Showing posts with label Sonja Karkar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sonja Karkar. Show all posts

Talking Palestine to Power

By Sonja Karkar |  Journal of Palestinian Refugee Studies – Volume 2, Issue 1, Spring 2012
[revised from an earlier version in 2009]
Today, there is no excuse for not knowing the truth about Palestine.  Even taking the disinformation spread in mainstream media, there are enough glimpses one gets of an oppressed people in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem that should compel us to ask questions. This has been considerably aided by the internet.  Where once Israel could manipulate the media narrative, now millions can see videos and read witness accounts of Israel’s occupation in all its terrifying ugliness. Global initiatives, like the daring Free Gaza flotillas, force the mainstream media to report this news, however fleetingly.  Consequently, people want to see for themselves what is happening in Palestine and come back with stories that have shaken them to the very core of their being.
Stories of endless queues of people at checkpoints waiting for permission from armed soldiers who decide if they should pass; devastated families making sense of the rubble that was once their homes as Israeli bulldozers move on to the next calculated demolition; heartbroken farmers grieving over their centuries-old uprooted olive trees and scorched earth orchards; already traumatised children wondering if the next missile or bomb will this time wipe out their families or friends; terrified citizens waiting for the sound of army squads coming to arrest who knows who in the early hours of the morning; and the shadow of that rapacious Wall darkening the landscape even as it closes off the world to the Palestinians it imprisons.
And these are only the obvious signs of Israel’s apartheid plans as it moves to cement an exclusively Jewish state in a land that is home to almost an equal number of Palestinians and millions more in exile waiting to return home.
The alarm bells should be ringing when this information filters through, and yet there is a wall of silence while our political leaders declare undying fealty to Israel or cavalierly wear it as a badge of honour or indulge in junkets to Israel.  And those bells should be all the more alarming, when documented reports of Israel’s war crimes by human rights groups and official enquiries are virulently attacked and then ignored.
But the world lacks courage.  People are terrified of being labelled anti-Semitic.  Even Palestinians, who are themselves Semites, are often afraid of being further shunned and disadvantaged in countries that give them refuge.  Not only do people fear repercussions, but speaking the truth or even just hearing it has a way of taking people out of their comfort zones. They fear their troubled consciences may require them to act and so they bury their heads deeper into the sand where they hope even the sounds of silence might be extinguished.
This then is the challenge for advocates the world over.  How does one talk Palestine to power if one cannot even talk Palestine to the people who are in fear of the powerful?
In the face of Zionist saturation media and the new “Brand Israel” campaigns, many people wanting to advocate for Palestine might feel defeated, but time and again we see that the individual talking truth to power can be enormously effective.
The now deceased scholar and public intellectual Edward Said, showed more than anyone else that individuals can make a difference in the public defence of Palestine. He particularly saw the intellectual’s voice as having “resonance”.    In fact, it is so powerful that intellectuals have been subjected to all kinds of vicious campaigns against their persons and positions for speaking up for Palestine, just as Said was himself.
Of course, one does not need to be an intellectual.  Said’s words can just as aptly apply to any one of us. He said avoidance was “reprehensible” and described it as,
“that characteristic turning away from a difficult and principled position which you know to be the right one, but which you decide not to take.  You do not want to appear too political; you are afraid of seeming too controversial; you need the approval of a boss or an authority figure; you want to keep a reputation for being balanced, objective, moderate; your hope is . . . to remain within the responsible mainstream . . .”[1]
As an intellectual, Said had his academic record, his professional standing, his research and his publications to give weight to his pronouncements, but it took no less courage than it would for anyone else to challenge the accepted paradigm.  The challenge arises out of knowing the truth; the courage arises out of a commitment to principle in the face of collective condemnation.  This is just as true against the Zionist barrage of lies as it is against convenient explanations mounted by those who accommodate the powers that be for their own ends.
In 1993 when almost everyone else thought the handshakes on the White House steps would seal the negotiated Oslo Accords and at long last give the Palestinians their freedom and bring peace to the region, Edward Said saw that these accords would merely provide the cover for Israel to pursue its colonial expansionism and consolidate its occupation of Palestine.  However, he knew to criticise Oslo meant in effect taking a position against ‘hope’ and ‘peace’. His decision to do so also flew in the face of the Palestinian revolutionary leadership that had bartered for statehood.
Although Said was denounced for his views, he was not prepared to buy into the deception that he knew would leave the Palestinians with neither hope nor peace. And just as he predicted, each fruitless year of peacemaking finally exposed the horrible reality of Oslo as Palestinians found themselves the victims of Israel’s matrix of control, a term used to describe the situation by the Israeli activist Dr Jeff Halper in 1999.[2] And this domination of one people over another without any intention of addressing the injustices of the Palestinians ethnically cleansed from their homeland, has undeniably reduced Israel to an Apartheid state.
The Palestinians have nothing left worth calling a state and they are facing an existential threat on all fronts.  Yet, intellectuals are still talking about a two state solution in lock step with the politicians, a mantra that is repeated uncritically, even mendaciously, in the mainstream media. Media pundits argue that it is Israel facing an existential threat, but it is becoming evident every day, that against Israel, which is armed to the teeth with nuclear and conventional weaponry, the Palestinians do not stand a chance.  They have never had an army and have no acceptable means to fight off their own ongoing dispossession and occupation of their homeland.  It is no wonder the two state solution became the panacea to the Palestinian struggle for self-determination.
This pandering to an idea for twenty long years has been undermined by the furious sounds of drills and hammers reverberating in illegal settlements throughout the West Bank and East Jerusalem and the catastrophic societal ruptures engineered in Gaza.  Now those sounds are muffled by the rhetoric of “economic peace”, “institution-building”, “democracy”, “internal security” and “statehood”. These words must be challenged at every opportunity, for they are not only words, but dangerous concepts when isolated from truth on the ground.
It is no use talking about “economic peace” if you fail to understand that industrial estates built for Palestinian workers are intended to provide Israel with slave labour and cheap goods. It is useless to support “institution-building” when Israel continues to undermine and obstruct those programs already struggling to service Palestinian society. It is a lie to speak of “democracy” when fair elections in 2006 had Israel and the world denying Hamas the right to govern.  It is a charade to accept “internal security” when arming and training Palestinians to police their own people covers for Israel’s and America’s divide and conquer scheme. It is hollow to speak of “statehood” when Israel keeps stealing land and building illegal settlements that deprive the Palestinians of their homes and livelihoods while herding them into isolated and walled-in ghettoes.
Regrettably, Edward Said was proved right.
Now, it is our turn to speak the truth and act fearlessly, regardless of the censure we are likely to encounter. The German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer is believed to have said that truth passes through three stages: “first, it is ridiculed; second, it is violently opposed; third, it is accepted as being self-evident.”  Today, we are at the third stage:  the 11 million Palestinians, whether living under occupation, as second-class citizens in Israel, as stateless refugees or others in the Diaspora, are the living truth. That is Israel’s Achilles’ heel and Israel knows it.
The Palestinians are no longer the humble shepherds and farmers that Zionist forces terrorised into fleeing to make way for the Jewish state of Israel. A new generation wants justice and it is demanding it eloquently, non-violently and strategically.  Their message:  no normal relations with Israel while it oppresses Palestinians, denies their rights and violates international law.  And boycotts, divestment and sanctions are the legitimate tools for challenging a state that claims exceptionalism and which perpetrates extreme and criminal actions to ensure that status.
People, of course, are always tempted to opt for the path of least resistance, especially when they simply cannot empathise with those who have been so successfully misrepresented and demonised by the Western media.  However, the world is changing, and slowly people are realising that they too are vulnerable as Western societies begin to crumble under the weight of government power, which is burgeoning out of control without any checks or balances. Universal human rights and principles of international humanitarian law that once were the mainstay of our democracies have been cast aside in the stampede to fight the “war on terror” and few have been brave enough to challenge the current system.
It is indeed possible for all of us to “squeeze out of reality some of its potentialities”[3], the stuff that University of Melbourne Professor Ghassan Hage says is found in those utopic moments that come from challenging our own thoughts, fears and biases.  In that space lies the untapped power we seek to speak the truth without fear or favour.  In that space lies the potential for political change.  In that space, there will always be those who resist and speak Palestine to power.
__________________
[1] Edward Said, Representations of the Intellectual. London: Vintage, 1994, p74
[2] Jeff Halper, “The 94 Percent Solution: The Matrix of Control”, Fall 2000, Middle East Report 216
[3] Ghassan Hage, “The Real, the Potential and the Political”, an essay presented at the 2004 Res Artis Conference, Sydney, 10-16 August 2004
Share:

COUNTDOWN TO GENOCIDE

Gaza exploding copy


They came one cold December day. Not fearless warriors but fearsome hoardes hell-bent on destruction of the genocidal kind that leaves no room for regeneration. That was one year ago in Gaza.

The attack shocked a complacent world into finally seeing Israel’s merciless ferocity against the Palestinians already hounded, herded and imprisoned in compounds throughout their land, if not actually driven out. More than sixty years of Western devotion to Israel’s security was blown wide open as truth shattered spin in three weeks of carnage and devastation.

Dead bodies do not lie and neither do the maimed and the disfigured. Thousands have been left to make sense of the horrors they saw and the hollow aftermath to which they have been abandoned. Landscapes of rubble as far as the eye can see are still testament to the homes once standing in villages and towns, the homeless now huddled in tents while they wait one year on for materials to re-build. Little food, contaminated water, rationed fuel and electricity and the barest of medical supplies are just more of many cruel and wanton deprivations pushing Palestinian society to the limits of endurance.

This is Gaza: a population of 1.5 million people kept in formaldehyde by Israel’s crippling siege. It is a human catastrophe that has many enablers. World leaders have shut their eyes to the crimes witnessed and documented countless times over by human rights groups. World media continuously sidesteps the truth and deliberately ignores international efforts to highlight the humanitarian crisis. Together they are complicit in Israel’s dehumanisation of a people.

We are also complicit if we remain silent and do nothing. It is not enough to know and empathise. Change can only come from people being engaged – learning, thinking, communicating, and being prepared to act.

Almost 2000 internationals have taken action. Some 200 are in Jordan after a three-week trek through Europe in the Viva Palestina convoy of trucks filled with humanitarian aid while another 300 joined them from Greece, Turkey and Jordan; and then, there are the 1400 who have landed in Egypt from all over the world for the scheduled Gaza Freedom March on 31 December. Neither group has been given clearance to enter Gaza. This is where the rest of us who were unable to join these brave souls can bring some power to bear.

There simply is no time to waste. Letters, faxes, emails must be written to governments, embassies and media outlets. Not one letter, not one time, but a constant stream. We have to urge friends and families to write as well. We have to urge governments to put pressure on Egypt to open the Rafah crossing and pressure on Israel to lift the siege. We have to hound the media like they hound us when they sniff a story. And Gaza is a story that needs to be told. The marchers and the convoy bringing aid to a besieged Gaza are only a part of that story. The real story is Israel’s ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians from their homeland.

Israel must be held to account because it is the instigator of all this misery. Israel has acted with impunity for far too long. It is a bully in world affairs and our leaders and media are all shamefully intimidated. Only people coming together collectively can change that dynamic – and we must come together, before we too become craven hostages to Israel’s criminal enterprise.

Standing up for Palestinian human rights is not anti-Semitic because the Palestinians are also a Semitic people. Nor is it anti-Israel, but rather a protest against Israel’s Zionist policies and practices designed to permanently fragment and dissipate Palestinian society. So brutal is its Zionist agenda and so contrary to Judaic teachings that many Jews are already speaking out in shame at what is being done in their name.

As decent and honourable citizens of the world, we too need to speak out in shame at what we have allowed to occur for far too long. Terrible crimes have been committed and some predict that even more terrible ones are to come. The reality is that all along we have been witnessing a slow genocide and we have allowed guilt, pragmatism and self-interest to stand in the way of our common humanity. The world needs to say “enough” and refuse to indulge Israel’s Zionist leaders and advocates whose free ride has taken them to the heady heights of arrogance. That universal effort needs to begin before the bitter winter freezes any kind of hope in Gaza and it needs to be sustained for as long as it takes to free all of Palestine. Anything less, will hasten a 21st century genocide.

by Sonja Karkar - Australians for Palestine -
Share:

Australia hosts war criminal Ehud Olmert


Sonja Karkar,


The news that former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was in Australia and was welcomed by the honorable members of our parliament came as somewhat of a shock. It is one thing to have allowed a man charged with corruption and suspected of war crimes into Australia at all; it is another thing that he was listed as a distinguished guest in Hansard -- the official record of parliamentary proceedings -- and received a resounding "hear, hear" from our elected representatives.

As a High Contracting Party to the Fourth Geneva Convention, Australia has a duty to bring before its courts those responsible for alleged violations amounting to grave breaches of the convention. The UN-commissioned Goldstone report and other investigations into Israel's conduct during its attack on Gaza last winter by Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, the International Committee of the Red Cross and others, make for chilling reading of what the Palestinians in Gaza are made to endure for Israel's "security." Our government has shown a callous disregard for Palestinian human rights and no amount of aid can compensate for its cavalier decisions to back Israel regardless.

Only last month, the UK's Guardian reported that a UK lawyer "is working to expand the application of 'universal jurisdiction' for offenses involving serious human rights abuses committed anywhere in the world." A number of Israeli politicians and military leaders have already come close to being arrested in some European countries and Olmert would most likely face arrest if he visited Britain. It is only a matter of time before those wanted for war crimes will find themselves subjected to universal jurisdiction wherever they go, not least because of Israel's failure to undertake a genuine independent investigation into alleged war crimes as urged by the Goldstone report.

Australia's politicians on both sides of the spectrum are sending the wrong message when they open their arms to every visiting Israeli official. Not only are they condoning violations of international law, but they leave themselves open to charges of hypocrisy and racism. To wit, Australia's smearing of Dr. Mohamed Haneef for allegedly supporting terrorist attacks on no more evidence than innuendo and suspicion, which at the time then Opposition Leader Kevin Rudd backed without a whimper; and similarly, the government's ugly fear-mongering about asylum seekers, conflating them with terrorists.

Ehud Olmert is wanted for war crimes. Those war crimes have been amply documented. As Israel's prime minister at the time, there can be no doubt that Olmert knew the consequences of the military operations he approved and ordered. And he is by no means the only one.

Australia's position on war crimes is very clear. A recent letter from the attorney-general in response to a request from a concerned citizen for more information about Australia's handling of cases involving alleged war criminals states "the Federal Government takes the allegation of war crimes very seriously" regardless of where they are committed or by whom. The letter continues:

"Australia takes an active role in identifying and investigating anyone who may have had involvement in human rights abuses and war crimes, including those that have occurred overseas. If there is evidence on which to base a prosecution under Commonwealth law, the Australian Federal Police will give that evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public prosecutions (CDPP). It is then a matter for the CDPP to consider, in accordance with theProsecution Policy of the Commonwealth, whether there is sufficient evidence, reasonable prospects of securing a conviction, and whether a prosecution is in the public interest."

There is a danger that Australia could become a safe haven for Israeli war criminals if political pressure is allowed to interfere in the work of the judiciary, despite Australia's obligations under international law and Division 268 of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), which criminalizes genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity. The question for Australians will be whether justice and universal human rights is something they wish to champion over the political concerns and self-interests of whatever government is in power. The opportunity was missed with Olmert, but there will be no shortage of opportunities as long as our government continues to play host to war criminals whether from Israel or elsewhere.
Share:

MORE ON ISRAELI WAR CRIMINAL EHUD OLMERT




According to J-wire – Jewish Online News from Australia and New Zealand,
Olmert is in Australia attending the Australia-Israel Leadership Forum in
Melbourne this coming week. We have no other details. Also arriving in
Australia next week is the Israeli Vice Prime Minister Silvan Shalom who
will be attending a gala dinner in Melbourne on 6 December hosted by the
Australia Israel Cultural Exchange (AICA). Australia’s prime minister
Kevin Rudd will be there as well. For more information about Silvan Shalom
and the protest being organised see our website
http://australiansforpalestine.com/6-dec-melbourne-protest-visit-of-israels-vice-prime-minister

Don’t let Australia become a safe haven for war criminals. We ask you to
write to your local member, government ministers and the media
protesting visits and immunity given to suspected war criminals and demand
that Australia honours its obligations under international human rights
conventions by detaining anyone deemed to be war criminals until court
proceedings under universal jurisdiction can be brought against them.
Contact details available on our website
http://australiansforpalestine.com/

Sonja Karkar
Editor
Australians for Palestine
Share:

AUSTRALIA & ISRAEL FORGE CLOSER TIES AFTER RACIST CONFERENCE

With the echoes of outrage still resounding after the farcical walkout
during President Ahmadinejad’s speech at the Durban Review Conference in
Geneva last week, it is clear that those howling the loudest have not
bothered to read it or have put their lot in holus-bolus with Israel. One
such is our own Prime Minister Kevin Rudd who attended the Australia-Israel
Chamber of Commerce luncheon on Friday and had no qualms of conscience in
giving the obligatory obeisance to Israel. So what did the prime minister
say?“I further acknowledge the great work of the Australia-Israel Chamber of Commerce in hosting today’s function and in supporting the relationship between Australia and Israel and enabling me to confirm again publicly
before you all what I have said throughout my political career that I am a
lifelong friend of the State of Israel.”

And further, in relation to the Durban Review Conference:

“Australia cannot support and will not support a document which reaffirms
the 2001 Durban declaration and program of action. That 2001 declaration
singled out Israel. The inflammatory remarks of President Admadinejad of
Iran at the conference are unacceptable and underlined the Australian
Government’s decision not to attend that conference. The Australian
Government condemns the continued campaign of anti-Semitism on behalf
of the government of Iran.”

The prime minister’s full speech can be heard by accessing this link
http://www.brr.com.au/event/57198/partner/theaustralian

Just to reiterate a statement made in an earlier email on the Durban Review
Conference - there was nothing anti-Semitic in the speech given by President
Ahmadinejad. It is the usual charge to stop any criticism of Israel and also to
dump on Iran, possibly as a demonising lead up to a war that Israel wants and
may well ignite, drawing in the whole world.

Well might we ask - why is our new Labor Government of so much promise,
falling over itself to declare fealty to Israel? According to a news report this
weekend (appropriately on Anzac Day), the prime minister is set to announce
a $100 billion-plus military plan – the biggest build-up since World War II – and
although nothing has been reported yet, Israel may well be involved. It was
just 18 months ago that Israel’s new ambassador to Australia said “we’ll see
if there is room for further co-operation on defence and security-related
matters” once the Free Trade Agreement is finalised. In 2006, Australia
received classified defence technology from Israel totalling $14 million - a
figure projected for fast growth that is likely to see Australia acquiring
high-end robotic technology, smart missiles and unmanned aerial drones from
Israel which is known to be the world leader in these areas. Training
exchanges involving Australian and Israeli Defence Force personnel are
already taking place. (“Israel deal to boost defence”, The Australian,
26/9/07).

It seems though that Israel has not learned its lesson over the deeply-held
attachment Australians have for the resting places of their fallen soldiers.
Only last year, Israeli officials faced embarrassment over the neglect of
the historic site in Beersheba where Australian soldiers had fought and won
a significant victory. The Australian government had to order an
investigation into the shocking state of the site caused by Israelis who
used it as a rubbish tip. Australia’s Pratt Foundation created a big affair
by setting up a theme park in memory of the Australian soldiers and
commissioning a statue for it.

This year, Israel bombarded the Gaza War Cemetery of 3,000 graves and ended
up badly damaging some 300 graves, 10 of which belonged to Australian
diggers. While at first there were disgraceful hints that this was the work
of Palestinian militants and that the graves had not been properly tended,
the spent shells from Israeli tanks were clearly evident in the cemetery.
Furthermore, past Australian visitors to Gaza were able to vouch for the
beautifully-tended cemetery before Israel’s attack. It perhaps says
something that for the very first time since 1917, an Anzac Day service was
permitted in Gaza to remember the 230 soldiers buried there, new headstones
were allowed in to replace the damaged ones and Ibrahim Jeradeh, the
Palestinian gardener who has tended those graves for 50 years was awarded a
plaque in recognition of his work.

Returning to the Durban Review Conference that our prime minister dismissed
because of what he calls a continued campaign of anti-Semitism by the
government of Iran, we have included for your interest four
statements/articles by four eminent Jews who have shown no reluctance to
call Israel a racist state, worse than Apartheid South Africa, born out of
Jewish terrorism, guilty of war crimes, and beginning to go the way of the
Nazis with its genocidal acts that threaten to wipe out Palestinian society.
Now why would they say these things unless there is enough evidence to
warrant such statements? Unlike others who sit on the sidelines and are
quick to mouth what is expected of them without a moment’s thought for the
lives of so many innocent Palestinians, Pappe, Kaufman, Falk and Kasrils
have come to their conclusions after much painful deliberation. Please do
them the courtesy of reading what they have to say. It should make our
prime minister think twice about bonding Australia unconditionally closer
to Israel.

- SK
Share:

Jeff Halper and censorship from Australia’s Jewish community

Jeff Halper is now back in Israel after a successful two week speaking tour of Australia during the month of March. Yet, the repercussions of his visit are still resounding. Certainly, those who were fortunate enough to hear him speak remain inspired by his vision and practical solutions for the seemingly insurmountable problems of the Israel/Palestine conflict, but it is those solutions that are so threatening to the organised Jewish community. In fact, so threatening that The Australian Jewish News refused to publish any advertisements promoting his speaking engagements and the Emanuel Synagogue in Sydney decided to cancel his proposed talk.

The talk went ahead in a church for an audience of Jews who have increasingly been prepared to break their silence on the destructive policies and practices that Israel is carrying out on an imprisoned population of almost 4 million Palestinians in their own land. More than that though, the debate continued with articles, editorial and letters in Sydney’s mainstream newspaper and on the blog of well–known journalist and
writer Antony Loewenstein who has done sterling job of calling out the editor of the AJN, Robert Magid who said that he did not run the ad because he didn’t like the promoters of Halper’s tour. Another disingenuous letter from Magid followed and a week later, Bren Carlill – an apologist for Israel – claimed in an article on the ABC’s “Unleashed” that Halper had been disseminating “falsehoods” that had gone from “ridiculous to outrageous”.

Although well and truly away from Australia’s shores, Jeff Halper has responded to his critics. One article was refused by the AJN but was published on Antony Loewenstein’s blog. It is a challenge to Australia’s Jewish
community that for too long has lived in a bubble where Israel can do no wrong. Coming from an Israeli, Halper’s words should alert Jews here that discourse is alive and well amongst Israelis in the very state to which they give blind subservience from afar.

In a second article, Jeff Halper is given space on the ABC’s ”Unleashed” program to make his case entitled “On the road to apartheid”. Let us hope that the next time Jeff Halper comes to Australia, the wider organised Jewish community will give him the courtesy of an audience and a healthy debate.

We have also included in this newsletter a link to an excellent video on The Israel Lobby in the US. It is well worth watching as it looks at the influence that the pro-Israel lobby wields in the the decision-making
structure and process of the US administration. (See below.)

- SK


An unhelpful discourse on Israel

Antony Loewenstein blog
<http://antonyloewenstein.com/blog/2009/03/31/an-unhelpful-discourse-on-israel/
The following article is written by Israeli/American peace activist Jeff Halper for the Australian Jewish News, but the paper refuses to run the piece, despite spending weeks attacking Halper and his supporters in its
pages:

The uproar in the organized Jewish community over the prospect of my speaking in Australia is truly startling to an Israeli like me. Granted, I am very critical of Israel’s policies of Occupation and doubt whether a
two-state solution is still possible given the extent of Israel’s settlements, but this hardly warrants the kind of demonization I received in the pages of The AJN. Opinions similar to mine are readily available in
the mainstream Israeli media. Indeed, I myself write frequently for the Israeli press and appear regularly on Israeli TV and radio.

Why, then, the hysteria? Why was I banned from Temple Emmanuel in Sydney, a self-proclaimed progressive synagogue? Why did I, an Israeli, have to address the Jewish community from a church? Why was I invited to speak in every university in eastern Australia yet, at Monash University, I was forced to hold a secret meeting with Jewish faculty in a darkened room far from the halls of intellectual discourse? Why, when the “leaders” of the Jewish community were excoriating me and my positions, did the Israelis who attended my talks express such appreciation that “real” Israeli views were finally getting aired in Australia, even if they did not all agree with me?

Given the support my right to speak evidenced by most of the letters published in The AJN, this all raises disturbing questions over the right of Australian Jews to hear divergent views on Israel’s conflict with the
Palestinians held by Israelis themselves.

It raises an even deeper issue, however. What should be the relationship of Diaspora Jewry to Israel? Whatever threat I represented to the organized Jewish community of Australia had less to do with Israel, I suspect, than with some damage I might to do to the idealized “Leon Uris” image of Israel
which you hold onto so dearly. This might seem like a strange thing to say, but I do not believe that you in the Diaspora have internalized the fact that Israel is a foreign country as far from your idealized version as
Australia is far from its image as kangaroo-land. Countries change, they evolve. What would Australia’s European founders think – even those who until very recently pursued a “White Australia” policy – if they were to see the multi-cultural country you have become? Well, almost 30% of Israeli citizens are not Jews, we may very well have permanently incorporated another four million Palestinians – the residents of the Occupied Territories – into our country and, to top it off, it’s clear by now that the vast majority of the world’s Jews are not going to emigrate to Israel.

Those facts, plus the urgent need of Israel to make peace with its neighbors, mean something. They mean that Israel must change in ways Ben Gurion, Leon Uris and Mark Leibler never envisioned, even if that’s hard
for you to accept.

Yet I see this as a positive thing, a sign of a healthy country coming to grips with reality, some of it of its own creation, even if it means that Israel will evolve from a Jewish state into a state of all its citizens – a
bi-national or democratic state. Rather than “eliminating” Israel, this challenge is in fact a natural and probably inevitable development. It will not be easy, but if you can become multi-cultural, so can we.

But that’s our problem as Israelis. What’s your problem? Why should discussing such important issues for Israel be the cause of such distress for you? Because, I venture to say, you have a stake in preserving Israel’s
idealized image that trumps dealing with the real country. In my view, Israel is being used as the lynchpin of your ethnic identity in Australia; mobilizing around a beleaguered Israel is essential for keeping your kids
Jewish. I would go so far as to accuse you of needing an Israel in conflict, which is why you seem so threatened by an Israel at peace, why you deny that peace is even possible, why a peaceful Israel that is neither
threatened nor “Jewish” cannot fulfill the role you have cast for it, and thus why you characterize my message as “vile lies.”

This, to be honest, is the threat I represent. Only this can explain why rabbis, community “leaders” and Jewish professors choose to meet me secretly rather than have me, a critical Israel, in their synagogues or
classrooms. This is all understandable. You do need a lynchpin if you are to preserve your identity as a prosperous community in a tolerant multi-cultural society. I would just question whether the real country of
Israel can fulfill that role, or even if it’s fair to Israel to expect it to.

We are different peoples. Israel can no more define Diaspora Jewish life than you can define Israel. Rather than knee-jerk defense of an imaginary place, you need to develop a respect for Israel and Israeli voices, a
respect that will come only when you start regarding Israel as a real country. And you have to get a life of your own. You have to develop alternative Diaspora Jewish cultures and identities. Ironically, after all
I have said, the Israeli government will resist that, for it uses you as agents to support its policies, often extreme right-wing and militaristic policies that contradict your very values of cultural pluralism and human
rights. Remember: Israel does what it does in your name. Unless you take an independent position, you are complicit.

What befell me in Australia is just a tiny piece of a sad story of mutual exploitation: you using Israel to keep your community together, Israel using you to defend its indefensible policies. Perhaps something good can
emerge from all this: robust discussion on the nature of Israeli-Diaspora relations. I’m going home to Jerusalem. You have to let Israel go and get a [Jewish] life.

Jeff Halper is the Director of the Israeli Committee Against House
Demolitions http://www.icahd.org/eng/ , a peace and human rights organization dedicated to achieving a just peace between Israelis and Palestinians. He can be reached at jeff@icahd.org

On the road to apartheid

by Jeff Halper

ABC “Unleashed” program

It was appropriate that April 1 marked the first day of the new
Netanyahu-Lieberman-Barak government. For the notion that Israel acts
against the Palestinians out of concern for its security, that it maintains
its Occupation of 42 years for defensive reasons, that it really attacked
Gaza in such a vicious and disproportional way because of an actual security
threat or that it genuinely wants peace is increasingly seen by thinking
people as an April Fool's joke.

In fact, Israel - since the Occupation began in 1967, if not before - has
always striven for control of the entire country "from the [Jordan] river to
the [Mediterranean] sea," as we refer to it in Israel. This is the Land of
Israel, and in Zionist ideology, which drives all Israeli governments
including the present "unity" one, it belongs exclusively to us, the Jews.
We deny the very existence of a Palestinian people, certainly its claims
over "our" country.

In fact, we Israelis do not see ourselves in a "conflict," since a conflict
needs two sides and we deny that the Arabs (as we call the Palestinians)
constitute a "side." Instead, we are in a process of "redeeming" our ancient
homeland, to use the Biblical phrase. Arabs may stay, of course, if they
give up any national claims to what they call "Palestine" and acknowledge
that the entire Land of Israel is Jewish, but if not, they will be expelled
- or worse, as the attack on Gaza demonstrated. This is "The Message" Israel
tries constantly to communicate to the Arabs through its military actions.

And since they do not get The Message - or at least have not yet submitted -
we are justified in expelling them from our country. We began the process in
1947/48, when more than 700,000 Palestinians were driven from what became
Israel (some 70 per cent of the Palestinian population) and their homes
systematically demolished, and more than 60 years later that campaign of
ethnic cleansing continues. It is evidenced nowhere more graphically than in
Israel's policy of home demolitions.

One can only describe Israel's obsession with demolishing Palestinian homes
in light of the exclusive Jewish claim to the entire Land of Israel harking
back a century or more. It is not a policy specific to any particular time
or place, nor is it confined to the Occupied Territories. In 1948 and for
years after, Israeli governments systematically demolished more than 500
entire villages, towns, urban centres and neighbourhoods, both to prevent
the return of the Palestinian refugees and to take their lands and
properties.

Since the Occupation began in 1967, another 24,000 Palestinian homes have
been demolished, including 4,000 in the latest attack on Gaza. And in 2004,
the Israeli government announced the establishment of a Demolition
Administration within the Ministry of Interior; targeted for destruction are
20-40,000 homes of Israeli (Arab) citizens classified as "unrecognised
villages." (One Bedouin village in the Negev, al Twazil, has been demolished
18 times.)

It must be stressed that Israel has never explained or justified its
long-standing practice of demolishing Palestinian homes by security. For the
most part it has offered no explanations at all, treating the phenomenon as
a purely internal matter. Occasionally it justifies the wholesale
destruction of homes in military operations as "collateral damage."
According to Ha'aretz, "Israel Defense Forces investigations into last
month's offensive in the Gaza Strip indicate the army could face significant
difficulties justifying the scale of destruction of civilian homes during
the fighting. A military source involved in the investigation told Haaretz,
'It's clear to us that in a small portion of the combat sectors immeasurable
damage was caused, and that is very difficult to justify from a legal
perspective, particularly if such justifications are called for in legal
proceedings with international organi[s]ations.'"

As for the thousands of homes demolished due to a lack of building permits,
which Israel justifies on a legal basis, it neglects to say that its
explicit policy since 1967 has been to deny permits to Palestinians, or to
restrict them severely.

When one surveys the consequences of Israel's house demolition policy from
1948 until the present, the conclusion is inescapable: a systematic and
ongoing campaign is being waged to either rid the country of its Palestinian
population or, failing that, to confine the remaining Palestinians to tiny,
delimited, disconnected and impoverished enclaves, in Israel as well as in
the Occupied Territories.

House demolitions are illegal under international law, serve no obvious
purpose, have severe humanitarian effects and fuel bitterness and extremism.
Israel constantly complains about its security, but what of the security of
the Palestinians living under its control these past 42 years?

Until Israel stops such inhumane practices, until it recognises the
existence and rights of the Palestinian people and find a way to share their
common country, until it is held accountable for its actions by the
international community, there will be no peace in the Holy Land. And that,
given the instability and extremism the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
generates throughout the Muslim world, cannot be good news for Australians.

By all accounts the new Israeli government, while making the required nod
toward peace with the Palestinians so important to the American, European
and other world governments, Australia near the top, will continue the
policy of ethnic cleansing or, if expelling almost four million residents of
the Occupied Territories proves impossible, of locking them into small
enclaves, creating a Bantustan a la apartheid South Africa and calling it a
"Palestinian state."

Peace will come to Israel and Palestine when the Occupation truly ends and
Palestinians gain their fundamental human rights, collectively in a state of
their own as well as individually. Failing that, we must be prepared to
support the establishment of a single state of all the inhabitants of
Israel/Palestine. Ethnic cleansing, apartheid and occupation cannot be
allowed to prevail.


Web link
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/stories/s2533161.htlm

VIDEO LINK
The Israel Lobby
(Marije Merrman, VPRO Backlight 2007)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N294FMDok98&feature=related



For many years now the American foreign policy has been characterized by the strong tie between the United States and Israel. Does the United States in fact keep Israel on its feet? And how long will it continue to do so? In March 2006 the American political scientists John Mearsheimer (University of Chicago) and Steve Walt (Harvard) published the controversial article 'The Israel Lobby and US foreign policy'. In it they state that it is not, or no longer, expedient for the US to support and protect present-day Israel. The documentary sheds light on both parties involved in the discussion: those who wish to maintain the strong tie between the US and Israel, and those who were critical of it and not infrequently became 'victims' of the lobby. The question arises to what extend the pro-Israel lobby ultimately determines the military and political importance of Israel itself. Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson (Colin Powell's former chief-of-staff) explains how the lobby's influence affects the decision-making structure in the White House.
With political scientist John Mearsheimer, neocon Richard Perle, lobby organization AIPAC, televangelist John Hagee, historian Tony Judt, Human Rights Watch director Kenneth Roth, colonel Lawrence Wilkerson, Democrat Earl Hilliard, Israeli peace negotiator Daniel Levy and investigative journalist Michael Massing.

Share:

VIDEO: Zaynab's Story: A Call to Boycott Israel

You saw the bombs fall on Gaza in January and you shuddered at the terror
you knew would be felt by ordinary human beings unable to flee or defend
themselves. You saw the blackened bodies and the maimed images of children
and you knew it was wrong, despite all the justifications repeated like
mantras by Israeli spokespersons, and regrettably, our own Western leaders
and media. What you didn’t and don’t see are the daily humiliations,
discriminations and exploitations the Palestinians are forced to endure
under Israel’s apartheid rule in their own country. Far more insidious and
harmful than even the terrifyingly brutal military attacks, Israel’s
deliberate undermining of the Palestinian economy to the point of almost
wholesale dependence on aid and/or Israeli goods has damaged the very fabric
of Palestinian agrarian society. It has forced Palestinians, no longer
permitted to farm their own lands, to slave labour for Israel, while the
rest of the world, and of course Israel, benefit.

Watch this four-part video and weep at the terrible injustices being
suffered by the Palestinians. If you were reluctant to protest Israel’s
savage attacks because political spin gave the false picture of an equal
fight, the images of ordinary people desperately clinging to the shattered
remains of their farming lands and olive trees while Israel steals
everything they own, should make you think again. This video was made by
www.inminds.co.uk to educate Muslims, but it is educational for everyone.
In fact, you will discover just how normal Israel’s operations appear when in
fact their practices are no different to the worst of apartheid South
Africa. It took a long time to get the world to begin boycotts against the
apartheid regime then; it would be a tragedy if it took a long time again.
For the sake of humanity, let us begin to do what we can to make a
difference.

We ask that you avoid buying any products with bar codes beginning 7 29.

More information about what you can do to boycott will be available soon.
In the meantime, you can look at the website http://wwwbigcampaign.org to
familiarise yourself with some of the boycott, divestment and sanctions
campaigns that are being implemented around the world. - SK


Zaynab's Story: A Call To Boycott Israel


What is the connection between an ordinary person living in Britain and what
is happening in Palestine? How do our actions as consumers in this country
affect what happens to the Palestinians?

Part 1 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YN-YGoZK0i4&feature=email

Part 2 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dahkok0VuBs&feature=related

Part 3 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8GMHUIm5F8&feature=related

Part 4 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axmryqVamMM&feature=related


IMPORTANT: Mentioned in the video is INTERPAL, an accepted UK charity
organisation, but under Australia’s anti-terror laws, Interpal is
proscribed.
Share:

Gaza - Please sign petitions


The situation in Gaza is getting worse, if that is even possible, and it is
time to rally even more strongly than before. Below is yet another article
by Jeremy Salt that is truly a harrowing message. Also included is an
American CBS network video clip showing a Norwegian doctor at Shifa
Hospital in Gaza explain in chilling detail the effects of Israel’s latest
bombs which not only tear apart the bodies of people, but those who
survive, are likely to develop cancer from the fallout.

If any of you doubt the viciousness of Israel’s attacks, the doctor’s description will certainly
make you think again. In just one day, Shifa Hospital in Gaza received 150
wounded and 50 Palestinians killed and almost all of the injuries and deaths
were caused by these bombs. Half the Palestinian population in Gaza is
under 15 years of age which should really put into perspective the
motivation for Israel’s attacks. As one Australian put it - “genocidal
violence”.

If you want to do something to show your disgust, then perhaps you can
emulate the brave initiative of one of our Australian supporters who has
raised the Palestinian flag on the roof of his house in East Brunswick. He
expected a lot of abuse and even damage – instead he has got resounding
support from neighbours, passersby and motorists. He believes that Gaza is
like Sharpeville in 1923, the turning point in the anti-Apartheid movement
in South Africa when the police began firing without provocation at unarmed
demonstrators protesting the restriction of movement by pass laws and killed
69 people, some in the back as they tried to flee while wounding some 150
others. People in the West saw what they had been ignoring for years.
According to him, when the West really begins to realise the brutality of
the whole Zionist enterprise in Palestine, Zionism’s days will be numbered.
Our totally cowed politicians will suddenly have to do an about-turn when
the people on the street no longer accept the lies and their declarations of
fealtyto Israel.

Another thing you can do is sign the following petitions:

Free Gaza Now - 1.5 million signatures for 1.5 million humans in Gaza
http://www.PetitionOnline.com/1500000/

AVAAZ.org Gaza: Stop the Bloodshed
http://www.avaaz.org/en/gaza_time_for_peace/?cl=164104908&v=2624

Scientists for Gaza
http://www.petitiononline.com/I75SD92/petition.html

British Committee for Universities for Palestine Gaza Emergency
http://www.bricup.org.uk/

IACenter.org Stop the attack on Gaza
http://www.iacenter.org/gazapetition/

Palestinian petition to PLO Chairman Mahmoud Abbas
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/Palestinianpetition/signatures.html

End the Occupation Sign open letter to President-elect Obama
http://www.endtheoccupation.org/form.php?modin=137

Faculty for Israeli-Palestinian Peace Petition on the bombing of the
Islamic University in Gaza
http://www.ffipp.org/campus_area

ADALAH Petition to End the Siege on Gaza
http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/end-the-siege-on-gaza.html

Suspend EU-Israel Association Agreement
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/Suspend-EU-Israel-Trade-Agreement


You can also keep writing as many letters as possible to the media, our
politicians, members of the Israeli Knesset (addresses sent in an earlier
email) protesting these murderous attacks on 1.5 million imprisoned people.
And you can join vigils, rallies and pickets in your areas and bring your
family and friends. IN MELBOURNE, THE NEXT RALLY WILL BE ON SUNDAY 18
JANUARY at 2.00pm AT THE STATE LIBRARY OF VICTORIA. The last one saw some
6,000 people attend (double the number of the first rally). See if you can
help make that number even greater.

Please do not stop speaking out at every opportunity. Gaza needs your help
urgently.

For more articles by Jeremy Salt and a new article by former Israeli Staff Sergeant
and now psychotherapist Avigail Abarbanel, please visit our website
http://www.australiansforpalestine.com

- Sonja Karkar, Australians for Palestine, Women for Palestine
Share:

PLEASE WRITE TO MEDIA RE GAZA



If anyone wants the facts on what is happening in Gaza, then one simply
cannot go past Dr Sara Roy’s devastating account of how Israel’s brutal
siege affects every single aspect of Palestinian life. With Christmas
almost upon us, thoughts will most likely be more on food and gift shopping
than on keeping up with the developments in Gaza, but in a quiet moment,
please take advantage and read this compelling case for why we have a duty
as human beings to speak up unequivocally for the Palestinians. - SK



If Gaza falls . . .

by Sara Roy

London Review of Books
1 January 2009



_________________________________________________________

Israel's siege of Gaza began on 5 November, the day after an Israeli attack
inside the strip, no doubt designed finally to undermine the truce between
Israel and Hamas established last June. Although both sides had violated the
agreement before, this incursion was on a different scale. Hamas responded
by firing rockets into Israel and the violence has not abated since then.
Israel's siege has two fundamental goals. One is to ensure that the
Palestinians there are seen merely as a humanitarian problem, beggars who
have no political identity and therefore can have no political claims. The
second is to foist Gaza onto Egypt. That is why the Israelis tolerate the
hundreds of tunnels between Gaza and Egypt around which an informal but
increasingly regulated commercial sector has begun to form. The overwhelming
majority of Gazans are impoverished and officially 49.1 per cent are
unemployed. In fact the prospect of steady employment is rapidly
disappearing for the majority of the population.

On 5 November the Israeli government sealed all the ways into and out of
Gaza. Food, medicine, fuel, parts for water and sanitation systems,
fertiliser, plastic sheeting, phones, paper, glue, shoes and even teacups
are no longer getting through in sufficient quantities or at all. According
to Oxfam only 137 trucks of food were allowed into Gaza in November. This
means that an average of 4.6 trucks per day entered the strip compared to an
average of 123 in October this year and 564 in December 2005. The two main
food providers in Gaza are the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine
Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) and the World Food Programme (WFP). UNRWA
alone feeds approximately 750,000 people in Gaza, and requires 15 trucks of
food daily to do so. Between 5 November and 30 November, only 23 trucks
arrived, around 6 per cent of the total needed; during the week of 30
November it received 12 trucks, or 11 per cent of what was required. There
were three days in November when UNRWA ran out of food, with the result that
on each of these days 20,000 people were unable to receive their scheduled
supply. According to John Ging, the director of UNRWA in Gaza, most of the
people who get food aid are entirely dependent on it. On 18 December UNRWA
suspended all food distribution for both emergency and regular programmes
because of the blockade.

The WFP has had similar problems, sending only 35 trucks out of the 190 it
had scheduled to cover Gazans' needs until the start of February (six more
were allowed in between 30 November and 6 December). Not only that: the WFP
has to pay to store food that isn't being sent to Gaza. This cost $215,000
in November alone. If the siege continues, the WFP will have to pay an extra
$150,000 for storage in December, money that will be used not to support
Palestinians but to benefit Israeli business.

The majority of commercial bakeries in Gaza – 30 out of 47 – have had to
close because they have run out of cooking gas. People are using any fuel
they can find to cook with. As the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation
(FAO) has made clear, cooking-gas canisters are necessary for generating the
warmth to incubate broiler chicks. Shortages of gas and animal feed have
forced commercial producers to smother hundreds of thousands of chicks. By
April, according to the FAO, there will be no poultry there at all: 70 per
cent of Gazans rely on chicken as a major source of protein.

Banks, suffering from Israeli restrictions on the transfer of banknotes into
the territory were forced to close on 4 December. A sign on the door of one
read: 'Due to the decision of the Palestinian Finance Authority, the bank
will be closed today Thursday, 4.12.2008, because of the unavailability of
cash money, and the bank will be reopened once the cash money is available.'

The World Bank has warned that Gaza's banking system could collapse if these
restrictions continue. All cash for work programmes has been stopped and on
19 November UNRWA suspended its cash assistance programme to the most needy.
It also ceased production of textbooks because there is no paper, ink or
glue in Gaza. This will affect 200,000 students returning to school in the
new year. On 11 December, the Israeli defence minister, Ehud Barak, sent $25
million following an appeal from the Palestinian prime minister, Salaam
Fayad, the first infusion of its kind since October. It won't even cover a
month's salary for Gaza's 77,000 civil servants.

On 13 November production at Gaza's only power station was suspended and the
turbines shut down because it had run out of industrial diesel. This in turn
caused the two turbine batteries to run down, and they failed to start up
again when fuel was received some ten days later. About a hundred spare
parts ordered for the turbines have been sitting in the port of Ashdod in
Israel for the last eight months, waiting for the Israeli authorities to let
them through customs. Now Israel has started to auction these parts because
they have been in customs for more than 45 days. The proceeds are being held
in Israeli accounts.

During the week of 30 November, 394,000 litres of industrial diesel were
allowed in for the power plant: approximately 18 per cent of the weekly
minimum that Israel is legally obliged to allow in. It was enough for one
turbine to run for two days before the plant was shut down again. The Gaza
Electricity Distribution Company said that most of the Gaza Strip will be
without electricity for between four and 12 hours a day. At any given time
during these outages, over 65,000 people have no electricity.

No other diesel fuel (for standby generators and transport) was delivered
during that week, no petrol (which has been kept out since early November)
or cooking gas. Gaza's hospitals are apparently relying on diesel and gas
smuggled from Egypt via the tunnels; these supplies are said to be
administered and taxed by Hamas. Even so, two of Gaza's hospitals have been
out of cooking gas since the week of 23 November.

Adding to the problems caused by the siege are those created by the
political divisions between the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and
the Hamas Authority in Gaza. For example, Gaza's Coastal Municipalities
Water Utility (CMWU), which is not controlled by Hamas, is supposed to
receive funds from the World Bank via the Palestinian Water Authority (PWA)
in Ramallah to pay for fuel to run the pumps for Gaza's sewage system. Since
June, the PWA has refused to hand over those funds, perhaps because it feels
that a functioning sewage system would benefit Hamas. I don't know whether
the World Bank has attempted to intervene, but meanwhile UNRWA is providing
the fuel, although they have no budget for it. The CMWU has also asked
Israel's permission to import 200 tons of chlorine, but by the end of
November it had received only 18 tons – enough for one week of chlorinated
water. By mid-December Gaza City and the north of Gaza had access to water
only six hours every three days.

According to the World Health Organisation, the political divisions between
Gaza and the West Bank are also having a serious impact on drug stocks in
Gaza. The West Bank Ministry of Health (MOH) is responsible for procuring
and delivering most of the pharmaceuticals and medical disposables used in
Gaza. But stocks are at dangerously low levels. Throughout November the MOH
West Bank was turning shipments away because it had no warehouse space, yet
it wasn't sending supplies on to Gaza in adequate quantities. During the
week of 30 November, one truck carrying drugs and medical supplies from the
MOH in Ramallah entered Gaza, the first delivery since early September.

The breakdown of an entire society is happening in front of us, but there is
little international response beyond UN warnings which are ignored. The
European Union announced recently that it wanted to strengthen its
relationship with Israel while the Israeli leadership openly calls for a
large-scale invasion of the Gaza Strip and continues its economic
stranglehold over the territory with, it appears, the not-so-tacit support
of the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah – which has been co-operating with
Israel on a number of measures. On 19 December Hamas officially ended its
truce with Israel, which Israel said it wanted to renew, because of Israel's
failure to ease the blockade.

How can keeping food and medicine from the people of Gaza protect the people
of Israel? How can the impoverishment and suffering of Gaza's children –
more than 50 per cent of the population – benefit anyone? International law
as well as human decency demands their protection. If Gaza falls, the West
Bank will be next.

Sara Roy teaches at Harvard's Center for Middle Eastern Studies and is the
author of Failing Peace: Gaza and the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict.

Website link:
http://www.lrb.co.uk/v31/n01/print/roy_01_.html

Share:

Gaza and the World - So this is Christmas?

Please pass this video on to your friends so that we can get it viewed by
people all over the world as quickly as possible. The message is
particularly powerful now as Christmas is almost upon us and the people in
Gaza are having to endure impossible deprivations. Their situation has
still not impacted on Westerners mainly for a lack of headlines and powerful
images in the mainstream media. The responsibility, therefore, falls on all
of us to act. This video is just one of many initiatives being undertaken –
the people of Gaza desperately need your support. - SK

WATCH THE VIDEO AND THEN EMAIL THE LINK TO YOUR FRIENDS.

Share:

Disaster of Israel's Making


By Sonja Karkar - Melbourne

The illegal settlement movement, supported by every Israeli administration to date, has burgeoned out of control and its right wing leaders are vehemently opposed to negotiating land for peace.We will probably see the present Foreign Minister and Kadima party leader, Tzipi Livni - if she forms the next government and takes over from Ehud Olmert, now interim PM - use the same stalling tactics with the Palestinian Authority that have, up until now, allowed land grabs from the Palestinians for the Zionist dream of a greater Israel. After all, Livni was nurtured on that dream.

Her main rival, Likud leader Benjamin Netanyahu, has vowed to allow expansion of the settlements if he wins expected early elections. A 15-year-old peace process is ominously poised for failure, not just politically but economically.

The 1993 Oslo Peace Accords were supposed to offer the Palestinians the political freedom and economic independence to which they have always been entitled. Since then, Palestinian society has been taken on a rollercoaster ride of promises, lies, provocations and chaos with not a single benefit to show for its painful concessions.

So much has been made of Oslo's promise of new beginnings, when in fact the real historic moment of peace occurred when Palestinian chairman Yasser Arafat agreed to a two-state solution at the UN General Assembly in 1988, accepting on behalf of his people, Israel's “right to exist” on 78 per cent of the land stolen from them.

That was the hard-won chance for resolving the conflict that Israel should have grasped with both hands.

However, Israel was never going to let go of its dreams of taking all of the land and the Oslo Accords, and every renewed peace process since then, have simply paid lip-service to Palestinian aspirations, while Israel has pursued its own objectives in defiance of international law.

Powerful Israeli interests, and not Arafat's intransigence or Palestinian terrorism, have caused Oslo's failures. From the beginning, Israel and the World Bank violated the economic clauses of the Accords, which were supposedly designed to improve and stimulate recovery from the disastrous circumstances that had already been visited on the Palestinians by Israel's military assaults and occupation in the previous decades.

As Harvard University political economist Sara Roy points out, “Decades of expropriation and deinstitutionalisation had long ago robbed Palestine of its potential for development, ensuring that no viable economic (and hence political structure) could emerge”. A viable Palestinian economy is essential for the functioning of an independent Palestinian state.

No sooner had control of Oslo's economic development programs shifted to the World Bank, than the basic infrastructure that was supposed to have been built was reported as “repairs” to infrastructure when none in fact existed, and the building of a casino in Jericho took precedence over essential ports, roads and canals. As Arutz Sheva Israel News reported recently, “the casino was one of the most corruption-laden aspects of the Oslo Accords”.

Those who were allegedly involved reads like a who's who of the Israeli political establishment: Olmert; former prime ministers Netanyahu and Ariel Sharon; minister Avigdor Lieberman; and Sharon's adviser Dov Weissglas in concert with Austrian-Jewish businessman Martin Schlaff, who is now being investigated for allegedly giving millions of dollars in bribes to Lieberman and Sharon. Netanyahu could emerge as prime minister again if early elections are held.

The “Gaza and Jericho First” stage of the Oslo Accords, provided the perfect opportunity for gambling tycoons to bypass Israel, where gambling is illegal. The casino took in about $1 million a day from Israelis streaming into occupied Jericho for the pleasure of gambling while the Palestinians were barely able to put food on the table.

When the Gaza airport and seaport were finally built due to European Union efforts, along with roads, waterways and the Palestinian broadcasting station, Israel destroyed each of them, citing security reasons. Conservatively, Israel's destruction of infrastructure has been estimated at $3.5 billion in damages, while lost potential income for the Palestinian economy has been estimated at about $6.4 billion; the total loss far exceeding the overall international assistance received by the Palestinian people from 1994 to 1999.

The pauperisation of the Palestinian economy was further exacerbated by the punitive closure of Palestinian society. A complicated system of checkpoints and roadblocks severely restricted the movement of Palestinians and goods, and prevented Palestinians from travelling to Israel for work. Unemployment hit record highs, going from less than 7 per cent before 1993 to 25 per cent in the West Bank and 39 per cent in Gaza in the first quarter of 1996. Israel had created a Palestinian economy deeply dependent on its own during the previous 30 years, which meant that closure was now far more devastating than it would have been otherwise.

As the living standards plummeted and destitution pervaded, every level of Palestinian society reacted angrily. But Palestinian violence was not wholesale. Subjected to a barrage of provocations, minority groups and traumatised individuals committed most of the violence with homemade weapons. One of those early provocations was a terrorist attack which killed 50 praying Palestinians in a Hebron mosque commited by right wing extremist Baruch Goldstein, who is today venerated by the Kach settler movement to which he belonged.

Nevertheless, Israel launched reprisals each time against the entire Palestinian population - almost half under the age of 15 - using the powerful force of its military arsenal in defiance of international law, which prohibits collective punishment.

International public opinion has not been swayed then, or now, by the non-violent efforts of Palestinian resistance carried out weekly by community groups in towns and villages all over the West Bank. Instead, it remains fixated on Palestinian armed attacks and suicide bombings without any regard for the disintegration of Palestinian society under Israel's humiliating control and human rights abuses.

By 2000, the Palestinians were highly charged, especially after Arafat was derided for refusing to negotiate “peace” when he walked away from then prime minister Ehud Barak's much lauded “generous” offer at Camp David. Concessions on Jerusalem and the Palestinian right of return were not his to make and Barak knew it. To bolster his own political ambitions, Barak, now Defence Minister, was able to persuade the public that Arafat had pre-planned an Intifada (uprising) while negotiating peace, and had sought to destroy Israel through the return of millions of refugees.

Israeli researchers though have shown that the heads of Israel's Military Intelligence and the Shin Bet security service dismissed the existence of any such plan.

At the same time, Israel increased its settlement expansion in the Occupied Palestinian territories, in spite of the Oslo Accords prohibiting “any change in the status of the West Bank ...”. Throughout the past 15 years, successive Israeli governments have all continued to build these illegal housing estates for waves of Jewish settlers from abroad, while the Palestinians are being pushed into arid areas creating a series of disconnected Bantustans much like what was created in apartheid South Africa.

Despite Israeli-only roads, concrete walls, electric fencing and military zones separating the two peoples, Israel promotes these modern housing estates as “normal” developments. In effect, it has forced the Palestinians into a system of complete dependency where Israel controls all borders, Gaza's territorial waters, and 80 per cent of all the water resources.

Prevented from producing and competing with Israel's economy, the Palestinians became forced consumers, a situation perpetuated by foreign aid. Effectively, international donors foot the bill while Israeli companies reap the profits out of the desperate need of an entire population under Israel's occupation. Foreign aid has done nothing to revitalise the economy, and has only made the Palestinians one of the most aid-dependent populations in the world. According to the latest World Bank report, “aid and reform are unlikely to revive the Palestinian economy unless Israel removes economic restrictions at the same time”.

Even so, with a staggering 97 per cent of Gaza's industry now inactive due to Israel's punitive sanctions, removing those restrictions will not bring about economic recovery any time soon, if at all. The magnitude of social destruction is incomprehensible as 1.4 million people grapple with failing sewers, sewage-polluted water, rationed food, practically no electricity or fuel, and a crumbling infrastructure of roads, schools, hospitals, transport system and other normal municipal services. This systematic “de-development” is spiralling into an unprecedented humanitarian crisis likely to have grave political consequences.

Today, Israel will cite the demographic problem it faces with a Palestinian population fast catching up in size to the Israeli population. It is a problem of Israel's making, and one that it could solve tomorrow if it was not moving systematically and determinedly to expand its territory and fulfil its colonial ambitions for a Greater Israel.

It will not be long before the 4 million Palestinians being herded into reservations will be as much a problem for Israel to police as it will be for the Palestinians to endure.
Share:

A TRIBUTE TO YASIR ARAFAT


“Don’t forget Palestine”


by Sonja Karkar






For fifty years, Yasser Arafat - or Abu Ammar as he was more familiarly known
- made the Palestinian cause his life’s journey, and along the way, be
became the undisputed leader of the Palestinian people. His passion spilled
over into three words “Don’t forget Palestine” - words he wrote to Egypt’s
first President in 1953 when he was still a student, and words which
remained his mantra to the end. He lived and breathed Palestine, but
sadly, he did not survive to see an independent Palestinian state.

While the dream eluded him, Arafat was still looked upon as “father of the
nation”, a man who had almost single-handedly put Palestine back on the
world stage when the very name Palestine had been practically obliterated
from the history books and maps, and its people had been deemed
non-existent. Naturally, as one would expect after fifty years of
controversial public life, there are those who love him and those who hate
him, the praise and the slander each creating their own version of the man.
Some criticisms are valid: most have been manufactured. Yet, Arafat managed
to keep his head above the madding crowd, determined always to bring his
people home from the wilderness.

Like all liberation leaders, Yasser Arafat had to struggle against the tide
of influential powers, and even world opinion, but none were ever in
Arafat’s precarious position – pitted against a powerful enemy, surrounded
by ambitious Arab leaders from neighbouring countries, thwarted by an
interfering Western world, unable to operate from within his own country,
without a well-equipped army, his people dispersed throughout the world, and
internationally unrecognised. Against such overwhelming odds, Arafat
continually had to navigate the shifting sands of intrigue and sabotage, and
he made mistakes. But, as the late eminent Palestinian doctor, Haidar
abd-al-Shafi pointed out “Whenever the need arose to make a courageous
decision, all the others disappeared and Arafat was left alone. He was the
only one who had the courage to decide.”


Tripoli, 1973

He was beloved. Arafat always sat amongst his people, never in palaces.
Friends and visitors found his warmth engaging and his interest genuine.
Stories abound of how Arafat would offer a morsel of chicken or some other
delicacy from his own plate to tempt a guest – it was his form of breaking
bread. Even in his last years, he chose to remain in the besieged and
rotting Ramallah compound with his people rather than abandon them or his
country for a more comfortable life in exile. For all that, Arafat was a
lonely man. He had sacrificed what other men wouldn’t and couldn’t for
Palestine.


Ramallah, 2004

When Arafat was born sometime in August, 1929, his destiny was fated to be
burdensome. His birth name alone carried the weight of family pedigree –
Mohammed Abdel-Raouf Arafat Al-Qudwa al-Husseini. His birthplace, often
disputed – Cairo or Jerusalem – saw him move from one city to the other so
much so that either could just as well have been his home. Perhaps some
foresaw his future and determined to call him Yasser meaning easy, but there
was nothing easy in the path he chose whilst studying engineering at Cairo
University. It was there that he became actively involved with the politics
of Palestine, and by 1958, he and some friends had founded Al-Fatah, an
underground network of secret cells, which then produced a magazine
advocating armed resistance against Israel.

Al-Fatah was not recognised by the Arab states because Syria, Jordan and
Egypt had formed their own group called the Palestine Liberation
Organisation (PLO) in a bid to control a political imbroglio fomenting
within their midst. However, the humiliating defeat of the Arab States in
the 1967 war - having lost the Gaza Strip, the Golan Heights and the West
Bank – saw Arafat’s Fatah movement rise to prominence due to Arafat’s
guerrilla tactics which had achieved a considerable measure of success
against Israel. This was a turning point for Arafat. He realised that if
the Palestinians were ever to succeed, they could only rely on themselves,
and in 1968, thousands of Palestinians had joined the ranks of Fatah,
hailing Arafat as their hero and their leader.

It was natural that Arafat should take on the mantle of Chairman of the PLO
after the Arab losses, although his guerrilla attacks against Israel worried
the leaders of some Arab countries because they preferred a more
conciliatory approach, which would primarily benefit them. Not long after,
Jordan expelled him and his followers, accusing him of setting up “a state
within a state”. For the next 25 years, he operated from inside Lebanon and
then Tunis before finally setting foot in Palestine. This added to the many
difficulties Arafat faced in holding the liberation movement together. The
fact that he managed this for the years he spent outside Palestine, speaks
volumes about his command and influence, and more importantly, his
sensitivity to the nuances of all the different factions, passions,
opinions, and pressures that surrounded him.

However, Arafat never saw armed struggle as the only solution, and indeed
when he realised that Israel could not be vanquished by force after the 1973
defeat of Egypt and Syria, he began negotiating with Israel. One of his
greatest victories came on 13th November, 1974, when Arafat was invited to
address the UN General Assembly for the first time as leader of a legitimate
people – the Palestinians. In a dramatic speech, he called on the
international community to decide between an olive branch and a freedom
fighter’s gun.


speaking at the UN, 1974

For the next 14 years, Arafat worked with incredible patience, always
sensitive to the passions arising from his people’s overwhelming pain. It
was a slow process of dialogue and a gradual introduction of his ideas. But,
in all that time, he never neglected to support the men who were still
fighting in Lebanon. Both in 1982 and 1983, he stood with them against the
Israeli General Sharon who had invaded Lebanon to drive out the Palestinians
and to kill him. Both times, Arafat left to fight another day, refusing to
surrender. Those who fought with him will never forget his courage and
that he, like them, was ready to die for the cause.

As the 1987 intifada broke out, Arafat again began negotiations with Israel.
It was the following year that Arafat addressed the UN General Assembly in a
remarkable speech, which not only defended the Palestinian position, but
also accepted the need for compromise in the interests of peace. By agreeing
to an international conference for peace based on UN Resolutions 242 and
338, Arafat de facto recognised Israel and the right of the two states to
exist side by side. Until then, compromise had not been regarded as an
option by a people cruelly dispossessed and still victims of Israel’s brutal
occupation and oppression. That Arafat was able to bring about a paradigm
shift in their thinking, whereby they accepted their enemy’s right to exist
on 78% of the land stolen from them is extraordinary, and underlines
Arafat’s credibility with his people. No one else could have turned the
Palestinians around.

From then on, Arafat was involved in numerous peace negotiations with
Israel, and the US as broker. However, his decision to back Saddam Hussein
in the Gulf War of 1991 threw the Palestinians back into the abyss. He paid
a huge price for his loyalty to the one Arab leader who had supported the
Palestinians. His decision rendered Arafat irrelevant as a negotiating
partner, and from this position Arafat had the painful task of clambering
out of the abyss to re-establish his and the PLO’s credibility and bring
Palestine back into international focus.

In the meantime, bilateral talks held between Washington, Israel and a
non-PLO delegation, had stalled, and the PLO entered into secret
negotiations with Israel in Oslo. Arafat knew that concessions had to be
made and so he made concessions – too many for some and fatal ones for
others. Effectively, the arrangements gave Arafat limited self-rule in the
West Bank and the Gaza Strip in exchange for Palestinian recognition of
Israel. Arafat was expected to establish a police force to control internal
security and leave external security to the Israelis. Other issues were to
be negotiated at various stages over five years, the most difficult ones
being left to “final status” talks. These arrangements meant that Arafat had
finally abandoned his long held dream of a single secular democratic state
in favour of the two state solution. In reaching such a compromise, Arafat
had taken a political gamble knowing that some would see it as a sell-out in
order to bring the PLO back from the cold. Others were convinced that this
shift was well worth the sacrifices the Palestinians would have to make
individually and collectively. The negotiations culminated in the signing of
the “Declaration of Principles” in 1993. With US President Bill Clinton
watching, Arafat shook hands with Israel’s Prime Minister Rabin and thereby
sealed an interim agreement between the PLO and Israel of joint recognition.


Shaking hands with Israel Prime Minister Rabin, watched by US President Clinton, 1993

For Palestinians around the world, it was a momentous occasion. Many saw it
as the beginning of a new, although severely protracted, Palestine. Others
were outraged. They felt Arafat had offered too much and consigned the
Palestinians to Bantustans, effectively making a two state solution
impossible. Nevertheless, in January 1996 Arafat was elected the first
president of the Palestinian National Authority (PNA) overseeing the 88-seat
Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC) governing the West Bank and Gaza
Strip. It was a short-lived victory. Rabin was assassinated by an Israeli
extremist and Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu, determined to undermine the
Oslo process, refused to implement the first stages of the agreement.

The world had expected Arafat to become a statesman after the Oslo Accords,
but Israel did not allow him the dignity of presiding over a state. Arafat
had been simply relegated to the task of keeping the Palestinian population
under control while Israel kept a vice-like grip on the provisional state’s
borders, airspace and water, inevitably affecting its economic viability.
Clearly, Israel had never intended to hand over territorial sovereignty.

It was another devastating blow to Arafat’s credibility. The Oslo Accords
had not ended the occupation. Instead, the Palestinians found themselves
facing an apartheid situation worse than anything endured by South Africa.
The blanket closure of Palestinian civilian life, random attacks and
relentless home demolitions rendering thousands homeless, while Israel
continued to build settlements, soon caused some Palestinians to wonder what
Arafat had actually achieved for them. Arafat, under an obligation to
provide peace and security, saw his police force being decimated by Israeli
targeted attacks and was then in the humiliating position of being unable to
keep a lid on the explosive situation that was building daily.


Elusive peace

By July 2000, Arafat was being pressured to take part in “final status”
talks hosted by US President Clinton at Camp David. These talks were
supposed to be the culmination of the phased Oslo peace process and were
meant to resolve the most difficult issues of Jerusalem and the Palestinian
refugees. Arafat had to walk away: he simply could not agree to Israel’s
conditions. There was no choice. He either had to accept the Bantustans
already proven so disastrous in Apartheid South Africa, back down on the
inalienable right of return for the Palestinian refugees, and make
impossible concessions on East Jerusalem, or accept the ugly consequences of
refusing to negotiate “peace”. Prime Minister Barak’s “generous” offer was
totally without substance: a threat rather than a proposal.

Arafat, of course, was the bĂȘte noire of the talks. We are never told that
during those negotiations, Israel offered no detailed solution and nothing was in
writing. Neither are we told that contrary to what had been agreed at Oslo,
Barak continued to build settlements in the Occupied Territories. And,
whatever support Arafat might have been able to garner from his people on
some of the issues being negotiated, concessions on East Jerusalem as the
capital of the Palestinian State, and the right of return for all Palestinian refugees,
were simply non-negotiable. The irony of it all is that Israel was held up as offering
something when in fact it was offering nothing, and Arafat emerged as the
man who rejected peace. The Palestinian people despaired.


Failed talks, 2000

Arafat and Barak returned home to an enemy waiting in the wings. Sharon,
Arafat’s arch-enemy was about to make his entry on to the world stage. His
provocative visit to the compound in Jerusalem called Haram al-Sharif by
Muslims and Temple Mount by Jews with 1000 Israeli security forces was
deliberately engineered to display Jewish sovereignty over the area, and
when angry unarmed Palestinians began throwing stones at the police in riot
gear, Sharon’s security forces retaliated with gunfire. People were killed
and many were injured. The ugly clashes which ensued are often cited as the
beginning of the Al Aqsa intifada and were clearly set off by Sharon’s
provocative act and not Arafat’s so-called rejection of peace.

No one was surprised that the peace process was effectively frozen when
Barak lost the elections to Sharon. The war that had been unleashed on the
Palestinians even before Camp David, now escalated ferociously. No matter
how much Arafat condemned suicide bombings, Israel made sure that he was
seen as tolerating, even encouraging the suicide bombers which gave Sharon
the necessary excuse to reject Arafat as a viable partner in any peace
negotiations. This then led to a bizarre turn of events, whereby President
Bush declared Sharon “a man of peace” even as Sharon was bulldozing his way
through the territories and announcing that Arafat was a target for
assassination. Arafat, the man who had shared the Nobel peace prize with
Rabin and Peres was now branded a terrorist and unfit to negotiate peace.


More talks

The world watched incredulously as Sharon declared an all-out war on
Palestinians – on Ramallah, Jenin, Bethlehem, Nablus, Tulkarem, Qalqilya,
and particularly, Arafat. More than 100 tanks rolled into Ramallah in April
2002 and began smashing Arafat’s headquarters leaving him besieged in a few
rooms without electricity or water. For the next two and a half years,
Arafat was a prisoner within his own walls and within his own land, while
Sharon continued to blitz Palestinian cities and assassinate Palestinian
leaders. The Palestinian Authority was all but dead and the Oslo Accords had
foundered. Expecting Arafat to rein in the terrorists was a futile demand
under the circumstances, but Arafat continued to issue one statement after
another in Arabic calling for an end to violence and an end to suicide
attacks. All to no avail. The people had suffered too much and without an
effective police force, Arafat had no way of bringing law and order to civic
life.


Israel’s prisoner in Ramallah, 2002

This time, however, Arafat refused to go into exile, preferring to stay with
his people. If anyone knew Sharon, it was Arafat. He knew that Sharon
wanted all of Palestine and would dismantle everything that had been gained
through the Oslo Accords. Some were prepared to give Sharon the war he
wanted. Arafat was not. He, therefore, had to find a way of becoming
“relevant” again and in March 2003, Arafat agreed to political reforms and
to share power with Mahmoud Abbas as prime minister. It opened the way for a
“road map” for peace drawn up by the Quartet – the US, UN, EU, and Russia.
But as before, neither Abbas nor Arafat were able to control the Palestinian
militants, much less put an end to suicide bombings: the roadmap was leading
nowhere.


“Bring back the Road Map”

With Arafat imprisoned in the Muqa’ata, the road map deadlocked, and Sharon went
on a rampage and the Palestinian situation escalated further. Arafat needed a
miracle. He had fought countless adversities with enormous courage and
determination, and had always emerged relatively unscathed. But, not this
time. A mystery illness short-changed his life’s work. Perhaps the saddest
moment in his long masterful career for those who watched was to see a frail
old man waving feebly to his people, before being airlifted out of
Palestine. It was too much of a miracle to hope that he would come back to
lead his people again.


leaving Palestine for the last time, November 2004

The wolves were baying a long before and the wolves closed in.
Much will be written and analysed about Arafat and his deeds, but for the
Palestinian people, Arafat will always remain a hero. Certainly, he made
mistakes: he would not have been human otherwise. But he never deserved the
vitriol and bile that have been heaped on him so cavalierly by his enemies
and even Palestinians who comfortably criticise from afar.

He deserved more. This small man who was able to command the world stage for
his beleaguered people, who could excite passions in men who served with him
in the grimmest of battles, and who could to the last, hold together the
Palestinian factions, rivalries and differences inherent in any society,
deserved to see the peace he sought and negotiated. He didn’t. However, he
did see out the terms of nine US presidents and eleven Israeli prime
ministers and came closer to peace and the Palestinian dream than anyone had
ever thought possible. He had tried everything and to the end kept the
olive branch firmly in his grasp. Tragically, for all of us, it fell from
his dying hand and the world lost the real peacemaker in the Middle East.

There will be others who will carry the cause aloft for Palestine, but none
who will ever symbolise the Palestinian struggle with all its pain, its
momentary glory, its dashed hopes, and its eternal resilience, as potently
or enduringly as Arafat. Four years since his untimely death, the
Palestinians are no closer to the vision that Arafat held in 1988 in the
hall of the UN General Assembly in Geneva. But he always had faith - the
stuff of legends, unshakeable and uncompromised. The Palestinians need that
faith more than ever today. This may well be the time to remember Arafat’s
words:

“ Don’t forget Palestine.”




In memoriam, 11 November 2004
Share: