Showing posts with label United Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label United Church. Show all posts

The Right Course for the United Church Of Canada


 
The United Church of Canada should be congratulated for showing real moral courage by not succumbing to the smear tactics and intimidation they had been subjected to by some politicians and journalists over the last few weeks.
 
UCC's decision that the settlements built illegally by Israel in occupied East Jerusalem and the West Bank are the main cause of the Middle East conflict, is solidly grounded in international law.
 
Palestinian Christians have been the main victims of the Zionist project in the Holy Land. They constituted 20 per cent of the population of Palestine at the beginning of the British Mandate in 1920. Nearly overnight, more than 100,000 Christian Palestinians, including my family, were displaced when Israel came into being in 1948. More were displaced following Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza in 1967. As a result, the number of Christian Palestinians now stands at two per cent of the total population of the Holy Land.
 
This explains why UCC has responded positively to the appeal issued in 2009 by 13 church leaders in Jerusalem calling for a boycott against Israel with the objective of putting an end to the Israeli occupation in the Holy Land.
 
Contrary to what your editorial suggests, politics is part of religion. Jesus sided with the downtrodden, drove the money-changers and bankers from the temple and was crucified by the Roman authorities for preaching his message of justice, love and equality.
 
Following the footsteps of Jesus, UCC takes its beliefs seriously by viewing occupation as a sin against humanity, and this is why it seeks non-violently to end the oppression of the Palestinians.
 
Khaled Mouammar, Richmond Hill, Ont.
Share:

Responding to the United Church position on Israeli settlements


By Rick Salutin

Speaking as a Jew, it feels good to be able to offer to relieve Christian guilt. It went the other way and with reverse traction for millennia, as Christians burdened Jews with guilt for "killing Christ." Real satisfaction comes from not doing to others what they did to you, when you finally get a chance.
I'm referring to the decision by Canada's largest religious organization, the United Church, to take a very mild position on Israeli settlements in occupied territories, as the main cause of Mideast conflict. You can disagree with this but it's hardly absurd and it's solidly grounded in international law. They don't say they'll cancel any investments they have in those settlements, as others have, though they think they'll "study" that. They breathe no hint of a "boycott" of Israel, like the one directed at apartheid-era South Africa. They merely "encourage" their members to "avoid" goods from settlements if they're sure of the source. They condemn any violent opposition to the occupiers and endorse non-violence. Most pertinently, their motion "denounces all questions of Israel's right to exist or that seek to undermine its legitimacy as a state."
They did all this with agonizing and reluctance because the United Church is so nice. They love everybody and want everybody to like them. Their greatest horror is the thought of being called mean, racist or, worst of all, anti-Semitic. They knew with certainty what would come if they did what they did -- and it came. "The only comments I've received so far are those advocating a complete severing of ties with the United Church," said the head of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs. Israel supporters had issued dark warnings long in advance.
So I'd like to congratulate members of the United Church and say I think they showed real courage, which consists in confronting your own deepest fears rather than fears abstractly or generally defined. This is especially true since there's a backstory here: In the 1960s, the United Church and its newspaper were early supporters of Palestinian rights and attacked by many Jews for undermining Jewish-Christian reconciliation. But that was long ago, well before Canada came to seen as a Judeo-Christian, and not merely a Christian, society.
Let me add that I think anti-Semitism still exists and could be having a resurgence. Some of it may even hide as criticism of Israel, though mostly it's content to exist as outright hatred of Jews and not bother with camouflage. But anti-Semitism has come (or descended) a long way since the 1930s. Then it could be found proudly in the upper classes, reputable intellectuals, political parties and high-level civil servants ("none is too many"). Anti-Semitism has moved way down-market since then. It exists in milieus that United Church members don't aspire to and would be horrified to find themselves lumped with.
I offer this support as a Jew without clearance from the Centre (for Israel and Jewish Affairs), which claims to be the main voice of Jewish Canadians. It took over a year ago from its predecessor, the Canadian Jewish Congress, which it smothered with a pillow. It dropped the "Canadian" part along with "Congress," which had at least implied concern with democratic representation; changed that to "Centre," implying centralized control, and indicated Israel was its priority.
So United churchpeople may find more encouragement in a National Post editorial that said they'd chosen "to put politics ahead of matters of faith. Indeed, it is getting harder to tell where the church ends and a budding left-wing political party begins." I'd take that as encouragement if I were them. Politics is part of religion. Like Jesus, who drove the money-changers and other banksters from the Temple; or the Biblical prophet Amos who said, Let justice well up as waters; or Jeremiah who rebuked the diplomats of his time for crying Peace, Peace, when there is no peace. Religion, when it's strong, is about politics not because it wants to be but because it can't not be if it takes its precepts seriously. That's also true of the vigorous religious right in the U.S., which is active from the Republican party to school boards. Right on, United churchers.
Share:

United Church bravely opts for boycott



By Ted Schmidt
(He's the editor of New Catholic Times)


Look for the full court press of the pro-Israel faction in 
Canada to go into hysterical overdrive as the UnitedChurch bravely has put modern Israel on trial with its decision to boycott of goods produced in the OccupiedTerritories. The usual chorus of the Toronto Sun and National Post, Israel firsters both, will raise the heat and avoid the light. Many local Jewish organizations sadly will opt for tribalism and reflexively condemn the motion in near apocalyptic terms and with the flimsiest of reasons. the worst of these is: How about Syria? Iran? Hezbollah or “sure I am guilty but how about those other guys!”

The fact remains that this 60 year occupation is intolerable. It continues for many reasons. First, because it can due to the overwhelming military superiority of 
Israel’s firepower. Secondly, the craven and idiotic politics of theUSA backed by the blinkered fundamentalist religious support which conflates “the Land of the prophets” with the modern oppressive state. The US government could force the Israelis to bargain seriously if they turned off the financial tap. It is mind boggling to think that a developed country like Israel consumes one-third of US foreign aid. This has allowed Israel to add 650,000 of these illegal settlers since the mid 90s. One wag asked the impertinent question: How can you negotiate over a whole pizza while one side is already eating it?

What has consistently stunned me as a committed friend of 
Israel is the refusal to see, the adamantine resistance for Canadian Jews to go to the West Bank and see for themselves the daily, crabbed and impoverished life of the Palestinians. They simply have no “blood knowledge” of the effects of Occupation. Secure in their privilege as Canadians, they think they are being loyal to Israel while in fact they are betraying her and doing irreparable harm to Judaism. Meanwhile hundreds of church sponsored exposure tours such as the United Church (forget the somnolent Catholics) has wakened the biblical prophetic conscience

The gut loyalty of Jews to 
Israel I understand. I have no problem with the emotional link to Eretz Israel. But it’s like having an alcoholic brother: if you really loved him, you’d get him help, try and bring him to his senses. Canadian Jews in larger numbers are simply feeding their drunken family member more alcohol.This is eminently tragic in the extreme.

For religious Jews a blinkered loyalty never trumps shalom and sedeqah---peace and justice. Tribal values must give in to the universal values of human rights and justice. And indeed many Jewish critics of 
Israel do state this.
Why can’t they see asked the brilliant israeli journalist Amira Hass in 2006. Hass who for years has lived both inGaza and the occupied Territories wrote:

Could it be that you do not know what is happening 15 minutes from your faculties and offices? Is it plausible that you support the system in which Hebrew soldiers, at checkpoints in the heart of the West Bank, are letting tens of thousands of people wait everyday for hours upon hours under the blazing sun, while selecting: residents of Nablus and Tul Karm are not allowed through, residents of the Salem village are not even allowed to be here, a sick woman who skipped the line must learn a lesson and will be purposefully detained for hours.Machsom Watch's site is available for all; in it are countless such testimonies and worse, a day by day routine. But it cannot be that those who are appalled over every swastika painted on a Jewish grave in France and over every anti-Semitic headline in a Spanish local newspaper will not know how to reach this information, and will not be appalled and outraged.

Hass has lived in the 
Occupied Territories, the sole Jewish journalist who does this since 1996. She sees. Those who live 15 minutes away are not interested in seeing.

And those in 
Canada? Where are the rabbis like Lynne Gottlieb of the Jewish Voice for Peace who encouraged the United Church to pursue the boycott as a loving gesture of true solidarity .Gottlieb wrote:

I speak for hundreds of thousands of Jews around the world from a wide spectrum of affiliations who oppose
Israel’s policy of settlement expansion and military occupation. We want to see real change. By supporting Palestinians in their struggle for justice, you are also supporting us, the Jewish people, because the fruit of justice is peace. Peace for everyone in the region,” Gottlieb said. “Now that 171 Palestinian organizations and scores of Jewish groups have called for a boycott of settlement products, I am standing with them. The boycott aligns my values with right action. It accords with my religious beliefs.”

The rabbi explained that the boycott of settlement products has come about because all other avenues of nonviolent struggle have failed to end 
Israel’s policy of settlement expansion, which lies at the heart of the conflict. She pointed to the fact that prominent Israelis including Miko Peled, Avrum Burg, Neve Gordon, Dalit Baum, Rabbi Jeremy Milgrom and thousands of others believe that Israel’s policy of settlement expansion enforced by military occupation is delegitimizing the country.
Share:

BIAC congratulates United Church of Canada on settlement boycott

The Boycott Israeli Apartheid Campaign (BIAC) in Vancouver congratulates the United Church of Canada for a strong step forward in support of justice. On Wednesday, August 15 – and re-confirmed on Friday, August 17 – the United Church’s General Council 41 adopted a policy (below) of urging boycott of goods produced in Israeli settlements.

"Call on United Church members to take concrete actions to support the end of the occupation by:

a. directing the Executive of the General Council to give high priority to establishing a church-wide campaign of education and economic action directed against one or more settlement products that can be identified as produced in or related to the settlements or the occupied territories;
b.    identifying the goal of the campaign as building awareness of United Church members of the illegal settlements’ unjust continuation of the occupation and its impact on the lives of Palestinians and Israelis;

c. supporting the campaign through accompanying resources such as this working group report, the Kairos Palestine document, and others that are clearly directed toward an end to the occupation;

d. directing the Executive of the General Council to explore the wisdom of divesting in companies that are profiting from or supporting the occupation;

e. encouraging members of the United Church to avoid any and all products produced in the settlements;

f. requesting that the Canadian government ensure that all products produced in the settlements be labelled clearly and differently from products of Israel;

g. requesting that the Canadian government ensure that products produced in the settlements not be given preferential treatment under the Canada–Israel Free Trade Agreement;

h. inviting the participation of other Canadian churches in the campaign.”
This motion, emerging from years of work by people of conscience within the Church working on Palestine issues, is an important victory toward advancing Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) and recognition and support of justice for Palestine and the Palestinian people within Canadian churches and popular institutions. BIAC salutes all of the Church organizers and organizers from other groups and organizations, such as Independent Jewish Voices, who worked for years on educational efforts directed at Church members.
It is also worth noting here the efforts of labour activists who have secured a BDS resolution in the Canadian Union of Postal Workers, and of student activists who have made Israeli Apartheid Week a fixture at Canadian universities.
This action by the United Church of Canada, Canada’s largest Protestant mainline denomination, follows quickly on the actions of the United Methodist Church and the Presbyterian Church (USA), two large mainline Protestant Christian denominations in the United States, which both adopted boycott motions targeting settlement products at their membership general assemblies in May and July 2012.
The action draws the United Church closer to alignment with the Palestinian civil society call for Boycott Divestment and Sanctions, targeting Israel’s violations of Palestinian human rights and international law. The BDS call emerges from all aspects of Palestinian civil society, including Palestinian churches, whose clarion call, the 2009 “Kairos Document“, has been an inspiration and a mandate for Christians of conscience around the world to take action in solidarity with the Palestinian people struggling for freedom.
It should be noted that the United Church of Canada vote came amidst an atmosphere of large-scale fear-mongering and deception promoted by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, the Simon Wiesenthal Centre and similar Zionist organizations, who sought to smear Church organizers as “antisemites” for their work to combat racism and oppression in Palestine. This campaign included numerous lobby efforts targeting the church, massive media exposure, and even statements from nine Canadian senators demanding the Church reject the settlement boycott. It is to the credit of the Church that the settlement boycott motion in fact passed with nearly 80% of the votes present.
We encourage the United Church and its members to continue to work to raise the Church’s voice as a voice for justice in Palestine, and salute the Church and its members for its action to end complicity in the ongoing occupation, oppression and apartheid directed against Palestinians. The United Church was a leading voice in the movement against apartheid in South Africa, and this vote is a crucial victory in the Church’s voice re-emerging as a key voice for justice against apartheid.
Share:

From doubt to conviction: the United Church brings a difficult issue back into the mainstream



The recent decision by an overwhelming majority of the nearly 400 delegates of United Church of Canada to support a boycott of goods from the illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank was significant in four important ways.
First, because the Church has dared to approach this issue at all. For too long, the Israel-Palestine issue has been stuck in what seems like a shouting match between those who supportIsrael unconditionally and those who are principally concerned about the fate of the Palestinians. Even trying to raise the subject in public often evokes reflexive cries of “anti-Semitism”. But theUnited Church has shown that it is possible for Canadians to take a thoughtful, respectful, and fact-based approach to what is one of the thorniest and perhaps emotion-laden public policy issues forCanada and most other western countries.
Second, because the decision was so overwhelming. Many had feared that the debate would split the 600,000 member church, causing irreparable damage to one of Canada’s most respected institutions. Delegates were painfully aware that some groups were already painting the report as “unfair” and “unbalanced”. They also knew that many of their own members were still very uncomfortable voicing public criticism of Israel. Yet in the end, the vote was not even close. Nearly 80% supported the resolution.
Third, because the Church’s deliberate and thoughtful process was respectful of all and every opinion. In fact, a similar motion was rejected by the Church’s General Council three years ago, in the face of strident opposition from various outside groups and concern among its members. Faced with doubt, the delegates decided to set up a Working Group to give detailedstudy to the issue, which was instructed to report back to this General Council.
That working group travelled across Canada consulting church members and various outside partners including Muslim and Jewish organizations. In addition, it made a two-week trip to theIsrael and the Palestinian territories to see the situation on the ground first hand and meet with both Palestinians and Israelis. (The working group was denied access to Gaza and the report’s coverage of Gaza is limited.)
After much research and investigation, the working group submitted its report and proposal for consideration to this year’s week-long General Council in Ottawa.
In essence, the report concluded that it was a moral duty for the Church to take a stand against Israel’s occupation of Palestinian land, and against the expansion of settlements as key obstacles to finding peace between Israelis and Palestinians. These policies, it was pointed out on several occasions, are fully consistent with what is Canada’s official policy, though it is mostly ignored by senior government ministers.
The discussion on the report took place over several days, with many pauses for prayer and reflection. Countless corrections and amendments were suggested – some were approved, some not. United Church Moderator Mardi Tindal was unfailingly polite, respectful and thoughtful as she steered the discussion to a near unanimous conclusion.
Fourth, because the discussion on Israel/Palestine now moves back to hundreds of UnitedChurch congregations across Canada. The report of the working group and the hours of intense discussion during the General Council have been a valuable educational process for the 400 or so UCC “commissioners”. They return home with a much deeper understanding of the complicated Israel-Palestine issue and strengthened in their conviction that supporting the boycott of settlement products is neither unfair nor an act of anti Semitism.
In short, the United Church of Canada has succeeded in bringing discussion about Israel/Palestine into the mainstream of Canadian moral and political conversation.
Consideration of what Canadians should do in the face of a 45-year old occupation, the illegal destruction of Palestinian homes, the suffering of over 4 million Palestinian refugees, or even what Canadians think about Israel “as a Jewish State’ in which Jews have many rights not shared by its non-Jewish citizens, has begun to move from protest demonstrations to serious public discussion.
How long will it be before such an informed discourse reaches the ultimate public policy forum: Parliament itself?
Peter Larson is Vice-President of the National Council on Canada-Arab Relations and chair of its Education committee on Israel/Palestine.
Copyright 2012. All rights reserved.
Share:

United Church of Canada Israel/Palestine Proposal Passed!



After a final debate on Friday, August 17, 2012, that included prayer, praise, and some emotional pleas, the United Church has put its stamp of approval on a proposal that includes a call for a boycott of products from the illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank.


An attempt to amend the proposal to remove the economic action and require the church to remain neutral in the Israel-Palestine conflict was defeated in an intense debate at the 41st General Council. 

The General Council endorsed the report of The Working Group on Israel/Palestine Policy, whose policies and recommendations include recognition of Israel as a Jewish state, a call for renewed peace talks, and an end to the Israeli occupation of the West Bank.

During debate earlier this week the proposal was expanded to include a section denouncing ongoing aggression and violence toward the state of Israel and its people and recognizing it as an important contributor to injustice in the region. The section also recognized the ongoing violence and hatred directed at Palestinians by settlers in the occupied territories.

During the final debate on Friday another amendment was approved to send the report and its policies on to church members for “study, prayerful discernment, and personal action.”

It’s now up to the Executive of the General Council to identify products, such as cosmetics and electronics, from the illegal settlements and inform church members, said Bruce Gregersen, General Council Officer for Programs, at a news conference after the proposal was passed.

Gregersen acknowledged that the Canadian government does not require identification of products from the settlements, although some European countries do. General Council will ask the federal government to require that such products be identified.

The church will also encourage members to discuss the report of the working group and contact federal politicians to discuss the federal government’s position on Israel/Palestine, Gregersen said.

Click here to continue reading.


Click here for the complete text of all 13 motions approved by the UCC General Council on Israel/Palestine.
______
NECEF
7565 Newman Blvd.
P.O. Box 3067
Station LaPierre
Lasalle (Montreal) QC H8N 3H2
www.necef.org
Share:

Major Boycott Win - United Church supports boycott

CJPME Logo - En - Fr
In historic vote - United Church will boycott "Settlements" / L'Église Unie boycottera désormais les colonies 
Follow CJPME / Suivez CJPMO

Sign up to CJPME's list
Abonnez-vous Ã  la liste de CJPMO
Forward to a Friend 

  
CJPME volunteers pose by the CJPME info table at the UCC Convention. CJPME volunteers spoke with literally hundreds of the convention delegates. /  Des bénévoles au kiosque d'information de CJPMO, lors du Conseil de l'ÉUC. Les bénévoles de CJPMO ont réussi à sensibiliser des centaines de participants. 

Help us do more
Internet
Click here to donate or become a member online
MailClick here to print and mail in a form(9880 Clark St., Suite 225, Montreal, QC, H3L 2R3)
PhoneDonate or become a member by calling our office at 438-380-5410
Aidez-nous à faire plus
InternetCliquez ici  pour devenir membre ou faire un don

MailCliquez icipour obtenir un formulaire à poster (9880 Clark, bureau 225, Montréal, QC, H3L 2R3)
PhoneTéléphonez à CJPMO au 438-380-5410

Upcoming Events across Canada
 Calendar2
London

Montreal

Toronto

Click here to submit your own event
* Note that an event listing in CJPME's event calendar does not constitute an endorsement by CJPME


Événements à venir à travers le Canada

London

Montréal

Toronto

Cliquez ici pour soumettre votre propre événement
* Veuillez noter que l'inscription d'un événement au calendrier de CJPMO ne constitue pas un appui de la part de cette organisation.

La version française suit... 
CJPME present as Canadian Church makes historic vote


CJPME is delighted to announce that the United Church of Canada (UCC) voted earlier today to boycott products from Israel's illegal colonies (a.k.a. "settlements.") CJPME was present at the Church Convention, and had been speaking with (and distributing information) to church delegates attending the convention since Saturday. This vote, and related church resolutions represent a significant and exciting step forward for the boycott movement in Canada.

The vote today solidified broad support within the church for Palestinian human rights. CJPME representatives found church convention delegates to be highly informed on the issue of Israel-Palestine. Many of the church delegates had been to Israel-Palestine, and had observed first-hand the human rights abuses against Palestinians. The UCC resolution echoes similar motions passed by Presbyterian and Methodist churches in recent months in the United States.

The resolution, however, was not without its powerful opponents. The pro-Israel lobby was also active at the church convention, as evidenced by the presence of the "Centre for Israel and Jewish Advoacy" (CIJA), and "Faithful Witness," a Christian Zionist organization.

The United Church of Canada (UCC) has been considering some type of economic action in support of Palestinian human rights for several years. CJPME supported this direction within the church as actively as it could, both formally and informally. For example, in 2011, CJPME leaders met with the UCC Working Group on Israel-Palestine and challenged the church to act on its deep knowledge of the human rights abuses suffered by the Palestinians.

CJPME and the other Solidarity organizations active on the UCC file have much to celebrate through this vote. CJPME members and supporters have much to be proud of. May the momentum from this vote carry on to other boycott issues, organizations and companies in the coming months and years in Canada.

Sincerely,

Thomas Woodley
President, CJPME
 



L'CJPMO est sur place pour le scrutin historique tenu par l'Église canadienne

CJPMO est ravie d'annoncer que l'Église Unie du Canada (ÉUC) a voté aujourd'hui pour le boycottage de produits issus des colonies israéliennes illégales, dans le cadre de son Conseil général. Depuis samedi, CJPMO échange sur place avec les participants et leur distribue de l'information. Ce vote, ainsi que les résolutions afférentes adoptées par l'ÉUC, représente une étape importante et déterminante pour le mouvement de boycottage au Canada.

Le scrutin d'aujourd'hui a consolidé l'appui généralisé des membres de l'Église aux droits de la personne des Palestiniens. D'ailleurs, selon les représentants de CJPMO sur place, les délégués ont une bonne connaissance des enjeux israélo-palestiniens et plusieurs d'entre eux ont séjourné en Israël- Palestine, où ils ont été témoins de violations des droits de la personne à l'endroit de Palestiniens.

La résolution entérinée par l'ÉUC fait suite à l'adoption de motions semblables par des Églises presbytériennes et méthodistes aux États-Unis. Toutefois, elle a fait face à de puissants adversaires. En effet, le lobby pro-israélien a aussi mené des actions lors du Conseil, par l'entremise du Centre consultatif des relations juives et israéliennes (CERJI) et de Faithful Witness, une organisation chrétienne sioniste.

L'ÉUC envisage depuis plusieurs années d'adopter des mesures économiques pour appuyer la défense des droits de la personne des Palestiniens. CJPMO s'est efforcée de promouvoir activement une telle orientation au sein de l'Église, tant de façon formelle qu'informelle. Par exemple, en 2011, lors d'une rencontre avec le Groupe de travail sur la politique concernant Israël/Palestine, CJPMO a encouragé l'Église à réagir aux violations des droits de la personne envers les Palestiniens, un enjeu bien connu de cette dernière.

Tout comme les autres organisations de solidarité qui ont activement appuyé l'adoption de la résolution par l'Église, CJPMO se réjouit de l'issue du vote. Ses membres et ses adhérents peuvent également être fiers du résultat atteint. Souhaitons que ce vote donne l'élan nécessaire au mouvement boycottage pour qu'il s'étende à d'autres enjeux, organisations et entreprises au Canada dans les mois et années à venir.

Cordialement,

Thomas Woodley
Président, CJPMO
Share:

United Church of Canada vote in - YES to Economic Action!!!


UCC vote in -
YES to Economic Action!!!

 
The United Church of Canada has been in the spotlight for the past few months following the May release of the report of its Working Group on Israel/Palestine Policy.  One of the most controversial recommentions in the report was the call for an economic boycott focused exclusively on settlement products. Their recommendation was for the United Church to establish "a church-wide campaign of economic action directed against one or more settlement products that can be identified as produced in or related to the settlements or the occupied territories."

After discussions and intense debate over a period of 3 days, the United Church of Canada, at its General Council meeting, voted in favour in support of the Israel/Palestine Working Group’s recommendation of economic action.

Rev. Bruce Gregersen, Senior Program Officer, explains the United Church of Canada's action to ask its members to avoid buying goods produced in the illegal Israeli settlements, but in the end, it will be a matter of individual choice.

(Please click on the following link to view his interview.)


Below is a transcript of Rev. Gregerson’s interview withCatherine Rodd, Web Report for UCC GC41 


CR – What have the commissioners decided with relation to Israel / Palestine?

BG - This is a conclusion, of a fairly intense debate, that has covered a period of time of over 3 days.  In the series of motions, which in the end, a majority of commissioners voted, fairly substantially for, I guess the estimate might be 75-80%, in favour of the council first approved a series of recommendations which on the council doc where called 3 to 13.  Two of those were added.  One of them particular recognized the questions of incitement against Jews and against Israel and hatred of Israel as one of the causes that needs to be lifted up of the injustice and lack of peace in the region.  But through it all, the main focus of the report, dealing with the occupation, was maintained.  And in that, the council affirmed one of the key recommendations, and perhaps one of the most controversial recommendations, that it would support economic action against settlement products as a key direction that the church would undertake.

CR – The wording is not in the report, but there are people that what we are taking about is a boycott.

BG - In the report itself, what the working group recommended, is that we do not support the overall Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement.  Because there are significant challenges in that movement and it is outlined in the report.  So it was intentional for the working group to say economic action.  Is it a boycott?  Well I think someone would need to reflect on that.   But we don’t want to confusion our action with the overall Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movements.  But it is clearly, economic actin.  It is clearly inviting people to not buy settlement products because they represent illegal goods produced in illegal communities, in illegal settlements, in the West Bank.

CR – What does this mean for United Church congregations and United Church people across the country?

BG -  In respect to the overall report, the council added a small amendment to that, that said that the report will be sent out to the church for study, reflection and personal action.  The intent of that, I think, was to reinforce the understanding, that in the United Church of Canada, we don’t tell people what to do.  What we will do in this is we will invite consideration of it.  We will encourage people to study, to reflect, on the nature of the occupation, on the situation in the Middle East and then choose to take action.  But in the United Church of Canada, it is individuals’ choice on what they will do.



-- 
______
NECEF
7565 Newman Blvd.
P.O. Box 3067
Station LaPierre
Lasalle (Montreal) QC H8N 3H2
www.necef.org
Share:

Call for Action! G&M front page: Senators warn (United) church on Israel boycott

Engage!  This front page article today invites a flood of letters to the Editor (before 2pm today, 150 words max.) to make a difference:  letters@globeandmail.ca 

-----------------------------------------------

Canadian senators warn United Church over Israel boycott

by: CAMPBELL CLARK
July 4, 2012


 
A group of nine senators has warned the United Church of Canada that it could spark a rift with the Jewish community if it approves the boycott of goods from Israeli settlements in occupied lands.

The senators, all United Church members and from both the Conservative and Liberal parties, have waded publicly into a controversial issue before it comes to a vote in mid-August.

It’s a debate in which the lines between church and state have already been crossed several times as the United Church considers a new foray into the electrified world of Mideast politics.

A working group established by the church has issued a report that proposes a boycott of all products from Jewish settlements in occupied lands, arguing the settlements are illegally eating away Palestinian lands and the hope for a two-state solution. But it also rejects a wholesale boycott of all Israeli goods.

The nine senators have warned in a letter to United Church moderator Mardi Tindal that the distinction drawn with the narrower boycott will “be lost upon” Israelis and Canada’s Jewish community.

“What will be made clear to them is that the United Church has chosen sides, declaring Israel guilty and the Palestinians the only injured party,” the senators wrote.

Conservative Senator Nancy Ruth noted that she has no objection to the church wading into weighty international politics, but fears that members of the Jewish community will see itself as being singled out by an anti-Israel-sentiment.

“I’d say it’s a matter of diplomacy,” she said. “I don’t think it will be helpful for Jewish-Christian relations.

The church’s working group said it struggled with that issue. But its report maintained that arguments about the complexity of affairs in the Middle East are not an excuse for silence.

“It is long past the point where claims of complexity can remove responsibility for making judgments about the situation,” it said. “Simply put, Israel is maintaining a harsh occupation that must end so peace can emerge.”

The report concluded that the key target must be Jewish settlements in occupied Palestinian lands. It noted that those settlements are considered a violation of international law under both United Nations resolutions and official Canadian policy. The settlements are eroding Palestinians’ land and rapidly removing the basis for any two-state solution, it said.

But it did not assign blame for the failure of peace negotiations to either side and rejected a wider boycott of Israel.

“The working group intentionally chose not to target Israel, but rather the settlements, because we don’t in any way want to be confused with seeking to weaken or contribute to something that would harm Israel,” said Bruce Gregersen, the senior program officer at the United Church, who worked on the report.

But that argument was rejected by Shimon Fogel, chief executive officer of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs. Boycotting settlements alone is technically impractical, and it’s really no different than that of a larger boycott aimed at delegitimizing Israel, Mr. Fogel said. “There’s an effort to disguise what the real intent is,” he said.

He said the United Church should explain why it has focused on Israel when Christian communities around the region are under threat.

The United Church of Canada is one of the country’s big Protestant denominations. It counts 650,000 members, but more than 2.5-million – 8 per cent of Canada’s population – identify themselves as followers of the church, according to Statistics Canada.

Its highest body, the General Council, will decide in a vote expected Aug. 14 whether to endorse the boycott. It’s a powerful symbol of church guidance, but council-approved policy is not considered a dictate to the church’s followers.
 


-- 
______
NECEF
7565 Newman Blvd.
P.O. Box 3067
Station LaPierre
Lasalle (Montreal) QC H8N 3H2
www.necef.org
Share:

UNITED CHURCH RESPONSE TO CAN. SENATORS RE ISRAEL

First see article in today's Globe and Mail: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/senators-warn-united-church-over-israel-boycott/article4387825/ 
 
http://www.united-church.ca/communications/news/general/120703

July 3, 2012 Senator Nancy Ruth, 
The Senate of Canada Ottawa, Ontario Canada K1A 0A4 

Dear Senator Nancy Ruth, 

Thank you for your letter concerning the Report of the Working Group on Israel Palestine Policy. I recognize your concern about the implications of the report and of course understand the significant challenges it presents to Jewish United Church relationships. The Report was prepared by an elected member group chosen from the members of the Executive of General Council in response to the direction of the 40th General Council. I assure you that it has been prepared with full understanding of its implications, and with careful attention to the voices of both Jewish and Palestinian colleagues. 

I was pleased to be able to join the Working Group in parts of its processes of consultation, including a visit to Israel Palestine last year. However, as the Working Group moved into deliberation and writing of its report, I intentionally withdrew from the process recognizing the need to remain neutral and unattached to its recommendations given that I will be presiding during the Council. The recommendations of the Working Group will come to the full General Council for deliberation and vote. 

It would, therefore, be inappropriate for me to comment on the report. 
Commissioners to General Council will receive both the report and a selection of the many responses that have been received. Among them we will include your letter. I have also asked the Working Group to provide a more detailed response to the issues you raise. 

Again, thank you and your Senate colleagues for the concern you hold for the United Church, your community of faith, and for the many ways you seek to live out God’s mission in your daily work in the Senate. 
In the deep peace of Christ, 

Moderator 
Mardi Tindal 
The United Church of Canada/L’Église Unie du Canada 

cc: Senator Bert Brown Senator Jim Munson 
Senator George Baker Senator James Cowan 
Senator Elizabeth Hubley Senator Yonah Martin 
Senator Dennis Patterson Senator Carolyn Stewart Olsen

__________________________________________________________
 
 
July 3, 2012 Senator Nancy Ruth, 
The Senate of Canada, 
Ottawa, Ontario 
K1A 0A4 
Dear Senator Nancy Ruth, 
Your letter of June 27th has been forwarded to us for response. We appreciate the concerns raised in your letter and most of all appreciate your care for the church and its relationship with the Jewish community in Canada. We too are deeply concerned for the implications of our report both for relations with the Jewish community and as well for the situation of Palestinians. We understand the challenge of conflicting narratives and the assessment that "choosing sides" implies assigning guilt to one party. 
We wish to assure you that the Working Group struggled with this question through the two full years of its work. We also want to assure you that we did not enter this process with a predetermined outcome in mind. Our deliberations were intense and open to listening deeply to the many sides of this undoubtedly complex situation. We also want to indicate that we came at this task with significant support and depth in relationship to the issues involved. 
Staff that supported us in our work included overseas personnel who have worked in the region, most recently for several years with the Heads of Churches of Jerusalem. Our senior staff person served for a decade as the InterFaith Officer of the church and was involved in the development of the church’s groundbreaking document on United Church–Jewish relationships, 
Bearing Faithful Witness. Other staff have been involved for numerous years in ongoing contact and relationship with Jewish and Palestinian partners in the region. One of our members spent three months in the region, during the time of the writing of the report, in addition to the Working Group’s own visit to the region. All of this is secondary to the depth of partnership that has framed our relationships in the region extending back into medical mission work in Gaza in the 1950s and forward until today. Most significantly we have strengthened our relationship with Palestinian Christians who have called out to us and to Christians throughout the world. Their voice is a critical part of our report. 
The Report has made a deliberate choice to focus on the ending of the occupation as the necessary step in moving towards peace in the region. We did so recognizing the significant implications of Israel’s continued expansion of the illegal settlements and therefore the continued dispossession of Palestinians. We find it hard to justify a neutral stance to this reality which in the end means that it is in Israel’s interest to delay any resolution while continuing to create "facts on the ground." The Working Group has also experienced and witnessed the harsh reality of the occupation which remains invisible to most Jewish colleagues and to those who are not able to visit and talk directly with Palestinians. 
Nevertheless, our report offers directions about which Palestinian partners have significant concerns. Our decision to continue to recognize Israel as a Jewish State is highly controversial among Christian Palestinian partners. Their concern is that if Palestinians recognize Israel as a Jewish State it will then provide support to those who wish to have Palestine become an Islamic state. Palestinian Christians strongly desire Palestine to be a secular democratic state, something they believe is only likely if Israel remains that as well. 
The report also proposes an understanding of the Palestinian Right of Return that is contentious within the Palestinian community. While upholding the need for a negotiated settlement to the right of return, the report clearly indicates that a resolution of this must be undertaken in a way that does not undermine the demographic integrity of Israel. The recommendations also uphold a right of return for all refugees, including Jews displaced during the war of 1948. (Please note that this is found in the recommendations section as well as in the body of the report.) 
These issues alone are highly significant and challenging to most Palestinians. It would be possible to add to them the report’s strong support for a two-state solution and the critique of a bi-national state (one state) solution; its advice against the language of Apartheid applied to Israel; and the critique raised of the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions Campaign. We offer these parts of the report as an indication that it is inaccurate to suggest that the report "does not mention a single expectation of the Palestinians." 
Your letter also argues that economic action against settlement products is indistinguishable from Israeli products. We note the increased emphasis within the Jewish community itself on settlement products. (Please see Peter Beinart’s book 
The Crisis of Zionism.) We also note that several countries, including the UK, Denmark and South Africa, have now required that settlement products be clearly marked as distinct from products produced in Israel itself. It is also critically important to the Working Group’s recommendation that Israeli settlements in the West Bank are illegal according to international law and the policies of most countries in the world, including Canada. Buying products from these settlements is benefiting from and supporting illegal activity. Again, we appreciate the concern that you have for the implications of the report for United Church–Jewish relations. The Working Group believes that the report itself does reflect with great care the complexities of the issue. But it also makes a choice that remaining neutral in respect to the difficult realities of the region is not acceptable after 45 years of continued occupation. 
Sincerely, 
Bruce Gregersen 
Staff of the Working Group on Israel Palestine Policy 
cc: Senator Bert Brown 
Senator Yonah Martin 
Senator Dennis Patterson 
Senator Carolyn Stewart Olsen 
Senator Jim Munson 
Senator George Baker 
Senator James Cowan 
Senator Elizabeth Hubley 
Share: