Showing posts with label Muntadhar al-Zaidi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Muntadhar al-Zaidi. Show all posts

Iraq shoe thrower Has his jail term cut


The Iraqi journalist who hurled his shoes at former US President George W Bush has had his sentence cut from three years to one year on appeal.

Muntadar al-Zaidi's lawyer argued that the sentence should be changed from assault to insulting a foreign leader.

The judge agreed and reduced the term in line with the less serious offence.

An official for the court said the presiding judge had also taken into account the fact that Zaidi had no prior criminal history.

Shoe hurling is a grave insult in Arab culture, but Mr Bush - who was on a farewell trip to Iraq at the time - shrugged off the attack.



Footage of the shoe hurling incident



It happened in mid-December 2008 during a news conference Mr Bush was holding with Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.

Zaidi, of al-Baghdadiya TV, called Mr Bush "a dog" and threw his shoes as a "farewell kiss" from Iraqis who had been killed, orphaned or widowed since the US-led invasion.

He was overpowered and arrested and his actions were condemned by the Iraqi government as "shameful".

But the shoe attack, at a globally televised news conference, was celebrated across the world by critics of the outgoing US president, who ordered the 2003 invasion of the Iraq.

An opinion poll carried out for the BBC and ABC - the full results of which appear next Monday - suggested 62% of the Iraqis polled considered Zaidi a "hero".

Twenty-four percent of the sample said they viewed him as "criminal", while 10% thought he was a hero and criminal equally.

Share:

Further Updates on the Case of Muntather Al-Zaidi

On December 14th, Iraqi journalist Muntather Al-Zaidi threw his shoes at American president George W. Bush, and with them a huge insult in Iraqi tradition. On the ninth day since Muntather's arrest, we'd like to provide you with some updates on the case and the reactions it has spurred around the globe.

Friday there was a soccer game between two famous Iraqi teams. Tens of thousands of Iraqi citizens who attended the match chanted Muntather's name, calling him a hero. They shouted that, Sunni and Shi'i, they wanted him to be released.

The sight and the sound showed the power behind their words, and watching impressed me deeply with the strength of these men's demand for Muntather's release.

Also at Al-Anbar University, hundreds of students marched out of classes and into the streets calling for the release of "Muntather Al-Iraqi". American forces tried to stop them by shooting into the air. The students stopped in front of them and began throwing stones at the soldiers.

Muntather's family organized a sit-in in front of one gate of the Green Zone in Baghdad, and many Iraqis have joined them. A few members of the Iraqi Parliament were present as well. Iraqi security forces ended the sit-in using force, and they prevented Al-Baghdadiya, the television channel for which Al-Zaidi works, from documenting what happened there.

In London and Manchester, Iraqis living in Britain along with other British activists protested Muntather's incarceration and called for his immediate release.

Many news media are still providing updates and following the case, and many of these have been surprised by the way in which the Iraqi government is dealing with the situation. They cite similar cases in which eggs or tomatoes have been thrown as a form of protest, and none of these have been considered such a serious crime. They are asking why this one should be taken so much more seriously, especially since Muntather's actions enjoyed widespread public support and targeted a man responsible for what is widely understood as an ongoing illegal military occupation.

If you have not yet done so, please sign this petition demanding Muntather's release and forward this information to anyone you know who might be interested.

An Update about Muntather's court case:

The judge has rejected the defense's request to release Muntather on bail, refusing to change the way the case is classified under Iraqi law.

The leader of Munthather's Iraqi team of lawyers, Mr. Hashim Al-Futyan, was surprised by the government's decision to refer Muntather's case to be tried in the criminal court that Ambassador Paul Bremer established at the beginning of the occupation in 2003.

Regarding what the defense was seeking, but did not achieve:

They wanted to change the legal classification of Muntather's case to be considered under law no. 227, which would mean it would be considered in the misdemeanor court instead of the higher criminal court. Their next step is to appeal the case based on the belief that the government is discriminating against Muntather for political reasons.

The Iraqi Federation of Lawyers said that what Muntather did reflects the deep frustration resulting from the abuse of Iraq citizens during the US occupation of Iraq during the past years, a time in which journalists have been and continue to be among the professions which have been most targeted and persecuted.

According to the Committee to Protect Journalists, 136 journalists and 51 media workers have been killed in Iraq since 2003, making it the deadliest conflict for the press in recent history.

Muntather's brother has stated that the family believes the letter allegedly written by Muntather to Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki asking for a pardon and apologizing for his "big and ugly act" is either an outright forgery or was coerced by torture.

Regarding the fate of the shoes:

The government investigators claim that they tried to find out if there was a weapon hidden in Muntather's shoes. In the process of this "investigation", they claim, both shoes were cut into pieces.
So the material evidence is gone - and with it two powerful symbols - but the court case continues.


Regarding Muntather's health condition:

After Muntather was tortured he was taken to an American hospital - originally an Iraqi hospital now occupied by American forces - and treated there. He has many injuries, one of them related to trauma he suffered when he was struck many times on his eye while in the custody of Iraqi security forces.

In other related events:

In Iraq, protests continue, and many Iraqi groups from across the society continue to call for Munthather's release.

An Egyptian man has offered his daughter (who is currenty a college student) in marriage to Muntather (with his daughter's permission), and has offered to cover all marriage expenses.

In Amman, Jordan, a comedy based on the shoe-throwing incident will be presented beginning on December 21.

Najlaa Al-Nashi is Direct Aid Iraq's Middle East Coordinator, organizing medical care and advocating for her fellow Iraqi refugees in Amman, Jordan.

Share:

"This is for the widows and orphans and all those killed in Iraq!"

Click the Link Here and Sign-up to support Muntadar al-Zaidi! Your signatures will be delivered to the Iraqi Embassy this week!

It reads:

We, the undersigned, understand and sympathize with the sentiment expressed in the action of Iraqi journalist Muntadar al-Zaidi, who hurled his shoes at President Bush, shouting, "This is for the widows and orphans and all those killed in Iraq." We, too, feel for the widows and orphans and all those killed in Iraq, thanks to the policies of the Bush administration.

It's outrageous that al-Zaidi could get two years in prison for insulting George Bush, who is directly responsible
for the deaths of 1.5 million Iraqis and 4,200 U.S. troops, and for the displacement of 5 million Iraqis. The one who should be in jail is Bush, not Muntadar al-Zaidi.

We call on the Iraqi government to immediately release al-Zaidi without charges.
View our press room for the DC "shoe" actions
Share:

Zaidi shoes destroyed after Bush attack

Security agents, looking for explosives, have destroyed the shoes which Iraqi journalist Muntadhar al-Zaidi hurled at outgoing US President.

"The shoes were examined by the Iraqi and American security services and then destroyed," the investigating judge, Dhiya al-Kenani, told AFP on Thursday.

The judge meanwhile stated that lack of the valuable piece of evidence in the case - Zaidi's shoes - would not place obstacles in the way of investigation proceedings.

"I would have preferred to have had the shoes as evidence for the case but since Muntadhar al-Zaidi has confessed to his action and that the television pictures confirm it, the investigation can continue," he said.

Under Iraqi law, the journalist could face between five and 15 years behind bars if found guilty of 'aggression against a foreign head of state during an official visit.'

Zaidi grabbed the world spotlight after he threw both of his shoes at Bush while the US president and Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki were holding a news conference Sunday after Bush's surprise visit to Baghdad.

Relatives and colleagues have said Muntadhar did the act because he 'detested' Bush and America.


Share:

Tumult in Iraqi Parliament Over Shoe

A session of the Iraqi Parliament erupted in an uproar on Wednesday as lawmakers clashed over how to respond to the continuing detention of an Iraqi television reporter who threw his shoes at President Bush during a Baghdad news conference earlier this week, people attending the parliamentary meeting said.As Parliament began to discuss legislation on the withdrawal from Iraq of armed forces from nations other than the United States, a group of lawmakers demanded that the legislature instead take up the issue of the detained journalist, Muntader al-Zaidi, 29. After his shoes narrowly missed Mr. Bush’s head at the news conference on Sunday, Mr. Zaidi was subdued by a fellow journalist and then beaten by members of the prime minister’s security detail.

The legislative session became so tumultuous that it prompted the speaker of Parliament, Mahmoud al-Mashhadani, to announce his resignation, according to The Associated Press. A spokesman for Mr. Mashhadani, Jabar al-Mashhadani, refused to confirm whether the speaker had tendered his resignation, although he would not deny it. Some in Parliament say the government should release Mr. Zaidi immediately, while others say the judiciary should decide his fate.

How badly injured Mr. Zaidi was by members of Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki’s security detail is not clear. He has not appeared in public since his arrest, and his family members and his legal representatives say they have not been permitted to visit him. On Wednesday, Mr. Zaidi was scheduled to appear before a judge, but it was unclear whether that happened.

Dhiya al-Saadi, one of Mr. Zaidi’s lawyers, said Wednesday that he was not sure whether Mr. Zaidi had appeared before a judge. As part of the Iraqi legal system, a judge typically determines whether bringing formal charges against a suspect is warranted, criminal lawyers in Iraq said. Mr. Zaidi faces up to seven years in prison if he is charged with and convicted of offending the head of a foreign state


Share:

Muntadhar al-Zaidi captures Mideast rage at Bush

By Alistair Lyon, Special Correspondent

The hurling of shoes at U.S. President George W. Bush on his farewell visit to Iraq strikes many in the Middle East as a fittingly furious comment on what they see as his calamitous legacy in the region.Iraqi shoe-thrower captures Mideast rage at Bush

The brother of Muntazer al-Zaidi, a TV reporter from al-Baghdadiya who threw his shoes at U.S. President George W. Bush, displays his picture during an interview with Reuters in his apartment in Baghdad December 15, 2008. (REUTERS/Atef Hassan)

Arab and Iranian TV stations have gleefully replayed the clip, sometimes in slow motion, of an Iraqi reporter calling Bush a "dog" and throwing his shoes at him -- the Middle East's tastiest insults -- at a Baghdad news conference on Sunday.

The affront was a twisted echo of the triumphal moment for Bush when joyous Iraqis used their footwear to beat a statue of Saddam Hussein toppled by U.S. invading troops in 2003.

"It indicates how much antagonism he's been able to create in the whole region," former Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Maher told Reuters, adding that the incident was regrettable.

Bush had harmed America's reputation and the friendship many had felt for it. "Despite past mistakes in its policies, there was always a redeeming factor. In this particular case, there doesn't seem to have ever been a redeeming factor," Maher said.

Muntazer al-Zaidi, who works for independent al-Baghdadiya television, has shot to local stardom for his attack on Bush and his cry: "This is a goodbye kiss from the Iraqi people, dog."

He has also won instant fame abroad -- a poem on an Islamist website praises him as "a hero with a lion's heart" -- although the Iraqi government slated his "barbaric and ignominious act".

Zaidi's crude public display of disdain for an incumbent U.S. president hit a chord with many in the Middle East.

"The Iraqi journalist is a true and free Baghdadi," said a Saudi private sector employee who gave his name as Abu Faisal. "He was brave and did us proud. Bush destroyed (Iraq) so surely he deserved to be beaten with a shoe".

Khalid al-Dakhil, a Saudi university lecturer in social politics, said the incident summed up Bush's impact on the Middle East, which "will haunt this region for a long time".

Dakhil, who said Bush had committed war crimes in Iraq after launching a war based on "lies" that Saddam possessed weapons of mass destruction, nevertheless fretted about the shoe-throwing.

"While understandable, it wasn't the most sophisticated and constructive way to express one's anger at Bush, especially coming from an educated Arab journalist. It reinforces the stereotype ideas in the Western world about Arabs."

Some Palestinians, whose hopes of independent statehood have withered in the eight-year Bush era, relished the moment.

"A shoe company in Hebron claimed the attack on Bush and they will give the attacker shoes all his life," runs one joke being exchanged on mobile telephones in the Gaza Strip.

"LEGACY OF DISGRACE"

In Iran, under U.S. pressure over its nuclear programme, ordinary people had no good words for the outgoing president.

"He left a legacy of disgrace for America. His name will certainly go down in history and be remembered for all bad things for ever," said pensioner Assadollah Ghorbani, 67.

Parviz Alousi, 59, a former Iranian industry ministry employee, said the Bush had only created problems for the world, which "because of his ego" he had sought to dominate.

Some political analysts in Lebanon took an equally scathing view of Bush's policy record in the region.

"To say disaster is an under-statement. The best thing he can do is exit the White House," said Hilal Khashan, political science professor at the American University of Beirut. "I can't remember a lower point in U.S. prestige abroad."

Arabs have long fumed at American support for Israel in its conflict with the Palestinians, but Bush's war in Iraq created a new source of anger and instability in the Middle East.

"It's a sore, open and bleeding wound, just as the Palestine issue is," said Amal Saad-Ghorayeb, an expert on Hezbollah.

The Iraqi shoe-thrower had found a far more telling protest than raising a banner or poster showing war victims, she argued.

"It's a sign of empowerment. He was saying not only that your (Bush's) legacy is one of disgrace, not only do we see you as lowly, but that we can overpower and defeat you."

Mohammed al-Masri, a researcher at Jordan University's Centre for Strategic Studies, saw the vignette as iconic.

"Arabs will always remember the shoes hurled at Bush as symbolising their deep frustration with his failed policies."

The insult to Bush also embarrassed Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, who was standing beside him at the time.

They were marking the recent passage of a security pact that calls for U.S. troops to withdraw from Iraq by the end of 2011 -- a major challenge awaiting President-elect Barack Obama.


Many in the Middle East are pinning hopes on the next U.S. president, despite past disappointments.

"Any change appears welcome because we had reached the bottom," said Maher, Egypt's former foreign minister.


(Additional reporting by Souhail Karam in Riyadh, Hossein Jaseb in Tehran, Aziz El-Kaissouni in Cairo, Suleiman al-Khalidi in Amman and Inal Ersan in Dubai; Editing by Samia Nakhoul)


Share:

Bush shoe-thrower in hospital after beating: brother



The Iraqi journalist who hurled shoes at US President George W. Bush is in hospital after being beaten up by security guards, his brother charged on Tuesday, as judicial authorities launched a probe into the incident that grabbed headlines around the world.

"He has been taken to Ibn Sina hospital because he has a broken arm and ribs and is also suffering injuries to his eye and leg," Durgham al-Zaidi said of his brother Muntazer.

The 29-year-old Muntazer al-Zaidi became an instant star in the Arab world when he threw his shoes at Bush on Sunday during the US leader's farewell visit to the country invaded by American forces in 2003.

Zaidi, a journalist for private Iraqi television channel Al-Baghdadia, was swiftly overpowered by Iraqi security forces after his action, regarded as the supreme mark of disrespect in the Muslim world.

His brother charged that Zaidi had been beaten by Iraqi security guards but was unable to say whether Muntazer had sustained the injuries while being overpowered during Sunday's protest or while in custody.

He said he had been told that his brother was initially held by Iraqi forces in the Green Zone where the US embassy and most government offices are housed. The Ibn Sina hospital, which is run by American military medical services, is also inside the zone.

An AFP journalist said blood was visible on the ground as he was led away into custody on Sunday although it was unclear if it was his.

"Muntazer al-Zaidi has been transferred to the judicial authorities who have opened an investigation. But it is too soon to say who was behind this act," General Qassem Atta, spokesman for a Baghdad security plan, told AFP.

Bush, who was on a swansong visit to the battleground that came to dominate his eight-year presidency, ducked when the shoes were thrown and later made light of the incident.

Zaidi's action won him widespread plaudits in the Arab world where Bush's policies have drawn broad hostility, although Iraqi reaction was mixed.

In parliament, Baha al-Araji, an MP with the Shiite movement headed by radical anti-American cleric Moqtada al-Sadr, demanded an inquiry into the "brutality" of the security guards.

But Sami al-Askari, a Shiite lawmaker close to Prime Minsiter Nuri al-Maliki, lashed out at Zaidi for what he branded a "shameful act which sullies the reputation of the media."

An Iraqi lawyer said Zaidi risks a minimum of two years in prison if he is successfully prosecuted for insulting a visiting head of state.

In Gaza, around 20 Palestinian gunmen from the Popular Resistance Committees, a hardline militant group behind a spate of rocket attacks on Israel in recent weeks, staged a demonstration in support of Zaidi.

Wearing fatigues and brandishing Kalashnikov assault rifles, they stamped on photographs of the US president and held banners in support of the journalist.

In Iraq, press comment was divided.

The pro-government Al-Sabah expressed concern about the potential impact on press freedom of what it called Zaidi's "abnormal individual behaviour."

But the independent Al-Dustur hailed the journalist as the "only Iraqi whose patriotic feelings made him express his opinion in this way."

"It is not a declaration by the Iraqi media only, but for all Iraqis who have suffered over the years and we demand that he not be handed over to US forces," the paper said.

Lebanese television channel NTV, known for its opposition to Washington, went as far as offering a job to the journalist, saying he would be paid "from the moment the first shoe was thrown".

"Pelting the American president with shoes was the best way for expressing what Iraqis and Arabs feel toward Bush," wrote the editor of Egypt's government owned Al-Gomhuria newspaper.



Share:

THE SHOE LORE

YESTERDAY WE WERE OVER 1 000, AND NOW OVER 5 000!

PLEASE SIGN.



Free Muntather al-Zaidi - The 50,000 Signatures Campaign for
Muntather al-Zaidi

http://windowintopalestine.blogspot.com

/2008/12/free-muntather-al-zaidi_18.html

"Iraqi reporter al-Zaidi's arm, ribs broken"

Iraqi reporter Muntadhar al-Zaidi threw his shoes at Bush.
Security agents have broken the arm and ribs of al-Zaidi, a reporter who hurled his shoes at Bush during a press conference Sunday in Baghdad.

"He has got a broken arm and ribs, and cuts to his eye and arm," the reporter's brother Durgham told AFP on Tuesday.

"He is being held by forces under the command of Muaffaq al-Rubaie," he added.

According to Durgham, his brother was being held by Iraqi forces in the heavily fortified Green Zone compound in central Baghdad.

On Monday, thousands of Iraqis staged a demonstration in Sadr City in Baghdad calling for the release of the journalist.
Bush ducks a shoe attack by the reporter on Sunday.

The 29-year-old Muntadhar al-Zaidi, a correspondent for al-Baghdadiya satellite channel, threw his shoes at the US President George W. Bush during a press conference on Sunday, shouting "This is a goodbye kiss from the Iraqi people, dog!"

Bush inked an interim security agreement with Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki during his farewell visit to Baghdad in a bid to extend the presence of US troops in the war-ravaged country.


America: We were unable to give President [sic] Bush the boot, but we *can* give him the shoe!


"This is a farewell kiss, you dog!"

It is time to carpet the lawn of the White House and carpet both the lawns of Bush's new homes. What better way to stand in solidarity with Iraqi television journalist Muntadar al-Zaidi?

Send virtual shoes, too! A CLG reader wrote, 'I urge everyone around the world who thinks it appropriate to email George Bush at president@whitehouse.gov a picture of a shoe.'

Contacting the White House

The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500

10151/10141 Daria Place
Dallas, TX 75229

Share:

Broken bones 4 throwing shoes: Join The Call To Release Muntadar al-Zaidi

Please circulate this message as widely as possible.

You can join the growing international call for the release of al-Zaidi! Click here to sign a petition:
http://www.iraqsnuclearmirage.com/articles/Zaydi.html

By now, you've all seen the footage of the Iraqi journalist hurling his shoes at George W. Bush during a press conference in Baghdad this past Sunday. Click here to see a YouTube video of the event.

What has not been so widely reported are the words Muntadar al-Zaidi, a correspondent for Cairo-based al-Baghdadiya TV, shouted out. As the first shoe was thrown at Bus
h, he said: "This is a goodbye kiss from the Iraqi people, you dog." And with his second shoe, which the president also dodged, al-Zaidi said: "This is for the widows and orphans and all those killed in Iraq."

This bold statement also has to be understood in its cultural context. Showing the soles of your shoes to someone, let alone tossing your shoes at them, is a sign of contempt in Arab culture.

After throwing his shoes, al-Zaidi was wrestled to the ground by security personnel and hauled away. According to Democracy Now! this morning, "Muntadar al-Zaidi has been held without charge for over twenty-four hours and has been reportedly beaten in jail. His brother said al-Zaidi has suffered a broken hand, broken ribs and internal bleeding, as well as an eye injury. Earlier today, al-Zaidi was handed over to the Iraqi military command in Baghdad."

We urge you to join the growing international call for the release of al-Zaidi! Click here to sign a petition:
http://www.iraqsnuclearmirage.com/articles/Zaydi.html

Help us continue to do this critical work: Make a donation to UFPJ today.

UNITED FOR PEACE AND JUSTICE
www.unitedforpeace.org | 212-868-5545
PO Box 607; Times Square Station; New York, NY 10108

To subscribe, visit www.unitedforpeace.org/email

Share:

Free Bush shoe-thrower, Iraqis urge



The two shoes narrowly missed the US president as he gave a news conference in Baghdad

Thousands of Iraqis have demonstrated in Baghdad's Sadr City in support of a journalist being held in custody after throwing his shoes at George Bush, the US president.

Muntazer al-Zeidi was detained for what the Iraqi government on Monday said was a "barbaric and ignominious act" during a news conference the previous day.

The outgoing US leader, who was making a surprise visit to Baghdad, had just told reporters that while the war in Iraq was not over "it is decisively on its way to being won," when al-Zeidi got to his feet and hurled abuse - and his footwear - at Bush.

Bush, who had been giving a joint press statement with Nuri al-Maliki, the Iraqi prime minister, ducked behind a podium as the shoes narrowly missed his head.

"Millions of Iraqis or rather millions of the people of the world wish to do what Muntadhar did," Uday al-Zeidi, Mundathar's brother, said on Monday.

"Thank God he had the guts to do it and avenge the Iraqi people and the country from those who plunder it and have killed its people."

Al-Baghdadiya television, his employer, has demanded his release after Yasin Majeed, the prime minister's media adviser, said al-Zeidi would be tried on charges of insulting the state.

An Iraqi lawyer told the AFP news agency that Zeidi risked a miminum of two years in prison if he is prosecuted for insulting a visiting head of state.

Freedom of expression

On Monday, al-Baghdadiya suspended its normal programming and played messages of support from across the Arab world.

A presenter read out a statement calling for his release, "in accordance with the democratic era and the freedom of expression that Iraqis were promised by US authorities".

Iraqis have hailed
Zeidi's actions [AFP]
It said that any harsh measures taken against the reporter would be reminders of the "dictatorial era" that Washington said its forces had invaded Iraq to end.

Demonstrations also took place in the southern city of Basra and Najaf, where some people threw shoes at a US convoy.

Khalil al-Dulaimi, Saddam Hussein's former lawyer, said he was forming a team to defend al-Zeidi and that around 200 lawyers, including Americans, had offered their services for free.

"It was the least thing for an Iraqi to do to Bush, the tyrant criminal who has killed two million people in Iraq and Afghanistan," he said.

"Our defence of Zeidi will be based on the fact that the United States is occupying Iraq, and resistance is legitimate by all means, including shoes."

In Iraqi culture, throwing shoes at someone is a sign of contempt and the incident is likely to serve as a lasting reminder of the widespread opposition to the US-led invasion of Iraq - the conflict which has come to define Bush's presidency.

"Throwing the shoes at Bush was the best goodbye kiss ever ... it expresses how Iraqis and other Arabs hate Bush," Musa Barhoumeh, editor of Jordan's independent Al-Gahd newspaper, wrote.

But support has not been entirely universal and some Iraqis believe al-Zeidi crossed the line.

"I deem it unnecessary. This thing is unjustifiable. It is an incorrect style. We are not violent. One can voice his opinion in other ways," one Baghdad resident said.

Robert Wood, a US state department spokesman, dismissed the incident saying that al-Zeidi was "trying to get attention for himself" and had ignored Washington's successes in Iraq.

"This was one incident and one individual's views, but if you look at the direction we are heading in Iraq now, it's a very, very positive direction and we hope to see that continue," he said.

Bush's visit to the Iraqi capital came just 37 days before he hands the presidency over to Barack Obama, who has vowed to withdraw troops from Iraq.


Share:

Iraq’s farewell to George W. Bush

Paul J. Balles

Paul views the cultural significance of Iraqi journalist Muntather Al-Zaidi’s hurling of shoes at George W. Bush at a news conference in Baghdad.

By now, everyone has seen the spectacle of George W. Bush ducking shoes thrown at him in Iraq. Muntather al-Zaidi, a 28 years old journalist, stood up and threw not one but two shoes at Bush.By Paul J. Balles

While throwing his shoes, Muntather shouted at the top of his voice "Ya kalb" (you dog), which is just about as insulting as one can get in Arabic. Not that Arabs don't like dogs, but to reduce a man to a dog is about as low as a put-down goes.

To make matters worse, Muntather not only threw an insult that would be hard to ignore at a press conference, he threw shoes. Throwing shoes in the Arab world differs from throwing them in the West. In the West, a pair of shoes coming at you would be only slightly more hazardous than a couple of ripe tomatoes.

According to Wikipedia,

In the Arab world, shoe flinging is a gesture of extreme disrespect. A notable occurrence of this gesture happened in Baghdad, Iraq in 2003. When US forces pulled down a giant statue of Saddam Hussein during the 2003 invasion of Iraq, many Iraqi detractors of Hussein threw their shoes at the fallen statue.

One of the first traditional items I learned after arriving in the Middle East was that displaying or throwing a shoe at someone or something in Arab cultures denotes that the person or thing is "beneath them".

Showing the bottom of one's feet or shoes (for example, putting one's feet up on a table or desk) in Arab cultures is considered an extreme insult. I once watched the shocked looks on Arab faces walking into an office where an unlearned American PhD sat at a desk facing the door with his feet atop the desk, with the soles facing anyone who walked through the door.

Bush dismissed the act that Iraqi officials considered "shameful". He must have felt a certain amount of satisfaction at having ducked the footwear missiles. He has never demonstrated a broad cultural familiarity beyond Texas pride and White House arrogance.

It has always been interesting to me that the insults from one culture may have little effect in another. Shortly after my arrival in my first Arab country, I pulled ahead of an empty parking space getting ready to back my car into it. Much to my dismay, another car pulled head first into the space. I swore at the driver in English. He laughed.

As soon as possible, I learned how to express my dismay in Arabic. The next time someone pulled a similar trick, I responded with a close Arabic equivalent -- Ibn kalb (son of a dog) -- to Muntather’s insult. It worked.

Muntather is being held by Iraqi security. The Associated Press reported that he is being questioned as to whether he was paid by someone to throw his shoes and is being tested for drugs and alcohol. His shoes are being held as evidence.

Thousands of Iraqis gathered in Baghdad's Sadr City demanding Muntather's release. The TV station that employs him, Al-Baghdadiya, also called for his release. They said he was exercising his freedom of expression. There's a delicious irony in that since Bush has attempted to justify the occupation of Iraq as bringing democracy to the people.

As he threw his shoes, he shouted in Arabic, "This is a farewell kiss, you dog. This is from the widows, the orphans and those who were killed in Iraq." There's little doubt that Iraq’s widows and orphans will celebrate Muntather as a hero.


Share:

A SHOE that made the headlines worldwide... Our Newsmaker of the Year

Muntadhar al-Zaidi has made history, he has done something that most can only dream about...God bless him! He has spoke his mind and used actions to back it up. Too bad the shoe missed because George Bush & Company needs a wake up call, along with the International World Court bringing him to trial for all his crimes against humanity.

Muntadhar al-Zaidi has a voice that can not be silenced along with actions to back it up and after hearing the bullshit that comes from leaders around the world concerning the holocaust happening in Gaza they can learn a thing or two from Muntadhar al-Zaidi and this is why Muntadhar al-Zaidi is not only News Maker of the Year but has made history big time!



Share: