internal affairs of Muslim countries during the entire post World War II period. The US overthrew an elected government in Iran and installed the Shah. The US backed Saddam Hussein in his aggression against Iran. The US has kept in power rulers it could control and has pandered to the desires of Israeli governments. If America is hated, America created the hate by its arrogant and dismissive treatment of the Muslim Middle East.

There is no such thing as Islamofascism. This is a coined propaganda word used to inflame the ignorant. There is no factual basis for the hatred that neoconservative Islamophobes instill in Americans. God did not tell America to destroy the Muslims for the Israelis.

In America today blind ignorant hate against Muslims has been brought to a boiling point. The fear and loathing is so great that the American public and its elected representatives in Congress offer scant opposition to the Bush administration's plan to make Iran the third Middle East victim of American aggression in the 21st century.

Most Americans, who Harris believes to be so reasonable, tolerant, and deliberative that they cannot defend themselves, could not care less that one million Iraqis have lost their lives during the American occupation and that an estimated four million Iraqis have been displaced. The total of dead and displaced comes to 20 percent of the Iraqi population. If this is not fanaticism on the part of the Bush administration, what is it? Certainly it is not reason, tolerance, and deliberation.

The Bush supporter will ask, "What about 9/11?" Even those who believe the fraudulent 9/11 Commission Report should understand that in the official account the attack was the work of individuals, none of whom were acting in behalf of Muslim governments and none of whom were Iraqi, Afghan, or Iranian. 9/11 provides no justification for attacking Muslim countries.

-Paul Craig Roberts was Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in the Reagan administration. He was Associate Editor of the Wall Street Journal editorial page and Contributing Editor of National Review. He is co-author of The Tyranny of Good Intentions.

Share:

Unmasking of Abbas gives Bush final shot at imposing Bantustan


..."reports about the handful of dollars turning into bucketsful and increased US training for Abbas’ private militia point to a set-up intended to culminate in the so-called “International Conference” organized by the Washington/Tel Aviv alliance for the end of the year. Many pundits expect that as much as that conference may be Bush’s last aria, it also will seal Palestine’s fate as a doomed Bantustan and Abbas crowned as King – if allowed to proceed!"
Written by Iqbal Jassat

Where does he hide now? Mahmoud Abbas, de facto dictator of the Occupied Territories is in hiding from his own people! Unlike his predecessor Yasser Arafat, who was incarcerated in his Ramallah HQ – under siege from Israel; Abbas is an esteemed guest in Jerusalem.

His limited movement within the West Bank and zero presence in the Gaza is in sharp contrast to the way he is feted by the Israelis. While he does Israel’s bidding by outlawing the elected government led by Hamas, Abbas has foolishly painted himself into a corner.

Unable to step into any role to lead a spirited struggle for freedom from the colonial occupier, Abbas has nowhere to hide. Neither his policies of collaboration, nor his unprincipled attempts to wrest control through a coup, have left him with any integrity. Now that he has been unmasked as a sell-out, his dependence on Israel is his only lifeline to gain endorsement from an equally discredited US leader.

In his rush to marginalize Hamas, he has in fact been following a script flowing from what is known as the Bush doctrine. This required him and his coterie of advisors to conspire with the Zionist regime and the US to dislodge Hamas from power. According to various accounts and more specifically from the editor of the on-line Electronic Intifada, Ali Abunimah, this entailed funneling weapons and tens of millions of dollars to militias, particularly the “Preventive Security Force” headed by the former Gaza warlord Mohammad Dahlan.

Abbas’ humiliating failure, compounded by revelations of Dahlan’s complicity in the murder of Arafat, has in effect tarnished his image in the eyes of Palestinians, thereby undermining his ability to lead his people. Indeed, sticking to the script has entrenched him as the latest addition to a long list of puppet leaders in the Arab world.

Within PLO structures many questions are being raised about why Abbas would turn his back on the Mecca Agreement, so soon after huge expectations were raised about a united Palestinian position – with a single minded focus on attaining national liberation.

Hamas was applauded for displaying graciousness in allowing Fatah a substantial role within a Government of National Unity, notwithstanding the fact that it [Fatah] lost the Jan ’06 elections by a huge margin.

In such a scenario where the defeated party is given a respectful presence in the legislative structures of the Palestinian Authority, it makes no sense for such an arrangement to be scuttled. Yet this is the route chosen by Abbas and his cohorts, who sought to regain complete and total control as became evident in the short-lived anarchy they created in the Gaza.

Why? Is it because Abbas was tempted to forego his people’s legitimate rights for a handful of dollars? Or is it due to US pressure and manipulation which he found too hot to handle? Perhaps it was the promise of being enthroned as the Czar of Palestine, with unlimited capacity to reign over his people without any regard to democratic values?

These questions will be answered in due course in possibly the same dramatic way Hamas uncovered Dahlan’s nefarious links and destructive mission to keep Palestinians in perpetual bondage.

In the meantime, reports about the handful of dollars turning into bucketsful and increased US training for Abbas’ private militia point to a set-up intended to culminate in the so-called “International Conference” organized by the Washington/Tel Aviv alliance for the end of the year. Many pundits expect that as much as that conference may be Bush’s last aria, it also will seal Palestine’s fate as a doomed Bantustan and Abbas crowned as King – if allowed to proceed!

Mahmoud Abbas and his small group of unelected charlatans have become Palestine’s biggest liability. They are willing to barter Jerusalem, the right of return and every legitimate right of the Palestinians for no more than the disgrace of being outright sell-outs.

Will they succeed?

Share:

More Money for Israel? You Have to Be Joking Me!

They're richer than ever, and they don't need it –
so why are we giving it?

American military aid to Israel has been increased yet again, which leads us to ask the inevitable question: What are we getting for our money?

Well, we're getting this, as well as this, and this – not to mention this.

The regularly quoted figure is $3.5 billion per year. John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt go with the figure of $3 billion in their new book, The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, averring that this is "generous, but it is hardly the whole story." This "canonical" figure, they say, "omits a substantial number of other benefits." The authors cite former congressman Lee Hamilton as saying that Israel is one of three countries whose aid total "substantially exceeds the popularly quoted figures." The actual figure, said Hamilton, is more than $4.5 billion.

As Mearsheimer and Walt have pointed out, neither the practical nor the moral case for this extraordinary amount of material support is justified: our Israel-centered foreign policy has been a burden to us in our dealings with the other nations of the Middle East, and it is increasingly clear that U.S. and Israeli interests have diverged since the end of the Cold War. Contrary to the Lobby's assertion that 9/11 made their fight our fight, the exact opposite is the case. Anti-Americanism in the Muslim world is a deadly danger to our national security and a great boon to Osama bin Laden and his many imitators around the globe. This arming of the Israeli Sparta is a strategic and diplomatic liability that grows with each passing year.

This post by Matt Yglesias over at The Atlantic makes a lot of sense, as far as it goes. An argument made by the Amen Corner is that the Israelis are performing a valuable service by refining the technical expertise of the military-industrial complex: they're doing the research and development that is giving America the weapons of tomorrow. But "this doesn't really make sense," Yglesias writes, "since defense contractors – American, Israeli, French, whatever – get paid for their work as is, so it's not clear why the Israeli government would need extra payment."

It's hard to differentiate between private and public industry in socialist Israel, especially when it comes to the military-industrial complex, where no clear line of demarcation exists. Indeed, in the United States, and throughout the world, such companies are virtual arms of the government, which is their primary and often only customer.

The point to be made is this: Just as America's policy of military intervention in the Middle East benefits Israel strategically, serving as an ever expanding protective shield against the hostility of its neighbors, so American subsidies in the form of military aid are designed to bolster the burgeoning Israeli arms industry, so that government-supported Israeli companies can sell us new weaponry developed on our dime.

The system works a little differently in Eastern Europe, where the installation of missile defense-systems purportedly defending against a very unlikely Iranian attack is a direct subsidy to the American companies that developed it. Again, aid to the Israelis is given on unusually favorable terms, and this underscores once more the central point made by Professors Mearsheimer and Walt, which is that the existence of the Lobby – as the single most powerful influence on the conduct of American foreign policy – explains the discrepancy.

Israel is a rich country. They don't need this enormous outpouring of free cash to shore up their military machine, which amounts to around one-sixth of our total foreign aid outlay and about 2 percent of the Israeli gross domestic product. It is the equivalent of roughly $500 per year to each and every citizen of Israel. So why this incredible amount of military aid?

After all, the Israelis are unofficial members of the nuclear club. They could turn Tehran into a molten puddle of glass at a moment's notice, and maybe someday they will. Which is precisely the point. Israel is one of the most warlike countries on earth, given that it has been, since its inception, perpetually at war with its neighbors. Israel's partisans claim this is no fault of the Israelis, yet that question is not only highly debatable, it is utterly irrelevant as far as determining what the American interest is in all this.

This new aid package will accelerate a process that was begun some time ago and help make Israel America's confidante and primary ally, a post once occupied by the British, ensconcing the Jewish state as the primary armaments-producer to the American empire. Israel will profit from the rise of the American empire not only monetarily, but also geopolitically.

This strengthening of the Israeli military-industrial complex fills the coffers of the War Party to overflowing and helps keep the political and economic dynamics of this uniquely binational war economy flowing and politically viable. As regards the latter, as we have seen, the Lobby and allied groups and individuals take a leading role in plumbing for an aggressive policy in the Middle East, pushing for policies that increase war profits. It's the economics of that famous "cycle of violence" that everyone is always talking about breaking, yet it won't be broken until the power of the military-industrial complex is successfully curtailed, and, with it, the decisive influence of the Lobby.

One effect of The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy will be to reopen discussion of the Foreign Agents Registration Act and how it's not being enforced in the case of AIPAC. As the arrest, trial, and conviction of Pentagon analyst Larry Franklin makes all too clear, Israel's top lobbying organization in the U.S. is an agent of a foreign government: the upcoming trial of top AIPAC officials Steve Rosen and Keith Weissman on charges of passing classified information gleaned from Franklin to Israeli government officials threatens to uncover what it means to really function as a foreign agent – including engaging in espionage, in addition to routine cheerleading for the Israeli government talking point of the moment.

Many people have written me – given that I have covered the implications of the AIPAC spy trial in detail but haven't published anything on the subject recently – asking whatever happened to Rosen, Weissman, and the case, and darkly implying that since the supposedly all-powerful "Jewish cabal" that (in their view) runs the world couldn't possibly allow this to come to trial, it won't ever see the light of a courtroom. Ah, not so: the trial, though delayed – through the successful legal tactics of the defense – has not been derailed. A trial date of Jan. 14, 2008, has been set – although this, too, is tentative, given the outcome of several pending legal maneuvers. Another reason for the successful delaying tactics by the defense: the media hasn't paid any attention to this case, apart from a brief flurry of interest when the story first broke.

For the reasons why that is so, you'll just have to read The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy. I'm just finishing it up now and hope to have a report for you soon. In the meantime, the Lobby marches on, devastating all opposition with its virulent smear campaigns, and pulling in a good chunk of change for the mother country in the process. So, what are we getting for our involuntary "contribution" to the IDF?

Well, nothing. But our politicians, and the corrupt corporate interests whose sock-puppets they are, are getting plenty – of that you can be sure. The former are getting reelected, thanks to huge campaign contributions by the special interests, including the armaments industry, and the latter are getting rich off the backs of the American taxpayers.

And the beat goes on…

Share:

Open Letter To Dr. Norman Finklestein

By Fred Habachi

Share:

Walking in Palestinian Shoes

Joharah Baker

Many times, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict deserves lengthy and deep analyses. There are historical, cultural, political and religious considerations that need to be picked apart before reaching some sort of theory as to why this tiny slice of earth is so tormented.

Then there are those times when a simple glance at the obvious is enough to clarify the complete injustice of the Israeli occupation. This is not even about the more significant issues such as political assassinations, home demolitions, prisoners or military operations that claim scores of lives. No, this is about everyday matters, most often taken for granted, which when one takes a moment to contemplate, show just how sinister a military occupation can be.

Take an innocuous trip to the coastal town of Herzeliya. One of the more ritzy areas in Israel, the main mall in the town center is picture perfect. Not only is the actual structure aesthetically appealing, but the spacious piazza onto which the mall opens is breathtaking, overlooking the equally picturesque port, lined with sailboats, motorboats and luxurious yachts.

Still, over and above the obvious affluence, something else is even more striking. Carefree Israelis stroll along the boardwalk, iced coffee in hand, while children run freely around them in circles. This is hardly the picture portrayed in Western and Israeli media about the Israeli people’s daily lives. Israel has succeeded in conjuring up one specific image in the collective minds of most of the world’s peoples: the Israelis live in terror, afraid to walk into malls, cinemas, onto buses or across crowded intersections for fear that a militant Palestinian terrorist – probably one with a green and white headband with Islamic scrawling – will detonate a powerful bomb in their midst.

Quite the contrary, this is completely undetectable in the shopping mall in Herzeliya. Not a single Israeli soldier could be found in sight, not one machine gun slung across the chests of belligerent Jewish settlers. No, these Israelis were hardly living in fear. On the contrary, there was not one policeman either, pulling people over at random, demanding ID cards or permits from their chosen targets. It also goes without saying that none of these shoppers had to endure the humiliation of crossing a checkpoint before reaching their sunny destination.

Switch frames now, to the Qalandiya checkpoint between Ramallah and Jerusalem, which by the way, was completely nonexistent six years ago. Today it is an elaborate maze of terminals, iron turnstiles, glassed-in Israeli soldiers, fluttering Israeli flags and hoards of Palestinians waiting to get to the other side.

The concept of a military checkpoint in the midst of occupied territory is inherently racist, given that it discriminates between the occupied and the occupier and knocks down the occupied population to second and third class citizens solely because of their nationality. This particular checkpoint takes this racism up one more notch. Only Palestinian Jerusalemites and Palestinians with Israeli issued permits [in addition to the odd foreigner] are allowed to cross the checkpoint, barring the majority of other Palestinians bearing West Bank IDs from reaching their most revered city. Even among this small group, discriminatory measures have been put into place.

Once passengers reach the crossing by bus, those between 12 and 60 years of age are allowed to stay on the bus through the lengthy Israeli inspection. The others are made to get down and walk through the checkpoint where their IDs are checked and personal belongings run through an X-ray machine before boarding the same bus on the other side.

Even here, Israel manages to further dissect the “privileged” Palestinians allowed across. Only the elderly and mothers with children with a Jerusalem ID can stay on the bus when crossing the checkpoint. If a mother with young children is carrying a West Bank ID [albeit with an Israeli permit] she is not “worthy” of staying on the bus. She too must get down, no matter how small her babies are, and walk through the iron turnstile so a young soldier, not much older than her own child, can inspect her papers and make sure she is not a “threat to the security of Israel.”

Anyone living outside the surreal box known as Palestine would be appalled by the absurdity and blatant injustice of such a situation. Logically, it seems unfathomable that anyone would accept such human and civil rights abuses on an everyday basis. The Palestinians however, have fallen into a treacherous pitfall where the more they are oppressed the more they seem to tolerate injustices. We have grown so accustomed to an Israeli military presence on our land, checkpoints, the permit system and daily harassment by Israel’s military establishment that crossing a checkpoint with all of the hassles this entails has become no more than a nagging inconvenience.

The truth is, the racist system put in place for Palestinians living in the West Bank, Gaza and Jerusalem, is far from a mere inconvenience. It is outrageous; an atrocity against humanity and one that Israel is allowed to pull off with impunity because it has so artfully molded an image of victimization around the Israeli people.

One only has to go to Herzeliya, Tel Aviv or Eilat to realize just how great this injustice is. Israelis seem to go into fits of rage if there is a traffic jam or the line at the grocery store is not moving fast enough. Most people in the world are like this. A backed up traffic jam in downtown New York would elicit a similar response. But the Palestinians wait patiently at the window and hold up their ID’s obediently to the soldier inside, not because the situation suits them but because this has become more of a survival tactic than anything else. One slip up and they could be pulled aside, made to wait for hours or worse, arrested for some cockamamie reason like talking back or refusing to pull up their shirt to check for explosive belts underneath.

The problem is that Israel is extremely influential in western circles and has convinced the world that this labyrinth of checkpoints and bypass roads is necessary to ensure its citizens’ security and safety. If the average Palestinian is inconvenienced in the mix, this is just an unfortunate byproduct. The truth is that not only do these checkpoints, roads and of course, the separation wall, swallow up kilometers of Palestinian land – hence the true intent of Israel’s actions – they are the manifestation of extremely racist policies that should be viewed in this light, not as an unfortunate consequence.

Perhaps all it would take is one day in Herzeliya, west Jerusalem or Tel Aviv - one day where average Israelis would have to cross checkpoints, apply for permits only to be rejected time and again, or wait for hours at a military barricade while their cars, papers and bodies are searched. All it would take is one day for Israelis to live in Palestinian shoes, to experience the demolition of their home, the assassination of their son or the imprisonment of their daughter, for them – and maybe the world along with them – to realize that this is no way to treat another people.


Share:

The Jewish National Fund = "Dark Side of Jewish Dream"

The Jewish National Fund's blue collection boxes have long been a familiar sight in diaspora schools, workplaces, shops and homes - a chance for ordinary Jews to contribute their private cash to the Zionist dream.

These "pennies from the pushka" were used from 1901 onwards to purchase land for Jewish settlements in the Turkish and later British territory of Palestine, stepping-stones towards the creation of a Jewish state.

Yet sixty years after the birth of the state of Israel the JNF continues to thrive - and to generate controversy.

Last month Israel's parliament overwhelmingly endorsed the first stage of a bill which would formally allow the JNF to continue its established practice of barring non-Jews from leasing land and housing held in its name - 13 per cent of the area of Israel, much of it now prime real estate.

The Knesset bill has led to renewed accusations both in Israel and abroad that the JNF denies Israel's 20 per cent Arab minority access to what is in practice state land.

Under the headline "A Racist Jewish State" an editorial in the center-left Israeli newspaper Haaretz wrote that "the Jewish National Fund's land policy counters the interests of the state and cannot discriminate by law against the minority living in Israel ... Even though the Jewish National Fund purchased the lands for the Jewish people in the Diaspora, the State of Israel has already been established and these lands must now serve all its citizens."

Other Israeli commentators have pointed out that the move comes just as the Israeli government and international Zionist bodies are trying to stifle moves by trades unions in Britain and South Africa to boycott Israel as an apartheid state.

Most government figures, including Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, have avoided taking a stand on the issue. The JNF and its many supporters say that its activities do not discriminate against anybody.

It says that the forests and parks it has built in its more recent environment role - many on bulldozed Arab villages - are open to all visitors, whether Jewish or not, and that it employs many Arabs there. It says that Bedouin herders are permitted to graze their sheep and goats in JNF forests.

"[JNF] land has been legally purchased penny by penny over the last 106 years, by Jews from all around the world in order to fulfill the dream of creating a secure Jewish homeland in the land that was from biblical times, the Land of Israel," said a statement from the Fund's office in Israel.

"To use these donations for any other purpose would be to breach the trust and desecrate the sacrifices of these Jews, many of whom were later to perish in the Holocaust and whose sole desire was to use the little they had to secure land for the benefit and security of the Jewish People, who like any other legitimate purchasers of land anywhere in the world have the right to decide, subject to the laws of the land how to manage, maintain or otherwise utilize the land that they have legitimate title to."

But historians say that much of the JNF's almost 3000-square kilometres of real estate was not legitimately purchased from its legal owners.

At the birth of the state the JNF had only purchased less than 1000 sq kms of land from willing sellers, but Prime Minister David Ben Gurion then hurriedly and illegally sold it another 2000 sq kms which had been seized from native Arab owners displaced by the fighting or by military orders.

Ben Gurion's aim was to block any possible implementation of a recent United Nations resolution calling on Israel to allow the displaced Arabs to return to their homes and property in the new Jewish state.

The "transaction of millions", as it was known, left the JNF holding much of what is now Israel's most valuable urban real estate. It was also a way to channel diaspora money into the new state's depleted coffers.

The close ties between the state and the JNF became formal in 1961, when the JNF agreed to manage its lands in tandem with the state-owned Israeli Land Administration (ILA). In return the privately-owned JNF was given half of the seats on the board of the ILA, collectively owning and managing 93 per cent of the state of Israel.

In recent years the twin organizations have lost two high court challenges accusing them of blocking non-Jews from leasing homes and property (ILA and JNF land is only leased, usually to long-term tenants, and never sold as freehold).

But the courts would not apply the precedents generally, and rights groups say that in practice Jewish housing developments are still able to exclude non-Jews by means of committees which vet the "suitability" of would-be new residents.

In Palestinian territories under Israeli military occupation the JNF's commercial subsidiary, Himnuta, has used agents and middle men to covertly buy Arab property in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. In 2005 Israeli police charged that some of this land was stolen from its Palestinian owners by corrupt Israeli officials and middle men who had forged bills of sale.

The new Knesset bill is sponsored by ultra-nationalist deputy Uri Ariel and was backed by a cross party majority of 64-16 on its first reading. Its introduction was prompted by an order from Israel's attorney-general earlier this year directing both agencies not to discriminate against non-Jews, even when the property in question belongs to the JNF.

Despite its political/ethnic agenda in Israel the JNF continues to enjoy tax-free charitable status in many Western countries, including Australia, where it presents itself as a primarily environmental organization.

Gordon Brown agreed to serve as a patron of the JNF shortly after becoming British Prime Minister, while its Australian branch recently co-hosted John Howard at a gala award ceremony to recognize his support for Israel.

In Israel the JNF has renamed a forest on the edge of the Gaza Strip after Mr Howard, and there are JNF forests in the Galilee named after former prime ministers Bob Hawke and Robert Menzies.

The Australian Jewish National Fund has adopted the Bnei Shimon community council near the southern Israeli city of Beersheva as its main fundraising project. AJNF's web site says it hopes to raise between $5 million and $8m dollars to provide water facilities to the council, which aims to double the number of Jews living amidst the area's marginalised and deeply underprivileged Israeli-Arab majority.

Nuri Elokbi, 65, a locally-born Bedouin Arab, said that the Australian money is helping to build the new Jewish community of Givot Bar on his tribe's land, from which the IDF expelled it under false pretences when he was still a boy.

"I've heard that the Australians once did exactly the same thing to their original natives that the Israelis are doing to us," he said, manning his lone protest tent on a dirt road near Givot Bar. "The difference is that this is the modern times. Today it's supposed to be forbidden."

The chief executive officer of the Australian JNF, Rob Schneider, has strongly backed the Knesset's new bill to prevent non-Jews from having access to JNF land.

"It is a question of exercising ownership over land that was purchased historically by Jews for the benefit of Jews," he was quoted as saying in the Australian Jewish News.

Yet the Knesset bill has disturbed many Jews in other parts of the diaspora.

In the United States the leader of the Union for Reform Judaism, the world's largest Jewish congregation, condemned the move.

"It's very hard to imagine any circumstance where a Jewish minority in any diaspora country would accept with equanimity a bill that would forbid Jews from purchasing land," said Rabbi Eric Yoffie, the union's president.

"Therefore it is essential that when the Jewish majority in Israel exercises power, it extend to others the rights it always demanded for itself when we were in the minority."

Source: The Sun-Herald



Share:

Chris Hudges: It's Time for a Declaration of Independence From Israel

By Chris Hedges, Truthdig

Israel, without the United States, would probably not exist. The country came perilously close to extinction during the October 1973 war when Egypt, trained and backed by the Soviet Union, crossed the Suez and the Syrians poured in over the Golan Heights. Huge American military transport planes came to the rescue. They began landing every half-hour to refit the battered Israeli army, which had lost most of its heavy armor. By the time the war was over, the United States had given Israel $2.2 billion in emergency military aid.
The intervention, which enraged the Arab world, triggered the OPEC oil embargo that for a time wreaked havoc on Western economies. This was perhaps the most dramatic example of the sustained life-support system the United States has provided to the Jewish state.

Israel was born at midnight May 14, 1948. The U.S. recognized the new state 11 minutes later. The two countries have been locked in a deadly embrace ever since.

Washington, at the beginning of the relationship, was able to be a moderating influence. An incensed President Eisenhower demanded and got Israel's withdrawal after the Israelis occupied Gaza in 1956. During the Six-Day War in 1967, Israeli warplanes bombed the USS Liberty. The ship, flying the U.S. flag and stationed 15 miles off the Israeli coast, was intercepting tactical and strategic communications from both sides. The Israeli strikes killed 34 U.S. sailors and wounded 171. The deliberate attack froze, for a while, Washington's enthusiasm for Israel. But ruptures like this one proved to be only bumps, soon smoothed out by an increasingly sophisticated and well-financed Israel lobby that set out to merge Israeli and American foreign policy in the Middle East.

Israel has reaped tremendous rewards from this alliance. It has been given more than $140 billion in U.S. direct economic and military assistance. It receives about $3 billion in direct assistance annually, roughly one-fifth of the U.S. foreign aid budget. Although most American foreign aid packages stipulate that related military purchases have to be made in the United States, Israel is allowed to use about 25 percent of the money to subsidize its own growing and profitable defense industry. It is exempt, unlike other nations, from accounting for how it spends the aid money. And funds are routinely siphoned off to build new Jewish settlements, bolster the Israeli occupation in the Palestinian territories and construct the security barrier, which costs an estimated $1 million a mile.

The barrier weaves its way through the West Bank, creating isolated pockets of impoverished Palestinians in ringed ghettos. By the time the barrier is finished it will probably in effect seize up to 40 percent of Palestinian land. This is the largest land grab by Israel since the 1967 war. And although the United States officially opposes settlement expansion and the barrier, it also funds them.

The U.S. has provided Israel with nearly $3 billion to develop weapons systems and given Israel access to some of the most sophisticated items in its own military arsenal, including Blackhawk attack helicopters and F-16 fighter jets. The United States also gives Israel access to intelligence it denies to its NATO allies. And when Israel refused to sign the nuclear nonproliferation treaty, the United States stood by without a word of protest as the Israelis built the region's first nuclear weapons program.

U.S. foreign policy, especially under the current Bush administration, has become little more than an extension of Israeli foreign policy. The United States since 1982 has vetoed 32 Security Council resolutions critical of Israel, more than the total number of vetoes cast by all the other Security Council members. It refuses to enforce the Security Council resolutions it claims to support. These resolutions call on Israel to withdraw from the occupied territories.

There is now volcanic anger and revulsion by Arabs at this blatant favoritism. Few in the Middle East see any distinction between Israeli and American policies, nor should they. And when the Islamic radicals speak of U.S. support of Israel as a prime reason for their hatred of the United States, we should listen. The consequences of this one-sided relationship are being played out in the disastrous war in Iraq, growing tension with Iran, and the humanitarian and political crisis in Gaza. It is being played out in Lebanon, where Hezbollah is gearing up for another war with Israel, one most Middle East analysts say is inevitable. The U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East is unraveling. And it is doing so because of this special relationship. The eruption of a regional conflict would usher in a nightmare of catastrophic proportions.

There were many in the American foreign policy establishment and State Department who saw this situation coming. The decision to throw our lot in with Israel in the Middle East was not initially a popular one with an array of foreign policy experts, including President Harry Truman's secretary of state, Gen. George Marshall. They warned there would be a backlash. They knew the cost the United States would pay in the oil-rich region for this decision, which they feared would be one of the greatest strategic blunders of the postwar era. And they were right. The decision has jeopardized American and Israeli security and created the kindling for a regional conflagration.

The alliance, which makes no sense in geopolitical terms, does makes sense when seen through the lens of domestic politics. The Israel lobby has become a potent force in the American political system. No major candidate, Democrat or Republican, dares to challenge it. The lobby successfully purged the State Department of Arab experts who challenged the notion that Israeli and American interests were identical. Backers of Israel have doled out hundreds of millions of dollars to support U.S. political candidates deemed favorable to Israel. They have brutally punished those who strayed, including the first President Bush, who they said was not vigorous enough in his defense of Israeli interests. This was a lesson the next Bush White House did not forget. George W. Bush did not want to be a one-term president like his father.

Israel advocated removing Saddam Hussein from power and currently advocates striking Iran to prevent it from acquiring nuclear weapons. Direct Israeli involvement in American military operations in the Middle East is impossible. It would reignite a war between Arab states and Israel. The United States, which during the Cold War avoided direct military involvement in the region, now does the direct bidding of Israel while Israel watches from the sidelines. During the 1991 Gulf War, Israel was a spectator, just as it is in the war with Iraq.

President Bush, facing dwindling support for the war in Iraq, publicly holds Israel up as a model for what he would like Iraq to become. Imagine how this idea plays out on the Arab street, which views Israel as the Algerians viewed the French colonizers during the war of liberation.

"In Israel," Bush said recently, "terrorists have taken innocent human life for years in suicide attacks. The difference is that Israel is a functioning democracy and it's not prevented from carrying out its responsibilities. And that's a good indicator of success that we're looking for in Iraq."

Americans are increasingly isolated and reviled in the world. They remain blissfully ignorant of their own culpability for this isolation. U.S. "spin" paints the rest of the world as unreasonable, but Israel, Americans are assured, will always be on our side.

Israel is reaping economic as well as political rewards from its lock-down apartheid state. In the "gated community" market it has begun to sell systems and techniques that allow the nation to cope with terrorism. Israel, in 2006, exported $3.4 billion in defense products -- well over a billion dollars more than it received in American military aid. Israel has grown into the fourth largest arms dealer in the world. Most of this growth has come in the so-called homeland security sector.

"The key products and services," as Naomi Klein wrote in The Nation, "are hi-tech fences, unmanned drones, biometric IDs, video and audio surveillance gear, air passenger profiling and prisoner interrogation systems -- precisely the tools and technologies Israel has used to lock in the occupied territories. And that is why the chaos in Gaza and the rest of the region doesn't threaten the bottom line in Tel Aviv, and may actually boost it. Israel has learned to turn endless war into a brand asset, pitching its uprooting, occupation and containment of the Palestinian people as a half-century head start in the 'global war on terror.' "

The United States, at least officially, does not support the occupation and calls for a viable Palestinian state. It is a global player, with interests that stretch well beyond the boundaries of the Middle East, and the equation that Israel's enemies are our enemies is not that simple.

"Terrorism is not a single adversary," John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt wrote in The London Review of Books, "but a tactic employed by a wide array of political groups. The terrorist organizations that threaten Israel do not threaten the United States, except when it intervenes against them (as in Lebanon in 1982). Moreover, Palestinian terrorism is not random violence directed against Israel or 'the West'; it is largely a response to Israel's prolonged campaign to colonize the West Bank and Gaza Strip. More important, saying that Israel and the US are united by a shared terrorist threat has the causal relationship backwards: the US has a terrorism problem in good part because it is so closely allied with Israel, not the other way around."

Middle Eastern policy is shaped in the United States by those with very close ties to the Israel lobby. Those who attempt to counter the virulent Israeli position, such as former Secretary of State Colin Powell, are ruthlessly slapped down. This alliance was true also during the Clinton administration, with its array of Israel-first Middle East experts, including special Middle East coordinator Dennis Ross and Martin Indyk, the former deputy director of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, AIPAC, one of the most powerful Israel lobbying groups in Washington. But at least people like Indyk and Ross are sane, willing to consider a Palestinian state, however unviable, as long as it is palatable to Israel. The Bush administration turned to the far-right wing of the Israel lobby, those who have not a shred of compassion for the Palestinians or a word of criticism for Israel. These new Middle East experts include Elliott Abrams, John Bolton, Douglas Feith, the disgraced I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby, Richard Perle, Paul Wolfowitz and David Wurmser.

Washington was once willing to stay Israel's hand. It intervened to thwart some of its most extreme violations of human rights. This administration, however, has signed on for every disastrous Israeli blunder, from building the security barrier in the West Bank, to sealing off Gaza and triggering a humanitarian crisis, to the ruinous invasion and saturation bombing of Lebanon.

The few tepid attempts by the Bush White House to criticize Israeli actions have all ended in hasty and humiliating retreats in the face of Israeli pressure. When the Israel Defense Forces in April 2002 reoccupied the West Bank, President Bush called on then-Prime Minister Ariel Sharon to "halt the incursions and begin withdrawal." It never happened. After a week of heavy pressure from the Israel lobby and Israel's allies in Congress, meaning just about everyone in Congress, the president gave up, calling Sharon "a man of peace." It was a humiliating moment for the United States, a clear sign of who pulled the strings.

There were several reasons for the war in Iraq. The desire for American control of oil, the belief that Washington could build puppet states in the region, and a real, if misplaced, fear of Saddam Hussein played a part in the current disaster. But it was also strongly shaped by the notion that what is good for Israel is good for the United States. Israel wanted Iraq neutralized. Israeli intelligence, in the lead-up to the war, gave faulty information to the U.S. about Iraq's alleged arsenal of weapons of mass destruction. And when Baghdad was taken in April 2003, the Israeli government immediately began to push for an attack on Syria. The lust for this attack has waned, in no small part because the Americans don't have enough troops to hang on in Iraq, much less launch a new occupation.

Israel is currently lobbying the United States to launch aerial strikes on Iran, despite the debacle in Lebanon. Israel's iron determination to forcibly prevent a nuclear Iran makes it probable that before the end of the Bush administration an attack on Iran will take place. The efforts to halt nuclear development through diplomatic means have failed. It does not matter that Iran poses no threat to the United States. It does not matter that it does not even pose a threat to Israel, which has several hundred nuclear weapons in its arsenal. It matters only that Israel demands total military domination of the Middle East.

The alliance between Israel and the United States has culminated after 50 years in direct U.S. military involvement in the Middle East. This involvement, which is not furthering American interests, is unleashing a geopolitical nightmare. American soldiers and Marines are dying in droves in a useless war. The impotence of the United States in the face of Israeli pressure is complete. The White House and the Congress have become, for perhaps the first time, a direct extension of Israeli interests. There is no longer any debate within the United States. This is evidenced by the obsequious nods to Israel by all the current presidential candidates with the exception of Dennis Kucinich. The political cost for those who challenge Israel is too high.

This means there will be no peaceful resolution of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. It means the incidents of Islamic terrorism against the U.S. and Israel will grow. It means that American power and prestige are on a steep, irreversible decline. And I fear it also means the ultimate end of the Jewish experiment in the Middle East.

The weakening of the United States, economically and militarily, is giving rise to new centers of power. The U.S. economy, mismanaged and drained by the Iraq war, is increasingly dependent on Chinese trade imports and on Chinese holdings of U.S. Treasury securities. China holds dollar reserves worth $825 billion. If Beijing decides to abandon the U.S. bond market, even in part, it would cause a free fall by the dollar. It would lead to the collapse of the $7-trillion U.S. real estate market. There would be a wave of U.S. bank failures and huge unemployment. The growing dependence on China has been accompanied by aggressive work by the Chinese to build alliances with many of the world's major exporters of oil, such as Iran, Nigeria, Sudan and Venezuela. The Chinese are preparing for the looming worldwide clash over dwindling resources.

The future is ominous. Not only do Israel's foreign policy objectives not coincide with American interests, they actively hurt them. The growing belligerence in the Middle East, the calls for an attack against Iran, the collapse of the imperial project in Iraq have all given an opening, where there was none before, to America's rivals. It is not in Israel's interests to ignite a regional conflict. It is not in ours. But those who have their hands on the wheel seem determined, in the name of freedom and democracy, to keep the American ship of state headed at breakneck speed into the cliffs before us.


Chris Hedges is the former Middle East bureau chief for The New York Times and the author of "War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning."



.

__,_._,___
Share: