Friday, December 30

Write For Palestine

WRITE! for Justice, Human Rights, and International Law in Palestine

On December 26th, the Chicago Sun-Times published an extremely biased op-ed by staff writer and editorial board member Steve Huntley, 'Palestinian State Would Expel Jews,' (12/26) which turns the history of the conflict upside down, dismisses ongoing events on the ground, and expresses sympathy solely with the plight of Israeli settlers.

In a meeting with the Chicago Sun-Times editorial board, the Palestinian Ambassador Maen Rashid Areikat allegedly rejected the idea that Israeli settlers would have the option of remaining in a future Palestinian state -- and this response provides the basis for the op-ed's title and the rest of Huntley's inflammatory argument that the PLO is effectively endorsing ethnic cleansing. In short, Huntley's argument is without merit because under international law, an occupying power is prohibited from transferring its population into occupied territory - regardless of the race or religion of those transferred. Virtually every country, human rights organization, the International Committee for the Red Cross, the International Court of Justice, and UN Security Council has determined settlements to be illegal under international law.

In addition, Huntley inaccurately refers to Israeli settlements as 'communites' and uses the term 'disputed West Bank territories.' He solely blames Palestinians for the persistence of the conflict 'given the history of Palestinian intransigence.' And worst of all, Huntley seems wholly ignorant of what is actually happening on the ground today with the problems caused by settlers/settlements, the permanent displacement of Palestinians in East Jerusalem, home demolitions, the restriction of movement, the expropriation of Palestinian natural resources, the siege of Gaza, etc. -- instead his outrage is reserved for some hypothetical arrangement in the future which may never even take place.

Please WRITE! your letter to the Chicago Sun Times at . It is important that we do not let this biased column from a member of the editorial board pass without a significant response. Letters should be kept under 200 words and be sure to include your name, address, and phone number for verification purposes.

For further information:


Palestinian state would expel Jews

STEVE HUNTLEY December 26, 2011 9:48PM

Buried in news stories about the conviction on a former president of Israel on rape charges was a telling insight into the Jewish state: The three-judge panel that convicted Moshe Katsav and the three-judge tribunal that rejected his appeal each had a justice who is an Israeli Arab.

Arabs make up 20 percent of the population of Israel, and, as the Katsav story indicates, they are able to play prominent roles in the country’s governmental life, including service in the Knesset.

Hundreds of thousands of Jews live in communities in the disputed West Bank territories. To Israelis, the West Bank is known as Judea and Samaria, reflecting its crucial role in the ancient and modern history of the Jewish people. If a peace settlement is ever reached — a big if given the history of Palestinian intransigence — could some Jews living in the West Bank choose to opt to remain and pursue their lives under a new Palestinian state?

No, according to Maen Rashid Areikat, the representative of the Palestinian Liberation Organization to the United States. In a recent meeting with the Chicago Sun-Times editorial board, he condemned the Jewish residents of the West Bank — he put the number at 550,000 — as unlawful settlers and declared that all of them must leave as part of any Israeli-Palestinian settlement.

Areikat did acknowledge that a settlement would involve “minor” land swaps that could incorporate some of the communities in Israel. And he did say that at some point in the future, Jews might live in a new Palestinian state.

But a settlement would require Jews living in the Palestinian-governed West Bank to leave. In other words, a peace deal will be followed by ethnic cleansing of the West Bank, where Jewish history is measured in millennia and where Jews had lived before being expelled in the Arab world’s 1948 war to destroy Israel. An Israeli victory in the 1967 war returned Jews to Judea and Samaria, and to eastern Jerusalem where they could again pray at the Western Wall, forbidden by Jordan during the Arab occupation after 1948.

Areikat painted a glowing picture of the Palestinian Authority, which governs the West Bank, as accepting Israel’s right to exist. After he several times insisted the Palestinian Authority, as opposed to Hamas, the terrorists ruling the Gaza Strip, had accepted Israel, I referred to him a recent article in the Palestinian Authority newspaper by the authority’s ambassador to India. Adli Sadeq wrote that Israelis “have a common mistake, or misconception by which they fool themselves, assuming that Fatah [the PLO’s main political party] accepts them and recognizes the right of their state to exist, and that it is Hamas alone that loathes them and does not recognize the right of this state to exist.”

The translation came from the Palestinian Media Watch. Areikat made vague comments about the ambassador’s writing, dismissed PMW founder Itamar Marcus as a biased settler, and offered to provide extreme statements from Israelis. Suggesting a mistranslation, he said he would get back to me about the article. It’s been several weeks, I haven’t heard from him.

Areikat made other suspect statements. He said the source of Israeli distrust of the Palestinians was not decades of Palestinian terrorism but the history of Western anti-Semitism. He said the “golden age” of Jews in the Holy Land was the medieval time of Islamic rule under Saladin. I think Jews might cite the time of King David or another Biblical era in their history.

Steve Huntley is a commentary columnist for the Chicago Sun-Times and a member of its editorial board.

To join our mailing list, please contact us at

Thank you,


The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this Blog!

0 Have Your Say!:

Post a Comment